Tower of Mice Is there a way to save Graham?

[KoolBreeze]

Is there a 3rd scenario that allows you to save Graham? I have found 2 different ending scenarios and he dies in both.

[KoolBreeze]

Nguyên văn bởi SegaSunset:

From what I remember playing back old saves, he dies twice. Bringing the bones to him, or having him go back to the tower to confess mistaking her death not knowing she drank poison. Make him die feeling "grief" or "acceptance". The third way plays out by not trusting her ghost & provoking her with some dialogue i think. She turns into a Pesta, you kill it, curse lifted. Thus not involving him?

I said no fought her outside got Graham and he died. I found no way to save him which is why i'm asking if there is third method some endings have 3 but it seems there are only two for this one.

[KoolBreeze]

Nguyên văn bởi SegaSunset:

You said there are only two ways & if i can't accept it take it up with cdpr.. I showed you a third. Idk what else to say lol.

There are only two ways the video you posted is one way the other is to take her bones to Graham and he dies in both of these scenarios what is the third? Although in the video there is a difference in dialogue the ending is the same. I backed out of that conversation due to only having to choices help or leave, then I left to go get Graham when I got outside the Pest attacked me I fought her off then went and got Graham he kissed her an died.

[Valden21]

Nguyên văn bởi SegaSunset:

Here you go, my proof. Right at the 22:00 minute mark. Idk who the youtuber is, just the first video that popped up
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pj3F-M4REPQ

That's not the "third way". That's the second way to complete the quest.

There are only two endings to this quest In one, Geralt does what what Annabelle wants him to do, which is bringing her bones to Graham so that he'll bury them. Afterwards, back at the tower, she'll kill him while Geralt's back is turned. That's ending #1.

If you disagree to that, she'll then turn into a Pesta when you try to leave the tower, forcing you to try an alternate method to removing the curse. That alternate method is convincing Graham to return to the tower and tell Annabelle the full story of what happened. If he does that, he'll kiss her and die in the process, and her spirit will pass on shortly afterwards due to the curse being lifted because of their love for each other. That's ending #2.

There you go; 2 ways to complete the quest. ONLY two ways, and Graham dies in both. The only difference between the two is whether or not Annabelle remains a Pesta.

[DD3650]

Fyke Island and its role in recent events in Velen make this one of the more interesting side quests in the game.

[KoolBreeze]

Nguyên văn bởi DD3650:

Fyke Island and its role in recent events in Velen make this one of the more interesting side quests in the game.

How so? This event is barely a quest what makes it interesting?

[SimranZenov]

Nguyên văn bởi KoolBreeze:

How so? This event is barely a quest what makes it interesting?

You didn't find it interesting? Using the lamp to see the past in the form of ghostly shadows, the interesting story, the scientific experiments, a love story ending in tragedy...

I'm not sure what you expect from a "SIDE" quest. Side-quests are not going to be full-blown stories if that's what you're expecting. It's extremely good for a side quest.

[KoolBreeze]

Nguyên văn bởi SimranZenov:

Nguyên văn bởi KoolBreeze:

How so? This event is barely a quest what makes it interesting?

You didn't find it interesting? Using the lamp to see the past in the form of ghostly shadows, the interesting story, the scientific experiments, a love story ending in tragedy...

I'm not sure what you expect from a "SIDE" quest. Side-quests are not going to be full-blown stories if that's what you're expecting. It's extremely good for a side quest.

When you put it that way I suppose I could understand but it never stood out to me in the 1st play-through so I didn't find it that interesting or at least not interesting enough to remember it. I truly wish there was a way to save Graham then it would have likely stood out.

[KromeHWI]

currious if you ever see her again if she gets away? i decided to trust her and she killed the guy and vanished. oops. i could try to run it again, but from what im reading it doesnt seem like it makes any difference on if you can romance the witch or not, so ill prolly just leave it be and chalk it up to the consequences of trying to do the right thing. but the only thing im currious about is it you let her get away, do you ever see her again? like, does this have in game ramifications? can you kill her later?