Proof of Concord Well-Kept bugged?

[Vinyl Scratch]

So, I just got summoned as a Darkmoon Blade to the Grand Archives.
I killed the red invader for the host, and got a Concord Well-Kept.
But aren't you only supposed to get those from Aldrich Faithfuls?

...Though that brings me to my next question...I've never actually gotten ANYTHING from killing an Aldrich Faithful.

So what is the intended way to receive the Well-Kept concords, vs the Normal ones?

[Grad]

Darkmoon Blades and Blue Sentinals share covenant rewards and the Concords.
Aldritch Faithful get Dregs.
Rosaria's Fingers get Tongues.
Vertabros get Shackles.
Sunbros get Sunlight Medals.
Wolves get Swordgrass.

[Vinyl Scratch]

Originally posted by Creamy Goodness:

Darkmoon Blades and Blue Sentinals share covenant rewards and the Concords.
Aldritch Faithful get Dregs.
Rosaria's Fingers get Tongues.
Vertabros get Shackles.
Sunbros get Sunlight Medals.
Wolves get Swordgrass.

........that's not what I'm asking...at all...even a little bit.
I'm asking what the supposed parameter for getting a Proof of Concord Well-Kept vs Normal Concord supposed to be.

[Andrashimmortal]

Originally posted by Vinyl Scratch:

So, I just got summoned as a Darkmoon Blade to the Grand Archives.
I killed the red invader for the host, and got a Concord Well-Kept.
But aren't you only supposed to get those from Aldrich Faithfuls?

...Though that brings me to my next question...I've never actually gotten ANYTHING from killing an Aldrich Faithful.

So what is the intended way to receive the Well-Kept concords, vs the Normal ones?

Concords Well Kept are rewards from eliminating an Aldritch Faithful invader as a Blade. Standard Concords are everyone else.

[Vinyl Scratch]

Originally posted by immortallegion:

Concords Well Kept are rewards from eliminating an Aldritch Faithful invader as a Blade. Standard Concords are everyone else.

Well that's what it's SUPPOSED to be.
But I got a Well-Kept from killing a red phantom at the Grand Archives (where aldrich can't invade)
I've also never actually gotten anything from killing an Aldrich at all.

Just 5 minutes ago, I got another well kept from killing a Red Phantom again.

So I guess at this point it's pretty clear that I'm somehow bugged in this (or the whole thing in general is bugged...big shock)

[Vinyl Scratch]

Just happened again.
Got summoned, only one Red Phantom present. No Covenant or anything.
Killed him, got a Well-Kept concord, got sent home.

[Javan Asher]

Looks like Vinul Scratch is a Blue at heart. You do your thing, internet person, you do your thing.

Yup, it looks like a bug.

[Bigfootmech]

It's not bugged

You "use" the item to get 2x concord kept - check the wiki

http://darksouls3.wiki.fextralife.com/page/revision/Proof+of+a+Concord+Well+Kept

[Grad]

Originally posted by a helpless tramp:

It's not bugged

You "use" the item to get 2x concord kept - check the wiki

http://darksouls3.wiki.fextralife.com/page/revision/Proof+of+a+Concord+Well+Kept

No, that's not what he means, what you thought is what I thought.
What he means is that only Aldritch Faithful kills shouls reward the Well Kept item, but he is getting them off regular reds in the Archives. That seems to be bugged.

[TheSilverPalm]

He could be in aldrich covenant and using red eye orb. Only reasonable thing i can think off...

[❌ Peath]

You bassically are killing Aldrich Faithfull who are invading by REO.

Why they do it? They are 100% into pvp and being a douchbag, while they are still getting summoned to the Aldrich Territory, they also invade normally in other areas in the meantime.

[Bouncer]

I guess you might have killed an invader that has a lot of sin or killed a lot of people via invasions. Doesn't the item discription say that its rewarded for people with a lot of sin? I've killed a red at pontiffs and he dropped double ears

[twin]

u lucky bastard, I've been farming silver knights all day long while waiting for BotDm covenant to find me. 3 days later, only 2 proofs dropped = =

[Vinyl Scratch]

Originally posted by VILLENT:

You bassically are killing Aldrich Faithfull who are invading by REO.

Why they do it? They are 100% into pvp and being a douchbag, while they are still getting summoned to the Aldrich Territory, they also invade normally in other areas in the meantime.

This makes sense but...
Then why don't I get Well-Kept Concords from ACTUAL Aldrich members in Irythl?

Originally posted by TwinDrive:

u lucky bastard, I've been farming silver knights all day long while waiting for BotDm covenant to find me. 3 days later, only 2 proofs dropped = =

http://steamcommunity.com/app/374320/discussions/0/357286119111456394/
Try this, it's what I had to do.