Have all rings, no achievement

[USARice]

Anyone else have this issue, I had all the rings, and I had a friend drop Prisoner's Chain since that was the last one I needed, but it didn't trigger.

[Lydia Scott]

Try dropping the chain then picking it up?

[MobiusPizza]

I think you don't get the achievement with dropped rings.
Anyway, I am not 100% sure. Some others had that problem and they could solve it by dropping and picking up again every ring

[lev]

Originally posted by MobiusPizza:

I think you don't get the achievement with dropped rings.
Anyway, I am not 100% sure. Some others had that problem and they could solve it by dropping and picking up again every ring

I got the achievement myself the hard way and gave rings to help people getting it too. It does work with dropped rings.

[TopHatPenguin]

I had the same issue I went through all of the steps had a list and got everything even dlc stuff and I never got the acievement

[lev]

Do you have all +1 rings, +2, and the Life Ring +3?

[USARice]

Welp, just realized that I need every version of all the rings, and I sold so many of my regular and +1's because I thought I didn't need them now that I had the superior version, welp that's a bust lol.

[MobiusPizza]

hahaha lol

[lev]

that sucks lol

[USARice]

Could someone help me figure this out though. I'm going by this picture

https://i.imgur.com/RSULq5S.jpg

and for example, coveteous gold only has 3 pictures, but there's a regular, + 1, +2, and +3, which would make 4. Or does it not have a regular non + version? Same for Havel, only 3 pictures, but there's a +1, +2, and +3. I don't remember really, is there no Havel's Ring(with no +) ?

[MobiusPizza]

The +3 version is from the 2º DLC, so it doesn't count for the achievement

[lev]

Originally posted by VenomBlade:

Could someone help me figure this out though. I'm going by this picture

https://i.imgur.com/RSULq5S.jpg

and for example, coveteous gold only has 3 pictures, but there's a regular, + 1, +2, and +3, which would make 4. Or does it not have a regular non + version? Same for Havel, only 3 pictures, but there's a +1, +2, and +3. I don't remember really, is there no Havel's Ring(with no +) ?

There is only one +3 ring in the base game and that is the Life Ring. Other +3's are in the DLC and are not needed for the achievement

[USARice]

Originally posted by MobiusPizza:

The +3 version is from the 2º DLC, so it doesn't count for the achievement

Originally posted by 722pam:

Originally posted by VenomBlade:

Could someone help me figure this out though. I'm going by this picture

https://i.imgur.com/RSULq5S.jpg

and for example, coveteous gold only has 3 pictures, but there's a regular, + 1, +2, and +3, which would make 4. Or does it not have a regular non + version? Same for Havel, only 3 pictures, but there's a +1, +2, and +3. I don't remember really, is there no Havel's Ring(with no +) ?

There is only one +3 ring in the base game and that is the Life Ring. Other +3's are in the DLC and are not needed for the achievement

Ahh kk thanks guys. Guess I'm gonna go for this anyway lol.

[Banr]

This Dark Souls 3 Cheat Sheet is pretty useful if you are interested

https://zkjellberg.github.io/dark-souls-3-cheat-sheet/

[lev]

Originally posted by Banr:

This Dark Souls 3 Cheat Sheet is pretty useful if you are interested

https://zkjellberg.github.io/dark-souls-3-cheat-sheet/

Cheating is for casuls

[wilco64256]

If you're already in a later game cycle you can still pick up the more basic rings again pretty easily. In NG+2 and beyond you can get *all* of the rings in the same run. It really is a pain that you have to be holding all of them at the same time though.