Is Cloth unsaveable?

[Eklipser]

I wanted to make a perfect steel soul run in which everybody is alive and live happily in Dirthmouth (I know, crazy) including Zote, Bretta, Grimmchild, Elderbug with flower, etc. And I wanted to save Cloth as well. At first run she died of course in fight with Traitor Lord. So I looked for way to not allow her to aid me and not die to Traitor. I found that supposedly she could be saved if I didn't ever speak (or rather listen) to her to not trigger/continue her story to point where she comes unwanted to battle. So I did it. I didn't hear even a single word from her. I completly ignored her (Except nodding. Apparently that's the only way in wich The Knight can communicate I imagine). But she came to battle anyway and epicly died being pierced all the way through her body while smacking Taitor Lord in the head with massive club.

So here's the question: Is there any way to save Cloth and let her live happily with others?

[Master-Steel]

her dying is the good ending for her

[Eklipser]

I know but I would like to have everyone alive rather then a party of ghosts.

[Hexamicor]

Even if you do let her live, she goes out into the desert and dies there. Though I recall there being a glitch that for some reason wouldn't let her leave Dirtmouth...

[Eklipser]

So her destiny is to die in battle anyway. So be it. Thanks for information.

[Suzaku Sparkpom]

The only way to save her is to never meet her in the first place,
she won't show up for Triator Lord and get skewered, but she'll just go seek death some other way, she's all about a glorious death.

[Hirungolwe]

McCramer is completely false. Cloth can be saved by not rescuing her at the ancient basin until after fighting the Traitor Lord. Doing so, causes her to go to Dirtmouth, depressed that she was not valiant enough. She says that she will try to go to other lands afterwards. This glitch McCrammer is talking about is not true, Cloth is meant to stay at Dirtmouth if you don't let her fight with you.

[Lewd Avocado]

How do you glitch cloth to stay in dirtmouth?

[Hexamicor]

Originally posted by fahim_taghavi:

McCramer is completely false. Cloth can be saved by not rescuing her at the ancient basin until after fighting the Traitor Lord. Doing so, causes her to go to Dirtmouth, depressed that she was not valiant enough. She says that she will try to go to other lands afterwards. This glitch McCrammer is talking about is not true, Cloth is meant to stay at Dirtmouth if you don't let her fight with you.

Read the dream nail dialogue while she's in Dirtmouth before accusing me, will you?
"Nola, I'm coming. More challenging foes are out there, somewhere, but none in this ruin could take me to you..."
Cloth wishes to die in combat to meet her friend once again, and departs from Dirtmouth when you leave the area after visitng the town. She does not stay in Dirtmouth like you claim.
Two out of the three times I went this route with her story, she left the town once I left after talking to her. The other time she would not leave for some reason no matter what I did, loading to an earlier save before her encounter in Dirtmouth fixed this.
I've had a similar bug with Tiso's Dirtmouth encounter before, also fixed by loading to an earlier save and encountering him again. So it is not character specific. I do not know what causes the bug, but it has happened to friends of mine, too.
Thank you for attempting to spread more false information.

[Eklipser]

So she will leave or stay because of some glicht or not. Which one is true is to be figured out for certain. Anyway I decided to sitck with the "good" ending for her. Althoug that's a little funny how story can be different when few people do the same and get different results because of some bug.