Welcome to Elderfield

Welcome to Elderfield

Ichimelon Jan 13 @ 11:47am
2
The character art
It really bothers me that the characters in this have the exact same faces as junji ito's characters. I get drawing inspiration but every single one looks like they just traced the face of the characters. The sprite work of the world itself is unique. I would love to see this game work on developing more of its own style with the characters, though.
< >
Showing 1-3 of 3 comments
chris-cote  [developer] Jan 13 @ 2:45pm 
Thanks for the feedback!

I can appreciate that some may not be fans of a deliberate homage/imitation of the art style of another artist, however this is the art style I have personally been using for more than a decade, and is the most "honest" way for me to draw characters. I am a lifelong horror manga fan, and my art style reflects this (not just Junji Ito, though I realize that he is the most well-known in the west, and the most likely to be recognized from the various references in the game).

None of these images are traced, it is just the way have always drawn characters. Junji Ito has a very recognizable and formulaic (in a good way) approach to illustrating characters, so knowing how to illustrate in this way leads to very consistent results. A good comparison would be the recent game "Tales of Mistria", and its imitation of Rumiko Takahashi's art style.

I do intend to keep the horror manga style, and with Junji Ito being my biggest influence, I expect (and intend for) the art to be compared to his. So far, it seems that most people like the inclusion of characters that are imitating his style and it has become a major selling point for the game, but I realize that it wont be everyone's cup of tea.

"World of Horror" is a major influence as well for this game, and so direct references to Ito's character style is sort of continuing an existing tradition.
Last edited by chris-cote; Apr 8 @ 7:43am
I would love if you are the only one that thinks like that, I'm here because the things you dislike
Likorys Apr 8 @ 2:59am 
Originally posted by Ichimelon:
It really bothers me that the characters in this have the exact same faces as junji ito's characters. I get drawing inspiration but every single one looks like they just traced the face of the characters. The sprite work of the world itself is unique. I would love to see this game work on developing more of its own style with the characters, though.

As someone who actualy read pretty much all of Ito's work and earlier horror masters before him: if you can't even name Tomie [who main character looks similar to] then you clearly don't have enough clue to be throwing allegations.
Trying to claim 'realistic eyes with simple lines' as somehow exclusive to Ito and not a branch of manga artstyle is laughable. Please stop throwing accusations with not substane, you can really hurt someone's reputation.
< >
Showing 1-3 of 3 comments
Per page: 1530 50