Prey Tell *spoilers*

[wolfserised]

New to the game. Played Crime and Punishment on the PS and recently purchased this one.


Best to turn away now if you haven't finished the case...

How did people resolve the case? Apparently only 7% of people did the same as me. Thought it would be interesting to have a discussion.


Chose to let Marsh live and die slowly of TB; he then went to cut Marsh's throat so had Holmes shot Marsh. Mentality being that the man was poor and only trying to look after his son and by Holmes shooting Marsh the father didn't do it and it wasn't on Marshs' terms. Anyone else come to this conclusion? What did you get different? Reasons for doing so?

[The Director]

Originally posted by wolfserised:

New to the game. Played Crime and Punishment on the PS and recently purchased this one.


Best to turn away now if you haven't finished the case...

How did people resolve the case? Apparently only 7% of people did the same as me. Thought it would be interesting to have a discussion.


Chose to let Marsh live and die slowly of TB; he then went to cut Marsh's throat so had Holmes shot Marsh. Mentality being that the man was poor and only trying to look after his son and by Holmes shooting Marsh the father didn't do it and it wasn't on Marshs' terms. Anyone else come to this conclusion? What did you get different? Reasons for doing so?

I'm stuck in the kid's house. I found Pub clues and tried to go to the Pub but all SH keeps saying is "I'm not thirsty"
What garbage! I thought this was supposed to be open world. Sure you can pointlessly wonder around but the computer won't let you actually investigate anything until you click everything in the right order.
I'm stick on Prey Tell at the kid's house and believe I've found everything. No idea what to do next. Not happy with this game at all.

[wolfserised]

Originally posted by SpizyChicken:

Originally posted by wolfserised:

New to the game. Played Crime and Punishment on the PS and recently purchased this one.


Best to turn away now if you haven't finished the case...

How did people resolve the case? Apparently only 7% of people did the same as me. Thought it would be interesting to have a discussion.


Chose to let Marsh live and die slowly of TB; he then went to cut Marsh's throat so had Holmes shot Marsh. Mentality being that the man was poor and only trying to look after his son and by Holmes shooting Marsh the father didn't do it and it wasn't on Marshs' terms. Anyone else come to this conclusion? What did you get different? Reasons for doing so?

I'm stuck in the kid's house. I found Pub clues and tried to go to the Pub but all SH keeps saying is "I'm not thirsty"
What garbage! I thought this was supposed to be open world. Sure you can pointlessly wonder around but the computer won't let you actually investigate anything until you click everything in the right order.
I'm stick on Prey Tell at the kid's house and believe I've found everything. No idea what to do next. Not happy with this game at all.

Have you used the matches and lamp when you get up the ladder? [/spolier] and have you checked your casebook to see if there is any analysis you need to do at 221B Baker Street on the clues you have found?

[coldmetalhands]

I shot Marsh after deciding he should hang. I still never understood why the father was chasing me down in the forest trying to kill me though.

It also seemed odd that the Lord's body was cold but the pauper's body was warm. That felt backwards to me, given what was supposed to have been going on.