Killing Orbeck of Vinheim ?

[Mattsworth]

I just killed Orbeck of Vinheim so I can get one of the endings but I forgot to get the Crystal magic wepon is there anything I can do to get a the spell or do I have to NG+ it ?

[lian]

no chance

[Jaago]

Killing Orbeck isn't required for any ending and yes, you have to go ng+ for it.

[76561198308101990]

Yuria demands his death, but you don#t actually have to kill him. Just find all the scrolls, give them to him and buy out his spell selection. He will leave firelink and his corpse can be found in the grand archives. This also completes Yurias quest.

[Mattsworth]

Well bugger to late now,is there any other spells simler to Crystall magic weapon ?

[Deadly.Crystal.Lizard]

Did you give him all the scrolls beforehand? Give the ashes to the Shrine Handmaiden to unlock his stuff for purchase. Don't know though if it works the same way for Yuria though...

[76561198308101990]

Originally posted by The British Nymph™ ツ:

Well bugger to late now,is there any other spells simler to Crystall magic weapon ?

Depending on your build there are:
Carthus flame Arc (pyromancy - fire)
Dark {LINK REMOVED}...edge? blade.. ? .. I don't know .. (Sorcery - dark)
Sunlight blade (Miracle - lightning)
Dark Moon blade ( should be a miracle but don't quote me on that - magic)
Great magic weapon (Sorcery - magic)

For their locations please look at the wiki or maybe someone else knows where to get them all.

[LedZepphead]

Originally posted by Deadly.Crystal.Lizard:

Did you give him all the scrolls beforehand? Give the ashes to the Shrine Handmaiden to unlock his stuff for purchase. Don't know though if it works the same way for Yuria though...

The Shrine Handmaiden doesn't sell all of his spells when you give her Orbeck's ashes even if you gave him all the scrolls before killing him. Yuria does have ashes if you kill her, but the Handmaiden will sell all the stuff she did sell.

[Artale]

Originally posted by Sin2:

Originally posted by The British Nymph™ ツ:

Well bugger to late now,is there any other spells simler to Crystall magic weapon ?

Depending on your build there are:
Carthus flame Arc (pyromancy - fire)
Dark ...edge? blade.. ? .. I don't know .. (Sorcery - dark)
Sunlight blade (Miracle - lightning)
Dark Moon blade ( should be a miracle but don't quote me on that - magic)
Great magic weapon (Sorcery - magic)

For their locations please look at the wiki or maybe someone else knows where to get them all.

Carthus Flame Arc - Carthus Pyromancy Tome (Catacombs of Carthus)
Dark Blade - Sold by Karla by giving her Deep Braille Divine Tome (I believe, could be Londor Divine Tome) (don't give it to Irina, you monster!)
Lightning Blade - Irithyll Dungeon, gotta jump off an elevator, after you face some rats (2 big ones), it's to the left in the next room. You get an outside bit with the Dragon Chest or something
Darkmoon Blade - Hand in 30 Proof of Concord Kept to Yorshka in Anor Londo
Great Magic Weapon - next to the gate between Crucifixion Woods and Farron Keep Perimiter

[Deadly.Crystal.Lizard]

Originally posted by LedZepphead:

Originally posted by Deadly.Crystal.Lizard:

Did you give him all the scrolls beforehand? Give the ashes to the Shrine Handmaiden to unlock his stuff for purchase. Don't know though if it works the same way for Yuria though...

The Shrine Handmaiden doesn't sell all of his spells when you give her Orbeck's ashes even if you gave him all the scrolls before killing him. Yuria does have ashes if you kill her, but the Handmaiden will sell all the stuff she did sell.

you sure? I'm pretty certain she does and the wiki states that aswell.

and with yuria I meant giving his ashes to Yuria.

[LedZepphead]

Originally posted by Deadly.Crystal.Lizard:

you sure? I'm pretty certain she does and the wiki states that aswell.

Ahhh, my mistake. On fextralife it listed a bunch of spells but I didn't read this line at the end: "...and all other spells unlocked with scrolls at the Shrine Handmaid".

So I guess she will sell them then. But by the time you get to the Archives, Yuria will have told you not to worry about killing Orbeck anymore. I'm pretty sure the Handmaiden doesn't take scrolls though, so you would have to give Orbeck all the scrolls before killing him to have his ashes let her sell all his spells.

Originally posted by Deadly.Crystal.Lizard:

.

and with yuria I meant giving his ashes to Yuria.

Yuria only gives the Morion Blade if you give Orbeck's ashes to her. And his Clandestine coat will unlock at the Handmaiden no matter who you give his ashes to apparently.

[Washing Machine]

Noticed also that you can't kill Orbeck BEFORE sending him to Firelink. If you slay him at the forest and bring his ashes to Yuria before she gives you the quest, you won't get the blade.

Need dat Scholar Ring. Drats.