I must be crazy (SPOILERS)

[Axion]

Stopped the bandits from killing the witch hunter. I guess if I let him get lynched, then that makes me as bad as them. I wanted to show my good side. If I can show one person that magic folk are good people, then I figured it would make a difference. Thoughts? Never read the books, but is it a "Geralt" thing to do?

[Beyuhz]

Geralt died defending non-humans from a pogrom in the books. So yea, it's a Geralt thing to do to defend the underdog in any situation.

[Uranius Johnson]

I did the same. Wanted him to sod off of course, but didn't think he deserved to die that way.

[Axion]

Originally posted by Beyuhz:

Geralt died defending non-humans from a pogrom in the books. So yea, it's a Geralt thing to do to defend the underdog in any situation.

Do you mean in Rivia when a peasant ran a pitchfork through his gut and Yennifer saved him?

[Coin]

Whats good about saving racist maniacal mass murderer.

Originally posted by Morosi:

Do you mean in Rivia when a peasant ran a pitchfork through his gut and Yennifer saved him?

He wasn't really saved. Not entirely.

[Beyuhz]

Originally posted by Morosi:

Originally posted by Beyuhz:

Geralt died defending non-humans from a pogrom in the books. So yea, it's a Geralt thing to do to defend the underdog in any situation.

Do you mean in Rivia when a peasant ran a pitchfork through his gut and Yennifer saved him?

Yeah, Yennefer tried to save him but was dying from it. Too much drain on her or something, so Ciri took them away to some island.

[Axion]

Originally posted by Coin:

Whats good about saving racist maniacal mass murderer.

It doesn't mean that Geralt has to become one. it's like in rl when it is considered wrong to be a vigiliant, even if the person deserves it.

[Locomotive]

I saved a dude from the peasants one time in Velen. Turned out he had robbed them. I only found out about it while on my way to Novigrad when he tried to kill me :(. So much for saving the innocent.

In another case I tried to save a damsel in distress and got chewed out for messing up their practice for the play :(

[Locomotive]

Originally posted by Nixxo:

So only me that bascially kills every witchhunter I come across? Well everyone the game permits me to choke to death with 3 pounds of steel that is.

You can basically fight the entire city of Novigrad if you want lol. Just steal in front of the witch hunter.

[Axion]

Originally posted by Nixxo:

So only me that bascially kills every witchhunter I come across? Well everyone the game permits me to choke to death with 3 pounds of steel that is.

Well there is a difference between killing an unarmed man in cold blood

[Coin]

Originally posted by Morosi:

It doesn't mean that Geralt has to become one. it's like in rl when it is considered wrong to be a vigiliant, even if the person deserves it.

Geralt already is a mass murderer. Also vigiliant argument doesn't really make sense. Just because by the law witch hunters can do whatever the ♥♥♥♥ they want doesn't mean folk shouldn't kill them in return.

Originally posted by Morosi:

Well there is a difference between killing an unarmed man in cold blood

What. 1st of all i bet he was disarmed, secondly how does that make any difference.

[Nixxo]

Witchunter = Not innocent, go ahead, burn, stab and dismember... Feed them to the trolls or make them into dog food... Do with them as you please... That is all I have to say... No need for more posts or comments...

[Locomotive]

Originally posted by Nixxo:

Witchunter = Not innocent... That is all I have to say... No need for more posts or comments...

It's more or less a profession, albeit a ruthless one. We see this a lot with religious fanatics.

[Axion]

Originally posted by Coin:

Originally posted by Morosi:

It doesn't mean that Geralt has to become one. it's like in rl when it is considered wrong to be a vigiliant, even if the person deserves it.

Geralt already is a mass murderer. Also vigiliant argument doesn't really makes sense. Just because by the law witch hunters can do whatever the ♥♥♥♥ they want doesn't mean folk shouldn't kill them in return.

I have no problem killing a witch hunter if they pose a threat. My Geralt hates lynchings. That's why i stopped Peasants from lynching a Nilfgaardian in velen.

[Locomotive]

Originally posted by Morosi:

Originally posted by Coin:

Geralt already is a mass murderer. Also vigiliant argument doesn't really makes sense. Just because by the law witch hunters can do whatever the ♥♥♥♥ they want doesn't mean folk shouldn't kill them in return.

I have no problem killing a witch hunter if they pose a threat. My Geralt hates lynchings. That's why i stopped Peasants from lynching a Nilfgaardian in velen.

You traded 1 life for like 5 others. :(

[Coin]

Originally posted by Morosi:

I have no problem killing a witch hunter if they pose a threat. My Geralt hates lynchings. That's why i stopped Peasants from lynching a Nilfgaardian in velen.

Oh so only you have the right to kill someone when they pose threat to you, but when someone else does it - it's wroing. I see.

Originally posted by Locomotive:

You traded 1 life for like 5 others. :(

A life of mass murdering racist monster to be precise.