Tower of Mice Is there a way to save Graham?

[KoolBreeze]

Is there a 3rd scenario that allows you to save Graham? I have found 2 different ending scenarios and he dies in both.

[Barefoot]

don't do the quest is only way i know to keep him safe

[cozycorewitch]

Wait Im confused...I brought the bones to Graham and he said he would bury them, I left the cabin and then....nothing? I talked to Keira after and when she asked how it went I just told her that Graham just had to bury the bones so I assumed the curse was lifted. He never died, Annabelle never revealed she was a plague maiden & the quest just ended. Everything I'm seeing on google says that I was supposed to get a different ending and now I am confused lol

[Alex_x86]

Originalmente postado por CelestialFoxxy:

Wait Im confused...I brought the bones to Graham and he said he would bury them, I left the cabin and then....nothing? I talked to Keira after and when she asked how it went I just told her that Graham just had to bury the bones so I assumed the curse was lifted. He never died, Annabelle never revealed she was a plague maiden & the quest just ended. Everything I'm seeing on google says that I was supposed to get a different ending and now I am confused lol

When you were few steps from Graham house you should've hear scream, if you go back you would find dead Graham and something else. Then Geralt would realize that by bringing bones he set Plague Maiden free. However if you did not came back to the house Geralt did not find out this -- ignorance is bliss :P

[Barefoot]

Originalmente postado por Alex_x86:

Originalmente postado por CelestialFoxxy:

Wait Im confused...I brought the bones to Graham and he said he would bury them, I left the cabin and then....nothing? I talked to Keira after and when she asked how it went I just told her that Graham just had to bury the bones so I assumed the curse was lifted. He never died, Annabelle never revealed she was a plague maiden & the quest just ended. Everything I'm seeing on google says that I was supposed to get a different ending and now I am confused lol

When you were few steps from Graham house you should've hear scream, if you go back you would find dead Graham and something else. Then Geralt would realize that by bringing bones he set Plague Maiden free. However if you did not came back to the house Geralt did not find out this -- ignorance is bliss :P

/nods ignorance is bliss

[SegaSunset]

From what I remember playing back old saves, he dies twice. Bringing the bones to him, or having him go back to the tower to confess mistaking her death not knowing she drank poison. Make him die feeling "grief" or "acceptance". The third way plays out by not trusting her ghost & provoking her with some dialogue i think. She turns into a Pesta, you kill it, curse lifted. Thus not involving him?

[Valden21]

Originalmente postado por SegaSunset:

From what I remember playing back old saves, he dies twice. Bringing the bones to him, or having him go back to the tower to confess mistaking her death not knowing she drank poison. Make him die feeling "grief" or "acceptance". The third way plays out by not trusting her ghost & provoking her with some dialogue i think. She turns into a Pesta, you kill it, curse lifted. Thus not involving him?

No, that's what triggers the second way to complete the quest. There's only two ways to complete the quest, and Graham dies in both. The big difference is that in the one where Graham brings Annabelle's bones to the tower, she remains a pesta and breaks free to roam the world. In the one where he returns and tells her the full story, that lifts the curse that and allows her spirit to peacefully pass on. She's no longer a pesta in that one.

[SegaSunset]

There are multiple ways man not just two. you just have to play around with dialogues choices. Like If you make him go back to the tower to confess, my first playthrough she didn't turn into a Pesta to roam free like you said. For me He kissed her in her monster form and she transformed back to humanoid form & passed on no trouble, but the kiss kills him anyway.

[Barefoot]

omg some people official guide says

This quest can be finished in two ways. If you want, during the conversation with Anabelle you can agree to deliver Anabelle's Remains to Graham. Leave the tower, jump to the boat and go north to Oreton village. Find Graham's hut there, talk to him and give him the remains. After getting away from the hut, you will hear Graham's scream. Go back to the hut and you will discover that the man is dead. You can meet again with Keira Metz - tell her that the curse is lifted and that Graham died. The sorceress will give you another quest - A Favor for a Friend.

Another solution to the quest is not helping Anabelle. In that case, trying to leave the tower or speaking about finding the corpse during conversation will lead to a battle with the ghost. During the battle you should depend mostly on the Yrden witcher sign. After Anabelle loses some health, she will try to escape. You must catch her and participate in another duel. After that, listen to a brief conversation with Keira and go to Oreton to meet with Graham. Explain the situation to the man and return with him to the tower. Go back to the highest floor of the building. Kill some ghouls on the way. At the top, watch a cutscene in which Graham dies and the curse is lifted from Anabelle. As in the first option, go back to Keira Metz and you will receive another quest

[Barefoot]

if you cant accept this then take it up with CD-projekt, those are the only 2 ways this can go, thats the guide i bought online from them directly

or third option dont do the quest and he doesnt die Keira is a B**** anyways

[SegaSunset]

Here you go, my proof. Right at the 22:00 minute mark. Idk who the youtuber is, just the first video that popped up
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pj3F-M4REPQ

[Barefoot]

what proof still die's.....

[Barefoot]

Originalmente postado por SegaSunset:

From what I remember playing back old saves, he dies twice. Bringing the bones to him, or having him go back to the tower to confess mistaking her death not knowing she drank poison. Make him die feeling "grief" or "acceptance". The third way plays out by not trusting her ghost & provoking her with some dialogue i think. She turns into a Pesta, you kill it, curse lifted. Thus not involving him?

....

[SegaSunset]

You said there are only two ways & if i can't accept it take it up with cdpr.. I showed you a third. Idk what else to say lol.

[Barefoot]

the original post asks

Originalmente postado por KoolBreeze:

Is there a 3rd scenario that allows you to save Graham? I have found 2 different ending scenarios and he dies in both.

key word Save

[cozycorewitch]

Originalmente postado por Alex_x86:

Originalmente postado por CelestialFoxxy:

Wait Im confused...I brought the bones to Graham and he said he would bury them, I left the cabin and then....nothing? I talked to Keira after and when she asked how it went I just told her that Graham just had to bury the bones so I assumed the curse was lifted. He never died, Annabelle never revealed she was a plague maiden & the quest just ended. Everything I'm seeing on google says that I was supposed to get a different ending and now I am confused lol

When you were few steps from Graham house you should've hear scream, if you go back you would find dead Graham and something else. Then Geralt would realize that by bringing bones he set Plague Maiden free. However if you did not came back to the house Geralt did not find out this -- ignorance is bliss :P

oops. that's what I get for playing with no sound while my kids slept ig LOL