Why does Plutia get so much hate

[Alex]

seriously

[banas002]

I actually like Plutia so much. She's as cute as button. Iris Heart was kinda scary though.

[shiratoriryuuko]

Originally posted by Janna:

I don't mind Plutia, and i think i will most likely like her once this game will come out, but from what i've seen i can already say i hate Iris Heart, and i really doubt this will ever change.

Why hate someone who is brutally honest about everything though? Iris Heart is honest to a fault.

[ImmaNovice]

I bought the game mostly because of Pururut/Iris Heart. Kana Hanazawa in her finest.

[Nihil]

I know this thread is mostly dead now, but did anyone mention that Plutia practically is as bad in some cases as those she tortures and rapes? You guys didn't forget the "good" ending... did you? (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VQOtQ-NIWcY)
Sure, she rapes the young CPU candidates as comedy, but still.... it's kinda hypocritical in some ways. She supposedly fights to stop bullies when she herself is one, as demonstrated by this ending, where she violates those who are weaker than her for her own fun, with no regard as to their well-being. She even has the gall to be sad when the candidates reject her after being sexually assaulted, as though she is somehow the victim, and did nothing to deserve their scorn.
If people can condemn Nepgear for the conquest ending, why not condemn Plutia based on this good ending, especially since unlike the conquest ending, Plutia is acting more in line with her usual behavior for the good ending than Nepgear was in the conquest ending?
Also, there's the concern that "Plutia" is just an elaborate act. Back in Lowee, when Blanc was beaten, and the CPUs were in prison, Plutia appeared to be relatively kind to Blanc, only to later reveal her less than compassionate motives: wanting to cause Blanc more pain so she would cry more because Blanc was cute when she cried.
Lastly.... she's kind of a Mary Sue (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/MarySue), Jerk Sue (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/JerkSue), and Karma Houndini (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/KarmaHoudini). Throughout the game, she loses a total of one times, and only against an invincible Yellow Heart. When the CPUs drag her away from Mr. Badd and his daughters that she was about to slaughter, she decides to try and torture them for preventing her from commiting an atrocity. In response, the CPUs turn on eachother and leave her friend, Noire, to recieve the brunt of the punishment. Sure, this is all amusing to no end throughout the first playthrough, but combined with the above paragraphs, it just gets annoying after a while.

Sorry for the wall of text, hopefully something useful can be gleaned from this response.

[hugo_ham]

deberian odiar a nepgear

[Nihil]

Originally posted by Yurist:

Originally posted by Nihil:

I know this thread is mostly dead now, but did anyone mention that Plutia practically is as bad in some cases as those she tortures and rapes? You guys didn't forget the "good" ending... did you? (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VQOtQ-NIWcY)
Sure, she rapes the young CPU candidates as comedy, but still.... it's kinda hypocritical in some ways. She supposedly fights to stop bullies when she herself is one, as demonstrated by this ending, where she violates those who are weaker than her for her own fun, with no regard as to their well-being. She even has the gall to be sad when the candidates reject her after being sexually assaulted, as though she is somehow the victim, and did nothing to deserve their scorn.
If people can condemn Nepgear for the conquest ending, why not condemn Plutia based on this good ending, especially since unlike the conquest ending, Plutia is acting more in line with her usual behavior for the good ending than Nepgear was in the conquest ending?
Also, there's the concern that "Plutia" is just an elaborate act. Back in Lowee, when Blanc was beaten, and the CPUs were in prison, Plutia appeared to be relatively kind to Blanc, only to later reveal her less than compassionate motives: wanting to cause Blanc more pain so she would cry more because Blanc was cute when she cried.
Lastly.... she's kind of a Mary Sue (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/MarySue), Jerk Sue (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/JerkSue), and Karma Houndini (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/KarmaHoudini). Throughout the game, she loses a total of one times, and only against an invincible Yellow Heart. When the CPUs drag her away from Mr. Badd and his daughters that she was about to slaughter, she decides to try and torture them for preventing her from commiting an atrocity. In response, the CPUs turn on eachother and leave her friend, Noire, to recieve the brunt of the punishment. Sure, this is all amusing to no end throughout the first playthrough, but combined with the above paragraphs, it just gets annoying after a while.

Sorry for the wall of text, hopefully something useful can be gleaned from this response.

Plutia is not "bad" her Iris Heart form is sadistic and somewhat psychotic. She don't want like Rei destroy the world. Clash between her human and Goddess form is so strong thats make her so interesting. She is just an dream about really dominant women who is taking what she want and when she want. Japanese medias like anime or games tend to made really exaggerated personalities (thats why Blanc is absolute dandere/yandere mix, Vert is an Fujoshi and Noire is an tsundere). Plutia (Iris) have really short temper is sexual and brutal to the limits so she behave like that. And about "raping" sisters: she most probably didn't rape them rather she molest them. It still bad, but at least she is a girl too (Katsuragi and Haruka in SV series are groping other girls too but since they are all girls they only get mad for a moment).

Sure, the ambiguity of where Plutia ends and Iris Heart begins is a rather amusing mystery. As far as raping/assaulting/molesting goes...how does them being of the same gender make is less bad to the point of being forgivable? If taken comedically, it's funny regardless, but if taken any other way, it's a violation of rights plain and simple.