Proper Bow + Silvercat Ring in the same playthrough?

[seraphim]

Is it possible to somehow get both the Proper Bow gesture and the Silvercat Ring in the same playthrough? From what I can tell, it can't be done.

To get the Silvercat Ring, I have to help Sirris out at the Irithyll bridge, and to get there, I have to defeat the Abyss Watchers. However, by defeating them, Yellowfinger Heysel is turned into one of those worm thingies in Rosaria's chamber, making the summon sign near Keep Ruins disappear.
If I try to do it in the other order and aim for summoning Yellowfinger Heysel first, then I have to join Rosaria's Fingers to turn in a Pale Tongue, which in turn will make Sirris hostile.

I already managed to miss both Proper Bow and Silvercat Ring in my first playthrough and was hoping to get them in NG+, but if it's not possible to get them both, I guess I'll have to wait until NG++ for one of 'em.

[Voru]

I thought the same, and missed both on first NG... But I know I'm going to do NG++ anyway for all the +2 rings, so I just went ahead and decided on one per.

[Lucathegreat]

Wondering the same, I guess you can't.

[Rogue]

nope

[seraphim]

I just went ahead and did the Sirris stuff, and I'll pick up Proper Bow in NG++.

[Jpmd3000]

Same problem here. I'm planning on asking a friend to trade the silvercat ring to me temporarily, just to unlock the trophy. That way I can just focus on unlocking the gesture. I missed both in ng and ng+ which means I need to go into a 4th play through to unlock all trophies.

[jay jay the dank planezinho]

nope. the silvercat ring is more important and you can get the bow gesture in NG+, i guess. stupid sirris. she's such a scrub. summons phantom to defeat invaders, uses estoc, buffs the estoc... and as you can see, her build is awful. she does no damage.

i think sirris represents the scrub player.

[ImHelping]

Yeah, the bow is nice but the Silvercat is Way, WAY more important. Especially if you can't spare the stats, or even just the spell slot to cast Spook without it.

On that note, I can't imagine any playthrough without at least 10/10/10 Att/Int/Faith minimum. SO useful for making PvE that much easier. "Let's see, I can cast spook, Heal Aid, Fire orb, Carthus Flame arc-"

[Agent Orange]

Originally posted by Rogue:

nope

Originally posted by WithFieryTruth:

I just went ahead and did the Sirris stuff, and I'll pick up Proper Bow in NG++.

[Reoden]

Prety sure they're mutually exclusive m8. The bow requires you to give Rosaria a finger (har har), and doing so will cause Sirris to have a hissy fit.

[Shepard]

♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥, that sucks lol. Im going for the platinum now and had the same question...a shame i have to do a ng+++ just to get the ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ gesture