So Farron is Sif?

[gackie]

I was watching a lore video on the wolf of Farron and he claims it is Sif, he also puts some really compelling reasons behind this claim. But all in all I don't see how Sif returned from the dead.

[New]

And how his fur became black

[Rinera]

Or how the Wolf of Farron is like... a few time smaller than Sif. Only about the size of Sif's head.

Honestly, that's just silly. It's understandable that there is a Wolf there, seen as the Abyss Watchers are The Artorias Fanclub, but it doesn't have to be Sif... And that's totally NOT Sif.

[gackie]

Originally posted by Rinera:

Or how the Wolf of Farron is like... a few time smaller than Sif. Only about the size of Sif's head.

Honestly, that's just silly. It's understandable that there is a Wolf there, seen as the Abyss Watchers are The Artorias Fanclub, but it doesn't have to be Sif...

No there is absolutely a crap tonne of evidence pointing towards it. Go watch the video, it's by the Ashen Hollow.

[Rord64]

Farron is the area, not the name of the wolf.

[gackie]

Originally posted by Rord64:

Farron is the area, not the name of the wolf.

Farron can be taken as "guardian of the grave". I believe.

[Tokebec]

The ONLY lore video you should watch are Vaatividya ......

[Rinera]

Originally posted by Hat Skeleton!:

Originally posted by Rinera:

Or how the Wolf of Farron is like... a few time smaller than Sif. Only about the size of Sif's head.

Honestly, that's just silly. It's understandable that there is a Wolf there, seen as the Abyss Watchers are The Artorias Fanclub, but it doesn't have to be Sif...

No there is absolutely a crap tonne of evidence pointing towards it. Go watch the video, it's by the Ashen Hollow.

Tssh.. FINE.

[Corus]

He might possess Sif's soul. Definitely not him.

[Corinne]

Originally posted by Ozz3605:

The ONLY lore video you should watch are Vaatividya ......

[Rinera]

Originally posted by Hat Skeleton!:

Originally posted by Rinera:

Or how the Wolf of Farron is like... a few time smaller than Sif. Only about the size of Sif's head.

Honestly, that's just silly. It's understandable that there is a Wolf there, seen as the Abyss Watchers are The Artorias Fanclub, but it doesn't have to be Sif...

No there is absolutely a crap tonne of evidence pointing towards it. Go watch the video, it's by the Ashen Hollow.

I went and watched the video. Well, he pretty much told us what we know already, but I still don't agree with THAT wolf being Sif.

He repeatidly mentions that "there are no coincidences" in this game, but Sif just HAPPENED to shrink in size and leave the actual grave of Artorias in order to lock himself into a Tower? Can't this just be an "Altar", like the one down at the Mound-Makers? "How does he give you the shield and ring".... well... how does a pile of bones give you a sword?

[New]

Originally posted by Corus:

He might possess Sif's soul. Definitely not him.

Instead of inventing silly stories why not ipotize that sif is an ancestor of the wolf of farron?

[New]

Originally posted by Rinera:

Originally posted by Hat Skeleton!:

No there is absolutely a crap tonne of evidence pointing towards it. Go watch the video, it's by the Ashen Hollow.

I went and watched the video. Well, he pretty much told us what we know already, but I still don't agree with THAT wolf being Sif.

He repeatidly mentions that "there are no coincidences" in this game, but Sif just HAPPENED to shrink in size and leave the actual grave of Artorias in order to lock himself into a Tower? Can't this just be an "Altar", like the one down at the Mound-Makers? "How does he give you the shield and ring".... well... how does a pile of bones give you a sword?

1-He doesnt look like sif
2-Sif got killed by the chosen undead
3-Sif didn't possess ♥♥♥♥ of artorias.
*both his sword and shield (in "mint" conditions) are TRANSPOSED with the soul of sif, he did not drop them upon death. What happened to those "relics" after the end of ds1 is unknown.
*The wolf ring in ds1 was in a random spot in darkroot garden.

[Hunubul]

Originally posted by Ozz3605:

The ONLY lore video you should watch are Vaatividya ......

And DaveControl, he has some very good lore videos too. And TerraMantis. But these 3 are good friends anyway, so they al lare trustworthy when it comes to lore.

[Rinera]

Originally posted by Basileus:

Originally posted by Rinera:

I went and watched the video. Well, he pretty much told us what we know already, but I still don't agree with THAT wolf being Sif.

He repeatidly mentions that "there are no coincidences" in this game, but Sif just HAPPENED to shrink in size and leave the actual grave of Artorias in order to lock himself into a Tower? Can't this just be an "Altar", like the one down at the Mound-Makers? "How does he give you the shield and ring".... well... how does a pile of bones give you a sword?

1-He doesnt look like sif
2-Sif got killed by the chosen undead
3-Sif didn't possess ♥♥♥♥ of artorias.
*both his sword and shield (in "mint" conditions) are TRANSPOSED with the soul of sif, he did not drop them upon death. What happened to those "relics" after the end of ds1 is unknown.
*The wolf ring in ds1 was in a random spot in darkroot garden.

Yeap, pretty much.

Regarding 2 though... We don't really know what is and isn't canon from our actions in Dark Souls 1. Well, there are some obvious ones like the Chosen Undead being the first to take Gwyn's place and officially start the cycle, killing the 4 holders of Souls, but that's about it.

Is it mentioned in Dark Souls 3 that an unknown travel, unknown undead or the chosen undead killed Sif?

[foofighter_ii]

There is an item description (the sword that is given at the covenant while reaching level 1) that states that this wolf is a guardian of the area, but is not Sif. Sif is, sadly, gone.