If I go to Rosaria's bonfire, I fail the Sirris questline?

[AntoniOwO]

Only go to the bonfire, don't talk with Rosaria, fails the Sirris questline?

[ChubbNutt]

No. If you hand over a pale tongue then you fail.

Joining the fingers probably also fails it.

[Seamus]

Using the bonfire, respeccing and changing your appearance do NOT fail the questline.

Giving her a tongue for the covenant does.

[Amix]

Originally posted by Seamus:

Using the bonfire, respeccing and changing your appearance do NOT fail the questline.

Giving her a tongue for the covenant does.

Can you respec without joining? I mean first option comes joining then you can respec. Maybe you are in new game & can do that.

[Abys]

Originally posted by AmiX:

Originally posted by Seamus:

Using the bonfire, respeccing and changing your appearance do NOT fail the questline.

Giving her a tongue for the covenant does.

Can you respec without joining? I mean first option comes joining then you can respec. Maybe you are in new game & can do that.

You are allowed to join the covenant, just not allowed to give her a tongue specifically to deepen your allegiance to Rosaria's Fingers.

[ShieldofFeep]

last time i checked, you cant even be part of her covenent, like you can use the bonfire but anything that uses her you cant do or you fail.

[Mephisto]

It's only giving tongues for the covenant. Anything else is fine. Respeccing is fine.

[Abys]

Originally posted by Onion Bro:

It's only giving tongues for the covenant. Anything else is fine. Respeccing is fine.

This.

[Wicked Sick]

Originally posted by HARVEY:

Originally posted by Onion Bro:

It's only giving tongues for the covenant. Anything else is fine. Respeccing is fine.

This.

So, 2020 now and after all the patches, is it still the same? Can one join and change appearance without failing the quest?

[Moh]

Originally posted by Juliano:

Originally posted by HARVEY:

This.

So, 2020 now and after all the patches, is it still the same? Can one join and change appearance without failing the quest?

yep

[windwalker129 (Canis)]

Equip covenant item or offer pale tongue will stop Sirris questline.
Change appearance and stats won't.

Backup your save file if you still worry.

[ZAToM]

nooooooo

lol sorry for necro i was just double checking.. im in ng+ and try to get what i missed (OMG SO MUCH)
and about leonhard wiki sais this

Once you reach the Cathedral of the Deep, find Rosaria´s Fingers in Rosaria's Chamber at the second floor of the Cathedral of the Deep and offer at least 1 Pale Tongue to Rosaria (Do NOT rank up in Rosaria's Fingers until the next event happens)

so i just offered 1 tongue cause i think you rank up with 10 and then with 30

i should have read tips section first :(

[Venombites]

Originally posted by windwalker129:

Equip covenant item or offer pale tongue will stop Sirris questline.
Change appearance and stats won't.

Backup your save file if you still worry.

do this