Fyke Isle, what did you all do about Keira, and why? [Obvious spoilers inside]

[Homer Morisson]

Regarding the end of Keira's little quest chain, how did you decide to end it, did you kill her, did you let her keep the documents, did you convince her to come to Kaer Morhen instead of going to Radovid?

And why did you decide that way?

Personally I think Geralt has every right to confront her about her being a manipulative, lying ♥♥♥♥♥, seeing as she did in fact lie to Geralt multiple times over the course of her quest chain, multiple times had opportunities to simply ask him for help in retrieving those documents, but instead she chose to lie, manipulate and obfuscate.

Furthermore, after chosing to confront her, it's actually her who still won't apologize, instead playing the hurt victim and refusing any further conversation, thereby forcing the issue and Geralt's hand.

That's why I decided to kill her rather than letting her take the Documents about how to turn Katriona into a Bioweapon to Radovid the Mad.

How 'bout you all?

[HUX]

I don't know enough about the game to know which decision is best (if there is one)

I chose to take the notes and convinced her to go to Kaer Morhen.
Yes, she is not a loyal person and tells lies, manipulates Geralt.

But overall I just feel like Geralt is being manipulated by all the women in this game :)
He has to do with it.

I also feel like Keira isn't a bad person.
Geralt needs to contain her anger and Geralt needs to take more steps to get her to trust him.

Nobody's perfect, and I think Keira doesn't deserve a fight and a death, but to be protected as much as other witches.

The future will tell me if I was wrong or right to do so :)

[Homer Morisson]

Thanks for your in-depth reply, exactly what I was looking for. =)

I could tell you the consequences, but only if you explicitely ask for them, otherwise I'd recommend just experiencing them for yourself.

Either way, it's nothing too major, mostly fluff results, but nice to have.^^

[Cap. Levi]

Originally posted by Homer Morisson:

Regarding the end of Keira's little quest chain, how did you decide to end it, did you kill her, did you let her keep the documents, did you convince her to come to Kaer Morhen instead of going to Radovid?

And why did you decide that way?

Personally I think Geralt has every right to confront her about her being a manipulative, lying ♥♥♥♥♥, seeing as she did in fact lie to Geralt multiple times over the course of her quest chain, multiple times had opportunities to simply ask him for help in retrieving those documents, but instead she chose to lie, manipulate and obfuscate.

Furthermore, after chosing to confront her, it's actually her who still won't apologize, instead playing the hurt victim and refusing any further conversation, thereby forcing the issue and Geralt's hand.

That's why I decided to kill her rather than letting her take the Documents about how to turn Katriona into a Bioweapon to Radovid the Mad.

How 'bout you all?

I still have to do that quest.. but from my perspective, keira only lied but did not want to kill geralt. bcoz of her lying, killing someone is a far more crime

[Sentient_Toaster]

Sent her to KM. She's still a potentially rather useful asset, and Geralt has much bigger problems to deal with -- like, oh, the Wild Hunt, and that both Radovid and Emhyr would love to have him killed for insubordination as soon as it were convenient to do so. Having her on board might be helpful if you want to make allies of any of the other Lodge members.

'sides, by this point you've probably manipulated people with actual mind control magic quite a few times. :P

[Graf Erik]

Yeah, Keira was lying to manipulate Gerald. That what all these sorceresses do through out the game(s).

I called her out on it, and told her to go to Keir Morhen. She can then make up for it by helping us defend against the wild hunt.

Better than kill her or get her killed on the stake.

[GoreTiger]

Banged her, Convinced her to go to Kaer morhen, Took the research from her.

She hooks up with one of your witcher friends and they live happily ever after.

[Homer Morisson]

Originally posted by Cap. Levi:

Originally posted by Homer Morisson:

Regarding the end of Keira's little quest chain, how did you decide to end it, did you kill her, did you let her keep the documents, did you convince her to come to Kaer Morhen instead of going to Radovid?

And why did you decide that way?

Personally I think Geralt has every right to confront her about her being a manipulative, lying ♥♥♥♥♥, seeing as she did in fact lie to Geralt multiple times over the course of her quest chain, multiple times had opportunities to simply ask him for help in retrieving those documents, but instead she chose to lie, manipulate and obfuscate.

Furthermore, after chosing to confront her, it's actually her who still won't apologize, instead playing the hurt victim and refusing any further conversation, thereby forcing the issue and Geralt's hand.

That's why I decided to kill her rather than letting her take the Documents about how to turn Katriona into a Bioweapon to Radovid the Mad.

How 'bout you all?

I still have to do that quest.. but from my perspective, keira only lied but did not want to kill geralt. bcoz of her lying, killing someone is a far more crime

Welp, depending on the route you choose throughout the quest, an innocent man will die because of Keira's manipulation and lies, plus it's Keira who initiates combat when Geralt tells her she can't keep the documents, that's what I meant by her forcing his hand... so in my opinion, she made her bed and now she has to lie in it.

[GoreTiger]

Originally posted by Homer Morisson:

Originally posted by Cap. Levi:

I still have to do that quest.. but from my perspective, keira only lied but did not want to kill geralt. bcoz of her lying, killing someone is a far more crime

Welp, depending on the route you choose throughout the quest, an innocent man will die because of Keira's manipulation and lies, plus it's Keira who initiates combat when Geralt tells her she can't keep the documents, that's what I meant by her forcing his hand... so in my opinion, she made her bed and now she has to lie in it.

Keira isn't at fault for the fisherman's death. Even tho she asked geralt to investigate fyke isle, The specter situation was all geralt's job. HE makes that call, not her. Geralt also fails to fully explain to the guy the negatives of what could happen in the situation.

Plus "innocent" is up for debate. You can find some ghosts around the back of the wall who're claiming the plan was for the fisherman to get them to open the gate so they can rush in, Makes it sound like he was the trojan horse. Likely he planned on running off with her while everyone was looting the tower since he hated her father, he just didn't realize that the other peasents hated the whole family.

[Graf Erik]

Originally posted by Homer Morisson:

Welp, depending on the route you choose throughout the quest, an innocent man will die because of Keira's manipulation and lies...

An innocent man will die?

Who? You can't possibly mean Graham. He went to the tower together with his friends, armed to the teath, torches, pitchforks and all, for one reason: To raid the place.
He went to the door and was like "Hey guys! Its me! Your fellow fishermen. Open the door, we will totaly not kill you all".
He certainly didn't plan to kill Anabelle, but he knew his friends weren't up to a friendly chat.

I always send Anabelle to clear things up with him. He deserves it.

Keira has... not much to do with this. She just asks Gerald to get rid of the curse. The curse that Graham created.

[Homer Morisson]

Graham wasn't in on the plan, that was Milli and the others who decided to murder everyone and rape Annabelle.

Graham was only told they wanted to ask for alms, he did NOT know beforehand what they were planning to do.

And Geralt was manipulated into clearing that curse by Keira, otherwise he'd never even have learned about it, and Keira manipulated him with the sole intention of getting her hands on the documents, she never once cared about any altruistic motives.

[GoreTiger]

Originally posted by Graf Erik:

Originally posted by Homer Morisson:

Welp, depending on the route you choose throughout the quest, an innocent man will die because of Keira's manipulation and lies...

An innocent man will die?

Who? You can't possibly mean Graham. He went to the tower together with his friends, armed to the teath, torches, pitchforks and all, for one reason: To raid the place.
He went to the door and was like "Hey guys! Its me! Your fellow fishermen. Open the door, we will totaly not kill you all".
He certainly didn't plan to kill Anabelle, but he knew his friends weren't up to a friendly chat.

I always send Anabelle to clear things up with him. He deserves it.

Keira has... not much to do with this. She just asks Gerald to get rid of the curse. The curse that Graham created.

Don't send her out of the isle, bring graham there. Sending her out basically gives her free reign as a maiden to terrorize the land.

Originally posted by Homer Morisson:

Graham wasn't in on the plan, that was Milli and the others who decided to murder everyone and rape Annabelle.

Graham was only told they wanted to ask for alms, he did NOT know beforehand what they were planning to do.

And Geralt was manipulated into clearing that curse by Keira, otherwise he'd never even have learned about it, and Keira manipulated him with the sole intention of getting her hands on the documents, she never once cared about any altruistic motives.

Graham's words don't hold up with what the ghosts around the isle were claiming.
Plus I highly doubt graham saw all his buddies loading up with weapons in boats and thought nothing was going to come of it. You don't bring pitchforks to an island to beg for alms.
He was likely lying to geralt about not knowing. I mean in his eyes, who could prove that he was? No way geralt could of known what happened on the isle.

[Raxus]

I always kill her. She keeps lying to the white wolf and the white wolf had enough. Geralt aint playing games no more!

[Cap. Levi]

Originally posted by Cap. Levi:

Originally posted by Homer Morisson:

Regarding the end of Keira's little quest chain, how did you decide to end it, did you kill her, did you let her keep the documents, did you convince her to come to Kaer Morhen instead of going to Radovid?

And why did you decide that way?

Personally I think Geralt has every right to confront her about her being a manipulative, lying ♥♥♥♥♥, seeing as she did in fact lie to Geralt multiple times over the course of her quest chain, multiple times had opportunities to simply ask him for help in retrieving those documents, but instead she chose to lie, manipulate and obfuscate.

Furthermore, after chosing to confront her, it's actually her who still won't apologize, instead playing the hurt victim and refusing any further conversation, thereby forcing the issue and Geralt's hand.

That's why I decided to kill her rather than letting her take the Documents about how to turn Katriona into a Bioweapon to Radovid the Mad.

How 'bout you all?

I still have to do that quest.. but from my perspective, keira only lied but did not want to kill geralt. bcoz of her lying, killing someone is a far more crime

i dont know who gonna die coz of keira .. if you are talking about graham, it was simply graham's choice.. also..

spoiler alert..











i think if you kill keira here, lambert is gonna die as well in battle of kaer mohan. if keira lives, he lives and they will live happily ever after. So, i guess keira does not deserve to die simple cause of lie and manipulation.. she also gonna save lambert's life

[Alexis Machine]

Originally posted by Homer Morisson:

Regarding the end of Keira's little quest chain, how did you decide to end it, did you kill her, did you let her keep the documents, did you convince her to come to Kaer Morhen instead of going to Radovid?

And why did you decide that way?

Personally I think Geralt has every right to confront her about her being a manipulative, lying ♥♥♥♥♥, seeing as she did in fact lie to Geralt multiple times over the course of her quest chain, multiple times had opportunities to simply ask him for help in retrieving those documents, but instead she chose to lie, manipulate and obfuscate.

Furthermore, after chosing to confront her, it's actually her who still won't apologize, instead playing the hurt victim and refusing any further conversation, thereby forcing the issue and Geralt's hand.

That's why I decided to kill her rather than letting her take the Documents about how to turn Katriona into a Bioweapon to Radovid the Mad.

How 'bout you all?

Send her to K.M. for sure; she may be vain and somewhat manipulative, but both in the game and in the books, she is NOT a bad person and in W3 she helps both Avallac'h and Geralt; she is NOT the one who experimented on the poor villagers in first place, she is merely, desperately trying to find a way to survive, and the research of her deceased colleague in her panicked mind appears as a life saving grace. Her behaviour is understandable, albeit not justifiable, when you consider that she is basically a fugitive on the run, risking a horrible death if caught by either Radovid's or Emhyr's forces. And don't forget, if you allow her to live, besides saving Lambert's life, she will be the one to ultimately find a cure for the Catriona Plague, proving that she is not that bad...

[Neon Noodles]

Well see I had opinions on her actions all the way until I clapped them cheeks. Then I forgave everything, and asked her to go to Kaer Morhen.

It may not have went down exactly like that, but that's how I remember it!