question about horace and anri please!!! (spoilers about them)

[ZEEK (Trained Navy Seal)]

if i kill hoarace were you find him hostile in the catacombs, is it ok to tell anri what happen? or should i not tell her in order to conitune her questline?

please and thanks

[Gatsu]

Originally posted by UnbornCorpser:

Originally posted by Björn ou Ours:

If you don't kill the pilgrim using chameleon in the Church of Yorshka when Anri is there, she will end up on that pedestal, yes you have failed Anri's quest,

That's not failed it's another branch of their story. You can even retrieve their sword by quitting and reloading at that location (the pedestal).

Thats the part of the ''Usurpation of Fire'' ending not killing the assassin.

[Ǵ̶͓̂͑lí̴̤̀̄́tcĥ̸]

If you tell Anri about Horace, you cannot do Yuria's questline and finish the Usurpation of Fire ending (I think because she goes to Smouldering Lake to put a grave down for Horace, or die to him if you didn't kill him before telling her, so the assassin doesn't get her). Same with if you kill the assassin in the corner of the room.

If you are focused on Anri's quest, in the end it makes no difference if you tell her or not depending on whether or not you killed Horace. If you don't kill Horace, and tell her, she will go to Smouldering Lake where he will kill her and end the quest. If you don't kill Horace, and don't tell her (causing her to skip Smouldering Lake), you can finish her quest fine but I believe they both appear hollow at the Cathedral afterwards. If you do kill Horace, telling her doesn't change anything aside from where you fight her when she goes hollow after you finish her quest (Cathedral of the Deep if you didn't, or Smouldering Lake if you did), and if you did tell her she will also put a gravestone for him in Smouldering Lake, and that's it. Either way she succumbs to the fate of Hollowing, which was going to happen anyway (you'll see if you follow Yuria).

[Rezonus]

Originally posted by UnbornCorpser:

That's not failed it's another branch of their story. You can even retrieve their sword by quitting and reloading at that location (the pedestal).

Actually it is. Anri's questline is to help her kill Aldrich, the Church of Yorshka is the critical point, Yuria's quest needs you to keep the pilgrim alive, Anri's needs you to kill it.

[TheMetalCorpser]

Originally posted by Juni:

He had the cloth over his head, and the pligrim was dead after I left the room. Picked up the chameleon off her body.

If you quit the game and reload where Anri's body was their weapon should be there if you want it.

Originally posted by Gatsu:

Thats the part of the ''Usurpation of Fire'' ending not killing the assassin.

I am aware I do have the achievement for it.

Originally posted by Rezonus:

Actually it is. Anri's questline is to help her kill Aldrich, the Church of Yorshka is the critical point, Yuria's quest needs you to keep the pilgrim alive, Anri's needs you to kill it.

No it isn't it's literally another branch of Anri's story. One is to keep them away/alive from the statue pilgrim which eventually leads to their hollow/death anyways. The other is to allow the pilgrim to get Anri and prepare them for the Usurp ending which they are a key character for thus it is part of their possible story.

ie Just because Anri has another branch involving Aldrich doesn't mean the other route isn't part of another branch for her/him.

[DraxTemSklounts]

i killed horace and also yuria because i didn't want her to die. she gave me the white branch spell but i think i missed out on alot, i can absolve my sins at the absolution?

[TheMetalCorpser]

Originally posted by DraxTemSklounts:

i killed horace and also yuria because i didn't want her to die. she gave me the white branch spell but i think i missed out on alot, i can absolve my sins at the absolution?

You can but that is really only used for access to talk to NPCs again if you made them hostile.

Just so you know Anri dies no matter what if you save him/her. They eventually go hollow and you kill them.

[Proper Mug]

A tribute to "Anri of Astora".
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ksprg3q_NQg

[Darklight]

If you tell her about Horace after you kill him, she will make a nice statue for him on the arena :)