Are "Thick as Thieves" and "No Honor Among Thieves" mutually exclusive?

[Jamers]

I reckon I managed to complete both of these side quests during my Xbox playthrough, but I also remember that it may have required a little finesse.

Is there a particular order in which one must tackle the various tasks of these two quests (the ones involving the male bandit castle and the female bandit castle), or shall I just treat them as normal, doing one at a time and making sure to stash away the Badge of Amity awarded by whomever's quest I finish first?

I haven't received either quest yet.

Thanks!

[Corlain]

I just did them. Just choose the options where you don't have to kill anyone. So feed the cyclops and talk to the thief guy who you caught earlier in Cassardis and get him to return to Maul.

[Jamers]

l_hamalainen님이 먼저 게시:

I just did them. Just choose the options where you don't have to kill anyone. So feed the cyclops and talk to the thief guy who you caught earlier in Cassardis and get him to return to Maul.

Hey, thanks!

Don't you get better rewards if you do both? Or do you get better rewards but also cause the opposing faction to become permanently hostile?

[Corlain]

I don't remember what happens if you kill the other group, but I think pawns need to see that route too if you want them to have max stars in these quest.

[Jason Eroge]

i kill some of the female bandits and completed the male 1....and feed the orge....lol....completed both....lmao...

[BurlsoL]

You can do them both, but arguably the tokens don't do what it says on the label (thieves on the road will still attack you).

I did no honor among thieves first and just told the guy in Cardassis to man up and accept his fate instead of killing the female thieves. At a later point I did Thick as Thieves and attacked the male thieves outside the fort no problem. I even killed a few isolated thieves within the fort without them caring. The only caveat might be if you killed the leader of either group.

Thick as Thieves will however require an all female party, or with males who are suitably shaved and dressed before you can talk to the leader.

[♪～くまモン～♪]

You can do both. Just remember to put the badge in your warehouse if you are working on the quest received from the opposite side. Male/female bandits will not show up if you bring those two badgets.

[Corlain]

Yeah actually I think you don't even have to kill the bandits in the main camp, the ones outside it count... So you can probably do both even through killing them as long as Ophis and Maul are alive. I'm not 100% sure about this though...

[C4Warr10r]

Saga님이 먼저 게시:

You can do both. Just remember to put the badge in your warehouse if you are working on the quest received from the opposite side. Male/female bandits will not show up if you bring those two badgets.

Not only that, Ophis will attack you if you're carrying Maul's badge.

[Zuvan]

Do both for better rewards and quest knowledge. Most people are missing the 3 stars on these me included, they are really boring quests .

[BurlsoL]

C4Warr10r님이 먼저 게시:

Saga님이 먼저 게시:

You can do both. Just remember to put the badge in your warehouse if you are working on the quest received from the opposite side. Male/female bandits will not show up if you bring those two badgets.

Not only that, Ophis will attack you if you're carrying Maul's badge.

She didn't attack when I went to her. Been walking around with both badges, bandits on the roads still spawn, but neither of the forts are hostile. Even after I moved my male pawn out of drag.

[♪～くまモン～♪]

Zuvan님이 먼저 게시:

Do both for better rewards and quest knowledge. Most people are missing the 3 stars on these me included, they are really boring quests .

well, there are 3 conditions to finish those 2 quests. Usually you only fulfill 2 conditions to receive the most rewards. A and B contradict each other. C is to kill stuff. So it'e either A+C or B+C

[C4Warr10r]

BurlsoL님이 먼저 게시:

She didn't attack when I went to her. Been walking around with both badges, bandits on the roads still spawn, but neither of the forts are hostile. Even after I moved my male pawn out of drag.

That's not how that's supposed to work. Once you have the amity badge from Ophis you can walk around her fort with men. Some bandits will always spawn, but not the ones on the roads near Heavenspeak or Maul's Fort.

But if you are carrying Maul's badge when you first meet Ophis, she's supposed to attack right away. Then the fort goes hostile.

[JamuThatsWho]

I did the second option (the traitor and feed the cyclops) and got both badges.

[JamuThatsWho]

Also, disguising yourself and any male Pawns as women stops Ophis' lot from attacking you (you also have to be clean shaven).

[Jason Eroge]

Saga님이 먼저 게시:

You can do both. Just remember to put the badge in your warehouse if you are working on the quest received from the opposite side. Male/female bandits will not show up if you bring those two badgets.

lmao i heard that they will hate you with the badges but i have both the badge and they dont care....and the female leader dont attack me even thou i am a guy and not dress as a lady