A question about Guild Guardians - Still dropping, but why?

[Koromac]

So, the Guild Guardians are still dropping for me. For what's worth, they are all ascended to Mythic quality already, fully traited and leveled-up, four copies of each, all six of them. What should I do, if for some strange reason, I would still receive Guild Guardians next week, from 1500 or 3000 Guild Seals? I usually open up the one option for 50 Chests, whenever possible.

[Koromac]

Screenshot link:
https://imgur.com/DUE23fg

[Jerry]

You could trade them for the few souls, it gets you. Or let them pile up in your troop selection.
Don't think too hard about this stuff. I think, I got some common monsters running into thousands by now. There's a point, when certain aspects of the game just no longer matter. A year ago, I was doing arena fights every now and then. Can't even remember, when I did this last. The more content is squezed into this game, the less each of it is worth on its own.

[Koromac]

Jerry님이 먼저 게시:

You could trade them for the few souls, it gets you. Or let them pile up in your troop selection.
Don't think too hard about this stuff. I think, I got some common monsters running into thousands by now. There's a point, when certain aspects of the game just no longer matter. A year ago, I was doing arena fights every now and then. Can't even remember, when I did this last. The more content is squezed into this game, the less each of it is worth on its own.

Well, if there's a (possible) bug, it must get fixed. That's what matters to me, at least.

[Whisper]

Koromac님이 먼저 게시:

Well, if there's a (possible) bug, it must get fixed. That's what matters to me, at least.

Why should there be a bug ?
There's nothing saying a troop can no longer drop even if you already have it at Mystic, Max Level and fully traited.

Guild Chest specifically call out that they will drop Guild Guardians regardless of (chest upgrade) level.

[Devonaut1]

Whisper님이 먼저 게시:

Koromac님이 먼저 게시:

Well, if there's a (possible) bug, it must get fixed. That's what matters to me, at least.

Why should there be a bug ?
There's nothing saying a troop can no longer drop even if you already have it at Mystic, Max Level and fully traited.

Guild Chest specifically call out that they will drop Guild Guardians regardless of (chest upgrade) level.

Yes, there is specifically an execption for guild guardians once all six are mythic and 4 copies each. If this is happening it is a bug and should be reported.

[Jerry]

There is neither an exception, nor a bug. When opening a chest, you have the chance to gain creatures of a certain rarity or type. The level, your creatures are, does have no influence on this.

Once all your common and rare troops are on mystic, gold chests will not suddenly stop spitting these out. It is the same with guild chests. Sure, it would be nice to rule out the trash drops at a certain amount, but this would conflict with the very concept of loot boxes.

[Koromac]

Jerry님이 먼저 게시:

There is neither an exception, nor a bug. When opening a chest, you have the chance to gain creatures of a certain rarity or type. The level, your creatures are, does have no influence on this.

Once all your common and rare troops are on mystic, gold chests will not suddenly stop spitting these out. It is the same with guild chests. Sure, it would be nice to rule out the trash drops at a certain amount, but this would conflict with the very concept of loot boxes.

You're wrong about the Guild Guardians.


https://community.gemsofwar.com/t/not-a-bug-a-question-about-guild-guardians-still-dropping-but-why-a-bug/49440


Official Guide:
https://gemsofwar.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/360000544796

[Whisper]

Koromac님이 먼저 게시:

Official Guide:
https://gemsofwar.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/360000544796

Oh, good to know !
Thx for the link.

[Dorgath]

Koromac: Did you also post this on the GoW forums? Someone posted the exact same thing and it turned out he only had 3 copies of Honor at the time when he opened Guild chests, not four as he thought (the devs checked). If this wasn't you, contact Support and have them check for you as well.

[Devonaut1]

Jerry님이 먼저 게시:

There is neither an exception, nor a bug. When opening a chest, you have the chance to gain creatures of a certain rarity or type. The level, your creatures are, does have no influence on this.

Once all your common and rare troops are on mystic, gold chests will not suddenly stop spitting these out. It is the same with guild chests. Sure, it would be nice to rule out the trash drops at a certain amount, but this would conflict with the very concept of loot boxes.

Yes there is, I just explained to you how it works.

[Koromac]

Dorgath님이 먼저 게시:

Koromac: Did you also post this on the GoW forums? Someone posted the exact same thing and it turned out he only had 3 copies of Honor at the time when he opened Guild chests, not four as he thought (the devs checked). If this wasn't you, contact Support and have them check for you as well.

Yes, I did. That was me.

[Dorgath]

Ah, okay :)

[Koromac]

Dorgath님이 먼저 게시:

Ah, okay :)

No more Guild Guardians for me. Not a bug.

[Saltypatra]

I'm glad to see this has all been sorted. We've been trying to make how guild chests work more clear in and out of game, so I'll pass this on.

[Koromac]

Saltypatra님이 먼저 게시:

I'm glad to see this has all been sorted. We've been trying to make how guild chests work more clearly in and out of game, so I'll pass this on.

I already posted the same post as I did in here. I think that they are already aware that's not a bug, since they tagged it before I even had a chance to test it. Still, it's 100% confirmed now.

6 Guaridans x4 will ensure that the next new Chest openings will not drop any more copies.