I'm about to return the Firekeeper soul

[The Black Baron]

I've just beaten Pontiff Sulyvahn is it too early to return the soul ? Since I'm going for the 4th ending.

[Dallagen]

if you want to usurp the fire you never give the soul to her

[Thor Odenson]

it would be more helpful to know which ending your going for

Endings

To link the first flame

The end of fire

Betray the keeper

Usurpation of the fire

[MundM]

Isn't that just to erase hollowing and the dark sigil? I think it doesn't matter if you give it to her or not, I gave it to her and still went for the hollow ending once.

[Mud]

Originally posted by MundM:

Isn't that just to erase hollowing and the dark sigil? I think it doesn't matter if you give it to her or not, I gave it to her and still went for the hollow ending once.

You need it for the second and third endings.

[The Black Baron]

Originally posted by Thor Odenson:

it would be more helpful to know which ending your going for

Endings

To link the first flame

The end of fire

Betray the keeper

Usurpation of the fire

I'm intending to do theUsurpation of the fire

[MortalitasBorealis]

Originally posted by Mud:

You need it for the second and third endings.

Firekeeper SOUL.
The soul is for healing the dark sigil, if you want to cancel hollowing permanently, but ruin Yuria's questline and the Ursurpation ending.
The End of Fire and Betraying the Firekeeper endings require the Firekeeper EYES, which you get from Dark Firelink after Champ Gundyr. It's two completely different things.

[Mud]

Originally posted by MortalitasBorealis:

Originally posted by Mud:

You need it for the second and third endings.

Firekeeper SOUL.
The soul is for healing the dark sigil, if you want to cancel hollowing permanently, but ruin Yuria's questline and the Ursurpation ending.
The End of Fire and Betraying the Firekeeper endings require the Firekeeper EYES, which you get from Dark Firelink after Champ Gundyr. It's two completely different things.

You are right. My bad.

[Rinera]

You should not return it till the actual end if you want that ending. I believe it only matters whether you heal your sigil or not, but you have no reason other than that to give it so just don't, to be safe.

[The Black Baron]

Originally posted by MortalitasBorealis:

Originally posted by Mud:

You need it for the second and third endings.

Firekeeper SOUL.
The soul is for healing the dark sigil, if you want to cancel hollowing permanently, but ruin Yuria's questline and the Ursurpation ending.
The End of Fire and Betraying the Firekeeper endings require the Firekeeper EYES, which you get from Dark Firelink after Champ Gundyr. It's two completely different things.

Thank you ^^ so I'm going to keep the soul since i already need to reach the pilgrim in Anor Londo to proceed the questline.

[Thor Odenson]

For that ending you can give her the soul any time, just can not cure the dark sigil(s). I am very sure you have to have sigils to do that ending

[Mohl]

The firekeeper soul is completely irrelevant to the endings.

[Fup My What?]

I've given her the soul every playthrough, as long as you dont give the Firekeeper the eyes or cure the sigil you should be fine