Lambert's Quest Decisions (Spoilers)

[Herb & Bea Ehltée]

So, who did you kill or not kill here? The drunk elf former scoia'teal girl at the bar? And Karadin?

I killed the elf girl because a rather ambiguous dialog choice led directly to it, and decided not to reload the save.

As for Karadin, I'm not sure which option to go with and what repercussions it might have. I read the letter from him to Hammond saying he wanted no part in a proposed joint business venture or anything to do with him at all really, indicating some sort of repentance or desire to move on, and he did seem to have a peaceful family life going on.

On the other hand, his voice actor made him seem kind of mild mannered and yet somewhat arrogant, so the dialog option where Gerralt says his remorse is feigned seems to me in part correct. Still not sure whose side of the story is right though. Lambert seems to have had a great deal of respect for Aiden and clearly doesn't believe a word of Karadin's story, but Lambert also seems like a hot head.

Keep in mind I play through all RPGs first as goody two-shoes, but not to the point of shirking deserved revenge. Just unsure if this fellow Karadin is full of it or not.

What did you do? Any terrible repercussions to leaving Karadin's wife a widow? Sparing him?

[Herb & Bea Ehltée]

Bumpenproletariat.

Nobody got this quest yet? All keywords I can think of bring nothing on these forums and google.

[Mikey]

Killed them all. Let Freya sort out the bad seeds

[O)))]

I didn't kill him because whichever was true, there simply wasn't any reasonable evidence past Lambert's word that he was guilty. Strangely, I did that quest way before even getting to Kaer Morhen and while Lambert leaves visibly pissed, he never brings it up again. So on that end, I don't think it matters what you do.

[AmAtic]

I let Lambert decide what to do with the elf girl, so that meant we ended up fighting, and had to kill her. Killed Hammond myself, but I let Karadin live. I told Lambert he could go and finish him off later if fhe wanted to, but I guess he was to big of a ♥♥♥♥♥ to do that himself.

[Herb & Bea Ehltée]

Ok, thanks for the input. I'll let him live then.

[Amazing]

Originally posted by Am4tic:

I let Lambert decide what to do with the elf girl, so that meant we ended up fighting, and had to kill her. Killed Hammond myself, but I let Karadin live. I told Lambert he could go and finish him off later if fhe wanted to, but I guess he was to big of a ♥♥♥♥♥ to do that himself.

he passed that because he was in debt with Gerald, when Gerald say this is the situation you have to listen to a cool-head friend that mean he want to remind Lambert that he owned Gerald a favor,now Lambert has to respect that in term of friendship

[Lulzifer]

I spared the elf girl, because you don't kill women, and spared Karadin, because he had a family to take care of, even though he sounded disingenuous.
Had to kill Hammond, though, because he attacked me outright.
Too bad I did not get a choice to talk to the brother owner instead of Lambert, because he ends up killing her.

[Tirigon]

They are murderers, and murder doesnt stop being a crime just because you have a family.


It's not a hard choice to make. In case that's unclear: Kill all of them.

[Locomotive]

Originally posted by Tirigon, the White Wolf:

They are murderers, and murder doesnt stop being a crime just because you have a family.


It's not a hard choice to make. In case that's unclear: Kill all of them.

I didn't read the damn note before I killed him lol. Oh well. I thought he was still the bad guy haha.

[Planeforger]

Originally posted by Tirigon, the White Wolf:

They are murderers, and murder doesnt stop being a crime just because you have a family.


It's not a hard choice to make. In case that's unclear: Kill all of them.

That's only true if you believe that he is a murderer.

If what he was saying is true, they never planned to kill Lambert's friend - but the friend provoked them, and the sniper got antsy and killed him. If true...I wouldn't say that he necessarily deserves to die for that, especially as it looks like he is completely out of that business now.

[BT]

I killed him because I wanted to try a new sword

[Cool Doge]

I spare the girl. Kill Hammond and Karadin. Hammond is jerk so I feel no pity for him. For Karadin. I have soft side for fellow witcher due we're fewer and fewer everyday. But I respect Lambert opinion about his friend. He's hot head yeah, but dont mean he's stupid. I think he know his friend so I decide that Karadin lied. And kill him to please Lambert haha.

[Tirigon]

Originally posted by Planeforger:

Originally posted by Tirigon, the White Wolf:

They are murderers, and murder doesnt stop being a crime just because you have a family.


It's not a hard choice to make. In case that's unclear: Kill all of them.

That's only true if you believe that he is a murderer.

If what he was saying is true, they never planned to kill Lambert's friend - but the friend provoked them, and the sniper got antsy and killed him. If true...I wouldn't say that he necessarily deserves to die for that, especially as it looks like he is completely out of that business now.

Except he is a mercenary. Maybe he didnt kill Lambert's Friend - he surely killed others, though, and given the wartorn stage of the world his death is one that surely won't be mourned.

[goodbye_bonito]

Originally posted by Tirigon, the White Wolf:

Originally posted by Planeforger:

That's only true if you believe that he is a murderer.

If what he was saying is true, they never planned to kill Lambert's friend - but the friend provoked them, and the sniper got antsy and killed him. If true...I wouldn't say that he necessarily deserves to die for that, especially as it looks like he is completely out of that business now.

Except he is a mercenary. Maybe he didnt kill Lambert's Friend - he surely killed others, though, and given the wartorn stage of the world his death is one that surely won't be mourned.

And how many people has killed Geralt? As mercenary or just for fun. He surely not a person to judge in this situation.
Also it will be mourned by his kids, wife and city.

Your logic is weird.

[Coin]

I see ppl sparing the woman. You'r so sexist...

Originally posted by Ukrop:

And how many people has killed Geralt? As mercenary or just for fun. He surely not a person to judge in this situation.
Also it will be mourned by his kids, wife and city.

Your logic is weird.

Geralt kills out of necessity, his not a thug or even a mercenary. You see, there is difference between normal people and those who gets under his blade.