can I still get horsehoof ring without meeting patches at cathedral.

[Disney Princess: GOTY Edition.]

I joined rosarias fingers before meeting patches. Can I go into ng+ to catch him?

[Mandrake109]

No need get locked in the bell tower at firelink and you're good to go.

[Disney Princess: GOTY Edition.]

OH THATS RIGHT I FORGOT. DUDE THANKS

[juicy]

All you need to do is open the gate near the rosaria bonfire across the bridge.

[Disney Princess: GOTY Edition.]

he isnt there. I just finished ng+ without going that way. but JTL2+3 is right about the bell tower.

[Mandrake109]

Originally posted by thekevster:

he isnt there. I just finished ng+ without going that way. but JTL2+3 is right about the bell tower.

Greirat still needs to be at firelink so you still my be out of luck.

[Disney Princess: GOTY Edition.]

He's in my firelink, but i never sent him anywhere for the risk of having him dying.

[Mandrake109]

Originally posted by thekevster:

He's in my firelink, but i never sent him anywhere for the risk of having him dying.

Then you are fine just make Patches show and talk to him he will comment on Greirat and should sell the ring then.

[Disney Princess: GOTY Edition.]

collecting all rings and ring + for achievment but i got it either way. thanks mah dude