What would you rate Witcher 3?

[LastOneAlive]

5 Is average.

I'd give it a 7. Too many reused NPC faces.
Unable to kill Villagers when they spit or pis on me.
As soon as I see a monster it should be in the Beasteary. Not after I kill it. Geralt is almost 100 years old now, he knows a monster by looking at it and so should we.

I appreciate the underwater Crossbow. But, haha, really? That it?

Anyway, my Rating 7/10
Badass seal of approval.
I'd still recommend to all my friends.

[General Rambo]

I'd definitely give it a solid 9/10, Will see what happens when the DLC's come out

[Steven Brattac]

10/10 pc version its that good i bought it as well for my ps4 that i have as backup incase my pc breaksdown .

[XeidiDent]

10/10. Best RPG ever. And I have played a lot of RPGs.

[Regret and Redemption]

Diposting pertama kali oleh thehotsung8701:

Diposting pertama kali oleh Crimsonprodigy:

10/10

Good finale after 1st and 2nd game as well as the books.

The game follow the books this time around instead of the previous two game. It a dream come true for those who read the book but for those who are fan of just the game, it is disappointing.

I give this game an 85 out of 100.

Yeah I'm in the same boat. from a gameplay perspective I love every second of it - but as for story - it's still good, but it feels like it completely cut all ties from the first two games - utterly disconnected. Might be closer to the books - but it really muddied my story experience, having only played the games and not read the books.

Will give it a 90 instead of 85 though, because they put Thaler back in it - he's a "♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ amazing" character. :)

Story gripes aside, one of the best RPGs I've ever played - and you could tell cdpr cared about it's production (despite what some say), just look at every little detail that didn't need to be added, but was anyway. And the quests actually feel personal - not just a game mechanic, nor a means to an end.

[MelvinFtw]

2/10 way too much bugs

[Jackal]

in about a year and a half of bug fixes/ patches/ modding to address issues i'd say about a 8/10
right now its 7 or 6 out of 10, too many crashes, too many bugs, game breaking bugs, unbalanced, performance is poor even on my top of the line machine, controls too poorly

[Steven Brattac]

Diposting pertama kali oleh XeidiDent:

10/10. Best RPG ever. And I have played a lot of RPGs.

I dident mention it open but the dephth of some family tragedies that unfold along the maintree are awesome set and spoken and you hardly can hold back some tears from time to time . Witchery is woven artlike into the medieval warlike times of that universe of Geralt! Hatoff!

[Regret and Redemption]

But how can you be sure it's the games fualt that there are bugs? For example, if it works on MY rig - why wouldn't it work on yours just as well? We both have the same code installed - It boils down to hardware, drivers, and 3rd party apps at that point.

[DeGorro82]

10/10 of years 2015 era. No games that use voice-over for every mission, literally. Even the shortest quest like help a villager get trouble by bandits, had it's own cutscenes. This is the new minimum standard of any RPG Story games basic line "a must have".

Playing TW3 using shortcut Road sign will make you loose any small but detailed moment like this. This is an adventure game, the hero will see many event on his road ride. And this game provide story, so damn too much I can digest. (in a good way)

Also, maybe you said there been many re-use of head models to NPC, but, if you pay attention to the voice of each NPC, they have their own color on their language. This game is like Pillars of Eternity. While PoE we need to read much to understand the depth of the game, in TW3, all you need to do is hear it.

[dadzilla]

10.5 you may ask why the .5 simply because now any other developers out there who try to shovel up our arse one more fetch quest will face our game godly wrath! lol

[Steven Brattac]

Diposting pertama kali oleh DeGorro82:

10/10 of years 2015 era. No games that use voice-over for every mission, literally. Even the shortest quest like help a villager get trouble by bandits, had it's own cutscenes. This is the new minimum standard of any RPG Story games basic line "a must have".

Playing TW3 using shortcut Road sign will make you loose any small but detailed moment like this. This is an adventure game, the hero will see many event on his road ride. And this game provide story, so damn too much I can digest. (in a good way)

Also, maybe you said there been many re-use of head models to NPC, but, if you pay attention to the voice of each NPC, they have their own color on their language. This game is like Pillars of Eternity. While PoE we need to read much to understand the depth of the game, in TW3, all you need to do is hear it.

True that i went 4 times the same road at different occasions and found 5 different enemies on that same spot atackin me or lurkin by or havin a nest to remove. that ups the reason to go back and search for resources in old known spots . Awesome it gives a reason to take wanderings off the Mainroute! This looks evolved and more believable than other rpgs where you clear out a zone and it is free forever and no wandering monsters fill that empty space !

[kurosect]

Diposting pertama kali oleh -Silver the Dragon-:

True that i went 4 times the same road at different occasions and found 5 different enemies on that same spot atackin me or lurkin by or havin a nest to remove. that ups the reason to go back and search for resources in old known spots . Awesome it gives a reason to take wanderings off the Mainroute! This looks evolved and more believable than other rpgs where you clear out a zone and it is free forever and no wandering monsters fill that empty space !

I'm pretty sure monster nests are fixed and only basic monsters like wolves/endregas/drowners/nekkers/hags respawn that much.

[GLaDOS]

Your villagers piss on you? Damn

[XeidiDent]

These guys are easily the best devs these days. I hope they don't screw things up. I liked this game so much that I'm gonna buy it on GOG too. Also, I hope they put the same effort on Cyberpunk 2077.

[DeGorro82]

Diposting pertama kali oleh XeidiDent:

These guys are easily the best devs these days. I hope they don't screw things up. I liked this game so much that I'm gonna buy it on GOG too. Also, I hope they put the same effort on Cyberpunk 2077.

Think Cyberpunk 2077, if it similar genre to TW3, which is story base... would be even darker.