Irina of Carim questline help (spoilers)

[isador]

So guys, I'm having a bit of issue with this questline. According to my sources, she'll turn into a firekeeper if you give her all the tomes that have light miracles in them, and then buy all the light miracles without buying any of the dark miracles. Right now I've given her 3 tomes, the only one I didn't give her was the one Yuria sells, since she never showed up in my game. However, she hasn't turned into a firekeeper yet.

So far I've bought: Heal,Med Heal, Replenishment, Bountiful Light, Caressing Tears, Tears of Denial, Homeward, Force, Blessed Weapon and Magic Barrier.
I have Gnaw and Deep Protection available, but didn't buy either of them.

Can anyone point out what I've missed?

[Hannya]

Dun dun da

There are only 2 divine tomes that you should give to her

You must've given the Deep Braille divine tome to her which gives you Gnaw and Deep Protection

Now she's outside the firelink shrine, next to the door of Gundyr's bossfight and an upset Eygon of Carim whom you have to fight

Unfortunately, even talking to her and convincing her to return won't allow her to become a firekeeper again since for that you may ONLY give her the Carim/Lothric divine tome and buy the miracles in them; giving either the Londor or Deep tome breaks this

[isador]

Oh, but she's not outside the firelink shrine, she's still at her usual spot.

[isador]

Actually bro, I'm afraid I gotta prove you wrong here.

Since I like exploring before doing bosses and such, I hadn't defeated the dragonslayer's armor just yet when I gave her that 3rd tome from the same area and bought the last few light miracles. So after I was done exploring, I decided to go beat the next boss, killed the dragonslayer's armor, came back to firelink to check on Irina, and she was gone. So, I feared the worst, but decided to check on the location she was going to be at IF I went down the light path correctly.

She's there and she's a firekeeper now. The dark miracle tome I gave her was at her feet, so giving her the tomes doesn't matter, all that matters is if you buy the dark miracles or not.

[lpnlizard27]

Dont forget to exhaust Eygons Dialogue.
Speak with him outside the cell, then again in firelink.

After buying all the light miracles Eygon will be dead in her old cell and she will become a firekeeper in the bell tower.

Ive never had a problem with this quest, i always give the dark tomes to Karla.

[Kalli :)]

Hey! I had this same issue and I was totally confused.

I understand this is an old thread, but I am replying in hopes it'll clear confusion for someone else!

-you can give her any miracle tome, just don't buy the dark miracles.
-ensure you have purchased all light miracles
-either defeat a boss or save and exit the game to trigger her promotion to fire keeper

This last step is familiar to anyone who has struggled in trying to get the dlc triggers for ds1 to go. It's the same basic thing.

I hope this helps!