Osrya Raedric's Hold

[Ringus]

She seems evil with all the undead around her...but she wants to cure.. She wants me to kill Nedmar which is evil.. but Nedmar appears to be holing up any cure.

I am confused as to what to do, I am play as mainly a good charcter ..but this evil deed seems to be good?

Basilcly I dont want to screw up my reputation will I do that if a kill Nedmar?

[Ringus]

nothing?

[Fi, Daughter of the Godeater]

Shades of grey(♥♥♥♥) deal. Which one do you agree with more, or, if extremely cynical, which one has the better lie.

[Ringus]

yep not a clue.. lol make me nervous because I dont know what long term effects... both choices mean murder

[Fi, Daughter of the Godeater]

Technically, you can free Ned's child by way of mechanics without killing Osrya.

[Lunessence]

I'm at this junction in the game right now, too. After Osrya said that she had information about possibly being able to suture a Hollowborn's soul back to life, I can't stop thinking about how important that body of knowledge would be for the town. It's like it's a choice between siding with religion (Nedmar) or science (Osrya). A very, very magical science.

Oh, if only I had the required mechanics skill to open Giacco's cell door. I guess I could leave the dungeon and go back to Guilded Vale to buy some lockpicks.

[Mansen]

She went the way of her "creations" - On a broom no less...

[Planeforger]

My conversations with Osrya went...a little differently to you guys.

Needless to say, it was a bit of a tough fight!

[Wasted_46]

well how about going with what you feel right and stop worrying about artificial crap like reputation.

[ducknuck84]

I her in the head and stole her cat.

[simuranbeast]

Generally Speaking, I agree with you. It looks like a tight moral dillema. That being said, the dealbreaker for me was the letter "Ludrana's Orders", that you get from a mage name Ludrana accompanied by some knights in one of the wilderness areas. This letter instructs Lundara to basically abduct peasants to be used as "specimen". It is signed by a mysterious "O'". Pretty clear from whom it is.

[War Crime Enjoyer]

Do exactly what I did!

Kill them.

Both.

In fact, kill everyone. Literally everyone. Rebels included.

[Eleidhûr]

I'm having a bit of a problem with this quest: I chatted with Osrya using Perception, and now I'm not able to get the key from her. My Mechanics skill isn't high enough to pick the lock on Giacco's door. Should I just return once I get another point in Mechanics? If I go on through the rest of the keep, will it be too late to save Giacco? If only there were a pickpocketing skill!

[Wasted_46]

Originally posted by Silverdrake:

I'm having a bit of a problem with this quest: I chatted with Osrya using Perception, and now I'm not able to get the key from her. My Mechanics skill isn't high enough to pick the lock on Giacco's door. Should I just return once I get another point in Mechanics? If I go on through the rest of the keep, will it be too late to save Giacco? If only there were a pickpocketing skill!

- you can slay her by issuing an attack command on her
- you can come back later, no time constraint on quests

[Stan the Sumo Man]

i have both her and the priest alive, put the rebels on the throne, and neither of them are hostile to me. When i first met her i told her the thane had sent me to check on her, she became friendly, and now i guess she still is, bug?