What Idol is best to give Caxton? (Bronze, Silver, Gold or Other?)

[Lashane The Simp of Mimi]

I heard this choice makes a big deal in what exclusive new gear he offers you afterwards, apparently that booby lady also will offer you exclusive wares as well. so which idol is best suited for these situations?

[Doomvora]

Depends on your vocation of choice really.

[Boskov]

http://dragonsdogma.wikia.com/wiki/Gold_Idol

See what items you want and give the idol accordingly.

[Max and Omnis]

If you are a strength class, give caxton gold idol. If not, give it to madeline.

[Lashane The Simp of Mimi]

Originally posted by BroBear Berbil:

http://dragonsdogma.wikia.com/wiki/Gold_Idol

See what items you want and give the idol accordingly.

ty, gold idol it is then, seems to give the best stuff for both caxton and booby lady.

[bugulu]

Don't forget to forge your gold idol so you can keep the discount bonus.

[Jtea]

According to some players of the console version, madeleine has some harder to come by armor (and she has better stock for female characters/pawns), while Caxton has a bigger variety of weapons that you can choose from (I researched the golden idol thing for a while, and people say madeleines items are more rare, although I don't know this myself and it could be different for PC)

[Quint]

Doh, I completely forgot about the possibility to give bronze or silver idols and ended up giving Claxon a forged gold idol (since I gave Madeleine the real gold idol). Oh well, maybe next time or something.

[Rob'sEvilTwin]

if you want new hotness in the way of female clothing, save the gold for Maddy :D

[.//slayer]

I already gave a bronze idol to Caxton without realizing that it's a final decision. Can I give him a different idol in NG+?

[Pinger]

Originally posted by .//slayer:

I already gave a bronze idol to Caxton without realizing that it's a final decision. Can I give him a different idol in NG+?

yes, also do Not give him a forgery I learnt that the hard way as it does nothing other than complete the quest

[.//slayer]

Thanks!