Should i kill orbeck of vinheim?

[76561198100970030]

The dark lady yuria kept telling me to kill the guy. then i progressed a little bit over after the abyss boss place. now she tells me something different. about a potential spouse or whatnot.
since she's not talking about me murdering orbeck anymore. should i still kill him? not like i really use magic or anything.

[cautr]

I don't think it changes anything about the questline, but I always wondered what she'd say.

[Yeshalot]

Originally posted by Z3:

The dark lady yuria kept telling me to kill the guy. then i progressed a little bit over after the abyss boss place. now she tells me something different. about a potential spouse or whatnot.
since she's not talking about me murdering orbeck anymore. should i still kill him? not like i really use magic or anything.

the quest will break after you complete the marriage ceramony. she won't care about killing him.
make sure you go get all the scrolls and buy all the spells from him first, then kill him, turn in his ashes. then go do your wedding if you want to get the most out of it.

[Nastumi]

If you're not sure about killing him, you can give him the 4 scrolls, and once you bought all the magics, he'll leave for the great library (you'll find his corpse after you killed the twins). Trade Yuria the ashes, and she'll be pleased, and trade you a sword. Or you can just murder him once you got what you need, his dead already, so he won't mind much :)
There is no time limit for killing Orbeck, so it's up to you.

@Yashalot : Traded the ahses just before going for Souls of Cinder, and I still got the sword, so I don't think the wedding change anything (and yup, I went for the wedding on the same run)

[76561198100970030]

Originally posted by Yeshalot:

the quest will break after you complete the marriage ceramony. she won't care about killing him.
make sure you go get all the scrolls and buy all the spells from him first, then kill him, turn in his ashes. then go do your wedding if you want to get the most out of it.

Sounds like a plan. i do need those spells for achievements. even though i won't be able to use any of them except maybe the starter ones. as a str knight with 10 intelligence. i could atleast use the magic weapon one. gives like maybe 10 - 20 extra damage with the starter staff.