Can i complete both Rosaria and Sirris Covenant

[Melon]

im play my NG+ and i followed guides for 100% completion. I know that you can not complete Sirris quest if you offer pale tongue to Rosaria first time you meet her, so i just talked to her and leave, keep her covenant item unequiped. however there is no dialogue and i can already change my stats and appearance without talking to her since i have joint her in my first playthrough. After that i cant find sirris in my Firelink Shrine. Do i mess Sirris questline up? Must i start a new character to complete?

[Miles (Tails) Prower]

Only giving tongue to rosaria will mess everything up. Changing model or stats doesn't mess up sirris questline. But I recommdend to complete Rosaria rewards lately.

[MOSLEY]

Just complete Sirris' quest line first. You can complete them both in one game cycle.

[Melon]

But i cant find Sirris in my shrine already. i did not give her any tongue in my current playthrough, but i did in the last playthrough. Does this affect Sirris quest?

[Artek [General]]

Originally posted by i git gud:

But i cant find Sirris in my shrine already. i did not give her any tongue in my current playthrough, but i did in the last playthrough. Does this affect Sirris quest?

Nope, the quests reset every NG cycle.

She's not always in the shrine. You should start worrying when she'll criticize you for beconing a finger and say that you better not cross paths.

Until then - its fine.

[Melon]

Originally posted by Artek General:

Originally posted by i git gud:

But i cant find Sirris in my shrine already. i did not give her any tongue in my current playthrough, but i did in the last playthrough. Does this affect Sirris quest?

Nope, the quests reset every NG cycle.

She's not always in the shrine. You should start worrying when she'll criticize you for beconing a finger and say that you better not cross paths.

Until then - its fine.

Thank you!

[Scraps]

I understand this isn't Sirris' questline, but I find this equally important incase you want to be efficient:

Yuria's quest and being her enemy can be done in 1 playthrough for the purposes of getting both Pale Shade Set and the Lord of Hollows ending/rewards, similar to Sirris' and Leonhardt's quests.

Trigger Yuria's arrival before Abyss Watches, and hit her 3 times to agro her (she may kill you, but she wont get out of her hole after). Then kill the Pale Shade in both of his areas (Farron Keep and Irythill) while doing Anri's quest simultaneously as you would to get Lord of Hollows. Leave Pontiff Sulyvahn alive until you've killed Pale Shade both times, and went to the Statue of Velka to absolve sin.

Yuria will then treat you as the Lord of Londor once again as if nothing happened, and you still get the Manikin Claws and Pale Shade Set without conciquence. Pefect for when you want these items in 1 playthrough rather than 2.

[Vovin]

Once you've made yourself known to Anri and Horace on the Road of Sacrifices, return to the Firelink Shrine and speak with the newly-arrived Sirris of the Sunless Realms. The event won't be triggered before meeting Anri and Horace. Although she appears to brush you off, her quest line will still begin. Note that participating in any activity involving the Rosaria's Fingers covenant (aside from the initial step of joining it or giving Leonhardt the first tongue), will prematurely and permanently end Sirris' quest line, so be careful. Finish Sirris ql first, then go for Rosaria.
There is a way to to finish all questlines successfully in one cycle.

[Melon]

Originally posted by Sassy the Lame Bird:

I understand this isn't Sirris' questline, but I find this equally important incase you want to be efficient:

Yuria's quest and being her enemy can be done in 1 playthrough for the purposes of getting both Pale Shade Set and the Lord of Hollows ending/rewards, similar to Sirris' and Leonhardt's quests.

Trigger Yuria's arrival before Abyss Watches, and hit her 3 times to agro her (she may kill you, but she wont get out of her hole after). Then kill the Pale Shade in both of his areas (Farron Keep and Irythill) while doing Anri's quest simultaneously as you would to get Lord of Hollows. Leave Pontiff Sulyvahn alive until you've killed Pale Shade both times, and went to the Statue of Velka to absolve sin.

Yuria will then treat you as the Lord of Londor once again as if nothing happened, and you still get the Manikin Claws and Pale Shade Set without conciquence. Pefect for when you want these items in 1 playthrough rather than 2.

Thankyou. i will use this method in my playthrough. So Sirris's and Leonhardt"s quest can get two results' item too?

[Melon]

Originally posted by Vovin:

Once you've made yourself known to Anri and Horace on the Road of Sacrifices, return to the Firelink Shrine and speak with the newly-arrived Sirris of the Sunless Realms. The event won't be triggered before meeting Anri and Horace. Although she appears to brush you off, her quest line will still begin. Note that participating in any activity involving the Rosaria's Fingers covenant (aside from the initial step of joining it or giving Leonhardt the first tongue), will prematurely and permanently end Sirris' quest line, so be careful. Finish Sirris ql first, then go for Rosaria.
There is a way to to finish all questlines successfully in one cycle.

Thankyou. I already did those steps and now it should be normal that Sirris is not in my shrine all the time.

[Scraps]

Originally posted by i git gud:

Thankyou. i will use this method in my playthrough. So Sirris's and Leonhardt"s quest can get two results' item too?

Not entirely certain what you're asking, but you can't use the absolve sin trick with Sirris, I'm... Almost certain.

You can still do both Sirris' and Leonhardt's quests, but use the methods other users are giving. Specifically, you want to give a Pale Tongue and start Leonhardt's quest after you've sworn knighthood with Sirris and killed Lothric. Her quest should be done by that point.

[Melon]

Originally posted by Sassy the Lame Bird:

Originally posted by i git gud:

Thankyou. i will use this method in my playthrough. So Sirris's and Leonhardt"s quest can get two results' item too?

Not entirely certain what you're asking, but you can't use the absolve sin trick with Sirris, I'm... Almost certain.

You can still do both Sirris' and Leonhardt's quests, but use the methods other users are giving. Specifically, you want to give a Pale Tongue and start Leonhardt's quest after you've sworn knighthood with Sirris and killed Lothric. Her quest should be done by that point.

Oh i got it. You mean both covenant from them. i thought i could do their quest with the same way of yuria's.

[Vovin]

Go outside Firelink Shrine, quit and reload a few times and check if bae arrived each time, Sirris's going to pop up eventually.

And Sassy is right, absolving works for Yuria and the other "permanent" Shrine dwellers, but not for Sirris. Anger her and she gonna try to poke a blade into your left eye.

PS: one time Sirris only arrived for me after I met Anri and Horace AND kicked Heysel's bony azz in the swamp after he invaded. But I think that was a coincidence and is not connected.

[matarabun]

She's dead outside the firelink shrine near her grandfather's tomb?

[Hunubul]

There is one emote you can only get if you screw up Sirris' questline. The proper bow. You have to know what's more important: the emote, or the ring/creighton's stuff/her talisman/Hodrick's stuff.

[Hunubul]

Originally posted by matarabun:

She's dead outside the firelink shrine near her grandfather's tomb?

Only if you finished her questline.