I killed Patches. How do I get Seigward's armor now?

[Setharim]

Seigward's quest in the well outside the Cathedral triggered after I killed Patches, but now I can't buy Seigward's armor from him. I tried giving his ashes to the handmaid but she doesn't sell it either.
Did I mess it up irreversably?

[That Cryptid Kira]

He didn't drop it? He dropped it when I murdered him

[Drake Ravenwolf]

Afaik he has to have it for sale for him to drop it, if you killed him before that point then... ya you may have messed up until NG+

[puzzlefox]

Spoiler alert:

It's a better idea to leave patches alive. If he still has the catarina armor when grierat goes on his second mission, you can inform patches of grierat's whereabouts and patches will save him. Sieg can save him too, but it's not nearly as easy. Then after you beat pontiff and patches/grierat return, you can buy the catarina armor from patches and go save sieg, and he will still spawn in the kitchen even after pontiff dies. It's the easiest way to do both stories.

[That Cryptid Kira]

Originally posted by puzzlefox (DS3 on PS4):

Spoiler alert:

It's a better idea to leave patches alive. If he still has the catarina armor when grierat goes on his second mission, you can inform patches of grierat's whereabouts and patches will save him. Sieg can save him too, but it's not nearly as easy. Then after you beat pontiff and patches/grierat return, you can buy the catarina armor from patches and go save sieg, and he will still spawn in the kitchen even after pontiff dies. It's the easiest way to do both stories.

While I admit that you're right, I ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ hate Patches so it was worth it to me

[CHAO$$$]

just kill siegward the first time you meet him

makes everything easier

[That Cryptid Kira]

Originally posted by CHAO$$$:

just kill siegward the first time you meet him

makes everything easier

living up to that name, Chaos

[puzzlefox]

Originally posted by JoanOfSnark:

Originally posted by puzzlefox (DS3 on PS4):

Spoiler alert:

It's a better idea to leave patches alive. If he still has the catarina armor when grierat goes on his second mission, you can inform patches of grierat's whereabouts and patches will save him. Sieg can save him too, but it's not nearly as easy. Then after you beat pontiff and patches/grierat return, you can buy the catarina armor from patches and go save sieg, and he will still spawn in the kitchen even after pontiff dies. It's the easiest way to do both stories.

While I admit that you're right, I ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ hate Patches so it was worth it to me :praisesun:

I do too. It took a concentrated effort not to kill him. lol

though at this point, his treasonous bastard ways are endearing.

[Da Diver]

this ♥♥♥♥ won't leave the Cathedral (i think you need to buy something so he moves to shrine?) and i really didn't want to buy onion dude's armor+grayrat was out and i wana save him for his stuff... so i killed this ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥, he only droped his ash, i panicked! so i forced shutdown the game, when i got back i found his ring/shield/sword? on his corpse, then i did that again and found onion dude's set...

[juicy]

You killed patches?

That qualifies for a redo of that current playthrough.

[Eggsu]

Kill, patches. he's mean. he tricked me into saying, there is a treasure uphead :(, and he got me killed by big giants. ;/

[D.Sofren]

Originally posted by Da Diver:

this ♥♥♥♥ won't leave the Cathedral (i think you need to buy something so he moves to shrine?) and i really didn't want to buy onion dude's armor+grayrat was out and i wana save him for his stuff... so i killed this ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥, he only droped his ash, i panicked! so i forced shutdown the game, when i got back i found his ring/shield/sword? on his corpse, then i did that again and found onion dude's set...

♥♥♥♥♥♥♥' necro you just did there.

[Remedy]

B-but... how can you... hate... Patches?... He is in fact one of the best characters of the game...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qlNFnR3Invs

[puzzlefox]

Oh hey this thread again.

[Mephisto]

There are a lot of Necromancers going around, huh?

[Fuqwin]

I met patches when he trapped me in firelink and killed him immediately. I did not get Sigewalde's armor, but I found him in ithryl with the estus soup like he was never trapped.