Love the game but there's zero replay value

[𝕊𝕃𝕊𝔸𝕄𝔾♔]

I can't be the only one that feels this way, right?

[Søn of Jøn]

theGOAT eredeti hozzászólása:

I can't be the only one that feels this way, right?

I don't see how you could think that, especially considering there are dialog choices and other situations in the game that cause many events to change and even major secondary quests to be missed entirely. I'm on my second playthrough now, doing things differently than the first time and also coming across quests I wasn't even aware had existed the first time around.

I would say it has more replay value than most games could ever hope to achieve.

[VolkNasty]

Well... I hit over 100 hours in my playthrough and hadn't even got through Skellige. SO I decided to just do a "maximum effort" run and get as many as the quests and POI cleared. That means I will only be playing this game once. I played through W2 3 times, so maybe in 10 years I'll give it another go; by that time CDPR will have pumped out 3 Cyberpunk games and will be ready to circle back around to the Witcher series.

[JOT DAT DA]

I wish I did not play it on console the first time....

[VolkNasty]

BuzzardBee eredeti hozzászólása:

VolkNasty eredeti hozzászólása:

Well... I hit over 100 hours in my playthrough and hadn't even got through Skellige. SO I decided to just do a "maximum effort" run and get as many as the quests and POI cleared. That means I will only be playing this game once. I played through W2 3 times, so maybe in 10 years I'll give it another go; by that time CDPR will have pumped out 3 Cyberpunk games and will be ready to circle back around to the Witcher series.

3 Cyberpunk games in 10 years? Jeez, they'll be lucky if they just get out the one out in that time.

Yeah I mean, 2077 is coming out next year, that's almost 10 years for 2 games. It can be done.

[ForevaNoob Wonemorturn]

If you play it as a roleplaying game should be played, you can not make different choices than your soul already told you to make the first time, and you will always end up choosing the same choice, according to the one and only human being you are. This is where I totally agree with you when you say this Witcher 3 game, if you succeed making that Geralt character your own, 'meaning making him yourself, or the other way around, like it should be done in a so called roleplaying game, hence the name, you'ld end up always making the same choice, according to your only one existence and flavor. You're not testing options, but living such a story. And you're living it as you are.
And you're right again: there is no, 0, none, replaying value in that game, for this is why it is such a great game.

I, for instance, never replayed WItcher 3.
And I knew it as soon as I throw that snowball at Ciri.
I knew I would always threw that ball, instead of playing safe and living bored.
For this is how and who I am, a snowball thrower, and always will be...

[𝕊𝕃𝕊𝔸𝕄𝔾♔]

ForevaNoob Wonemorturn eredeti hozzászólása:

If you play it as a roleplaying game should be played, you can not make different choices than your soul already told you to make the first time, and you will always end up choosing the same choice, according to the one and only human being you are. This is where I totally agree with you when you say this Witcher 3 game, if you succeed making that Geralt character your own, 'meaning making him yourself, or the other way around, like it should be done in a so called roleplaying game, hence the name, you'ld end up always making the same choice, according to your only one existence and flavor. You're not testing options, but living such a story. And you're living it as you are.
And you're right again: there is no, 0, none, replaying value in that game, for this is why it is such a great game.

I, for instance, never replayed WItcher 3.
And I knew it as soon as I throw that snowball at Ciri.
I knew I would always threw that ball, instead of playing safe and living bored.
For this is how and who I am, a snowball thrower, and always will be...

I don't even...

[Halcyform]

theGOAT eredeti hozzászólása:

I can't be the only one that feels this way, right?

I wouldn't say that it has no replay value. I believe it does, but, just like you, I never felt compelled to replay it.

[Goran]

Would be great if CDPR could remake Witcher 1 and 2 with the W3 graphics, combat and so on... this would be so great because W1 is a really nice game. The story is great. Just the combat sucks.

[belangf]

I think it does have replay value. But even if I played only once I already got 5x my money's worth. It`s by far the most time I got in a single playthrough for one game (and I'm not even done at 120h).

[CHUBBS PETERSON]

COSMOS eredeti hozzászólása:

I wish I did not play it on console the first time....

Same bro lol
Played 300 hours on consoles before i bought my PC

[gr4yw4rd3n]

I've played for 40hours and it seems only just scratching the surface. I think I will played at least 200hours. Who need replay value if you reached 200hours...

[Goran]

gr4yw4rd3n eredeti hozzászólása:

I've played for 40hours and it seems only just scratching the surface. I think I will played at least 200hours. Who need replay value if you reached 200hours...

Run around and discover places. Talk to every merchant, visit every house you can see on the map because you can find so many nice things and hidden quests out there. Dont run just on the paths. Go to the forest. If you like Gwent, challenge people around. Some of them have nice rare cards you can get if you win. This game is pretty sure 200 hours at least for the main game and the two DLCs. Even more.

[Halcyform]

Darkslav eredeti hozzászólása:

gr4yw4rd3n eredeti hozzászólása:

I've played for 40hours and it seems only just scratching the surface. I think I will played at least 200hours. Who need replay value if you reached 200hours...

Run around and discover places. Talk to every merchant, visit every house you can see on the map because you can find so many nice things and hidden quests out there. Dont run just on the paths. Go to the forest. If you like Gwent, challenge people around. Some of them have nice rare cards you can get if you win. This game is pretty sure 200 hours at least for the main game and the two DLCs. Even more.

That's been my experience. I doubt I have 100% completion, but main game and DLCs complete put me at around 210 hours.

[AdApt*]

Play it once, play NG+ for a new build and explore different dialogue choice outcomes and it's pretty much a done deal. There is a ton of content here though and the game is a work of art.

teh Johnson eredeti hozzászólása:

I would say it has more replay value than most games could ever hope to achieve.

Disagree with this. But that's your opinion.

There a ton of games, especially indie games with very high replayability coming from randomly generated content, unlocks, multiplayer/co-op, etc..

[JuX]

It's pretty pointless to critize the game for "lack of replayability". You will definitely get your moneys worth out of the game. Even for a casual gamer who isn't after completionist status, can rack up +100 hours in this game easily on a single play through.