Osrya or not Osrya, that is the question

[A€G|5]

I want to join Raedric to maintain his domain, so I have talked to him and nobody is attacking me anymore around the keep. But what about Osrya? I haven't spoken to her yet, because I dont know if it is better to kill her or to help her by killing Nedmar. What has the best reward? Do any of these options have repercussions? Help me please!!

[D'amarr from Darshiva]

Originally posted by A€G|5:

What has the best reward?

Define "best".

Killing Raedric - or Kolsc and Raedric - is the more interesting path anyway.

[A€G|5]

Originally posted by D'amarr from Darshiva:

Originally posted by A€G|5:

What has the best reward?

Define "best".

Killing Raedric - or Kolsc and Raedric - is the more interesting path anyway.

I am not talking about killing Raedric or Kolsc, because I had decided to help Raedric. I am talking about killing or not killing Osrya, because I don't know if killing her (to get her loot) has repercussions in the future.

[D'amarr from Darshiva]

Originally posted by A€G|5:

I am not talking about killing Raedric or Kolsc, because I had decided to help Raedric.

You repeat yourself.

I don't know what you consider the "best reward" - that explains my reply. The best reward is to kill Raedric, because it leads to The Champion of Berath side quest and extra loot. Osrya is uninteresting except for strict role-playing.

Originally posted by A€G|5:

I am talking about killing or not killing Osrya, because I don't know if killing her (to get her loot) has repercussions in the future.

It's a role-playing game. Talk to her and other NPCs, then decide yourself. She is one of the paths to reach Raedric. Nedmar is another path.

You could also seek for inspiration in older topics:

Are there any repercussions for killing Osrya?
https://steamcommunity.com/app/291650/discussions/0/618458030666518234

[psychotron666]

Well she is an animancer and she's trying to fix the hollowborn. However she's way off on her hypothesis thus doing the wrong experiments, and she keeps zombies around which is just plain creepy.

If you wanted to side with raedric because you believe his tyranny for the greater good is a better way of approaching a cure for the hollowborn, then I'd keep osyra alive because she's the one who's directly aiding him in that endeavour.

But if you're gonna kill raedric, kill osyra.

I find killing raedric is more fun because he's a more interesting boss fight and you also get a cool boss fight in a side quest later afterwards that you wont get if you kill kolsc.
But if you're doing roleplay decisions and keeping raedric then keep osyra

[smilehigh]

There are no repercussions for killing Osrya. You will get her grimoire if you kill her though.

Killing Raedric can be a challenging fight if you are underlevelled but once you know what you are doing and can position yourself properly it becomes rather trivial even on POTD. And once you unlock Warden's Lodge and start to receive bounties - you will get plenty of bossfights to choose from.

So no - unlike what the users above are saying killing Raedric is not the most interesting path. (The quest you will get in the late game if you kill him is super lame and easy, so you are not missing much). Follow your role-playing decisions and don't worry about the rest.

(Actually arguing with Raedric and then taking his side and killing Kolsc is arguably a more interesting role-playing decision than "I just arrived to a new country and the first thing I did was kill teh evil lord because a completely random stranger asked me to")

[A€G|5]

Originally posted by smilehigh:

There are no repercussions for killing Osrya. You will get her grimoire if you kill her though.

Killing Raedric can be a challenging fight if you are underlevelled but once you know what you are doing and can position yourself properly it becomes rather trivial even on POTD. And once you unlock Warden's Lodge and start to receive bounties - you will get plenty of bossfights to choose from.

So no - unlike what the users above are saying killing Raedric is not the most interesting path. (The quest you will get in the late game if you kill him is super lame and easy, so you are not missing much). Follow your role-playing decisions and don't worry about the rest.

(Actually arguing with Raedric and then taking his side and killing Kolsc is arguably a more interesting role-playing decision than "I just arrived to a new country and the first thing I did was kill teh evil lord because a completely random stranger asked me to")

Thank you very much! That is what I wanted to know. On my first gameplay I helped Kolsc, and now I am playing POTD and I wanted to try siding Raedric and killing Kolsc was easier for my current level 4 party, but I lost a lot of reputation on Guilded Valley though.

[psychotron666]

Originally posted by smilehigh:

There are no repercussions for killing Osrya. You will get her grimoire if you kill her though.

Killing Raedric can be a challenging fight if you are underlevelled but once you know what you are doing and can position yourself properly it becomes rather trivial even on POTD. And once you unlock Warden's Lodge and start to receive bounties - you will get plenty of bossfights to choose from.

So no - unlike what the users above are saying killing Raedric is not the most interesting path. (The quest you will get in the late game if you kill him is super lame and easy, so you are not missing much). Follow your role-playing decisions and don't worry about the rest.

(Actually arguing with Raedric and then taking his side and killing Kolsc is arguably a more interesting role-playing decision than "I just arrived to a new country and the first thing I did was kill teh evil lord because a completely random stranger asked me to")

I prefer siding with raedric for roleplay purposes. I did it my first play through, so I never knew about the second raedric fight until my next play through and felt like I missed out the first time around.

I mean I felt the game wanted me to kill raedric and I missed out by not doing it the first time. I like the roleplay reasons for siding with raedric, and it seems more logical though.

[Fiach]

Ive killed either in different playthroughs, Does anything interesting happen if you kill both, or does it just continue with the ghost thing later on?

[D'amarr from Darshiva]

No. Killing Kolsc and then turning also against Raedric only brings you back onto The Champion of Berath quest track.

[Fiach]

Originally posted by D'amarr from Darshiva:

No. Killing Kolsc and then turning also against Raedric only brings you back onto The Champion of Berath quest track.

Cool thanks for that!