Final Choice with Eyeless -- Completely frustrating (spoil me plz devs)

[Buyung Kilat]

I'm surprised that there are no discussions on the final choice you have to make during the debate with the Eyeless. Maybe not too many people have finished the game including the expansion yet.

There are three topics of debate. But in the end, I was only given the choice of restoring Abydon or returning the Eyeless to the wheel. Both of which are extreme choices with no compromise.

I have not yet seen a third choice because so far I've not won all three of those topics. But there must a third option else the whole debate itself is pointless. I've won the second and the third topic so far.

Now, the first topic is really ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ me off. I won the argument about Aloth, and about the mistake of reviving Durgan's Battery. But just because of one argument, just ONE, about anymancy, the whole thing becomes a waste.

It's total BS that the only reason I haven't won it all is because I didn't outrightly suggested that animancy be banned. Whereas with the other topics, I get to pick and choose my arguments, with this one. it was shoved down my throat. I'm ♥♥♥♥♥♥ as hell. I can't undo that decision without starting the game over.

Edit:

There is a way to get that third choice. Here's proof, https://forums.obsidian.net/topic/82024-the-white-march-ending-slides/?p=1788171. Nonetheless, again I've succeeded with every argument except animancy so I'm screwed.

[Sharlly]

Hey there :)
I have pillars of etternity on GOG. Now playing white march.
Know what you mean. Also have 2/3 argument victory
Made the decision to persuade duc to not banish animancy and it cripples this the best ending of white march which i want :/
funny thing is that topic about memory remains in dialouge as there should be more arguments, which i do not have maybe ?

[TaurusBully]

That's actually the beauty of the game. A long time made choice now biting is consequence in the future.

I'm completely down for it. That's why the game has replayability.

Complaining about this is like trying to make all missions for the factions in defiance bay in one try.

[Sharlly]

Yup, i see your point :) The game is awesome and I love that eyeless mention your big choice.

But it still looks like there are more options to argue and i just do not have them. Maybe bug or no ? If yes, they could probably win that arguemnt :) will try change companions or advance in main story for now .)

Guess I am not the player to replay games cause i would choose the same. Example i love arch with knights in defiance bay :)

Thanks Taurus :) what was your choice with Eyeless ?