This vs Melee vs Rivals

[Navonod]

Which of these is better? And how do they compare?

[MizManFryinP🍳]

Preference I'd say. I'd say brawlhalla is more of an equal oppertunity fighter while Melee has it's OPs and it's also way more fast paced than brawlhalla. I'm afraid I've never touched Rivals

[ComptonEMT TTV]

The feel of this is much different than melee or rivals. It more or less took the subgenre and made it's own game. It has some of the basic mechanics but it's like comparing Halo and counterstrike.

[Navonod]

Ok. Thank you for that analogy. I honestly prefer halo over counterstrike as far as esports shooters are concerned. I will probably prefer melee over this, but I was curious.

[ComptonEMT TTV]

Originally posted by Navonod Rethgualed:

Ok. Thank you for that analogy. I honestly prefer halo over counterstrike as far as esports shooters are concerned. I will probably prefer melee over this, but I was curious.

Give it a good try. My analogy was just to convey that they're different while in the same genre. Figure out if you like it or not.

I personally only started playing it because i just wanted something similar to smash... now I actually like this game more than smash. Most of my friends now do too. The main naysayers are the ones who just flat out "won't" play it.

[so novo]

i play both brawlhalla and rivals
right now, the community in brawlhalla is way bigger, has rank and everything, the online in rivals is still broken because of the player hosting system, but i really really want rivals to grow bigger, if not as big as smash scene, at least the less played titles

rivals skill cap is far higher than brawlhalla, but still a simplified version of melee
melee feels like all the mechanics are glitch abuse when comes to executing them, in rivals the same mechanics such as wavedashing feel as natural as a roll or air dodge, in brawlhalla these mechanics are close to non existent

if melee = dota 2 then rivals = heroes of newerth and brawlhalla = LoL

[ComptonEMT TTV]

Originally posted by Cuban Rafting 300ping:

rivals skill cap is far higher than brawlhalla

IDK man... i'd say they're similar ... but the type of skill isn't really comparable as they're different types of skill. Having played in top tier play for a while... there are some pretty crazy things in the skill of this game. Most of it is lost in how basic the core gameplay is that people never see the subtle things that make up higher tier play.

..::EDIT::..
for most people (prolly 90% of the player base) the stats don't really change anything at all... however for top tier players they can be game breaking... this is a small part of the reason why stances aren't allowed in competitive play.

[EcchiOtakuTM]

Best is Project M, Hope they can do the same for sm4sh

[Navonod]

Originally posted by Microsoft Word 2013:

Best is Project M, Hope they can do the same for sm4sh

You mean tr4sh?

[EcchiOtakuTM]

Originally posted by Navonod Rethgualed:

Originally posted by Microsoft Word 2013:

Best is Project M, Hope they can do the same for sm4sh

You mean tr4sh?

Hey they can't all be perfect lol but yea if the project m modders get a chance to do the same for it, we might have a legend right there...wish nintendo employed the project m modders

[so novo]

i lost my faith in smash bros because nintendo hate dealing with competitive players, they only care about their manchild fanbase that spends 1000 dollars with pikachu's merch

im glad there is smash bros crusade and rivals still growing

[EcchiOtakuTM]

Originally posted by Cuban Rafting 300ping:

i lost my faith in smash bros because nintendo hate dealing with competitive players, they only care about their manchild fanbase that spends 1000 dollars with pikachu's merch

im glad there is smash bros crusade and rivals still growing

All I really wished is that brawlhalla lowered alot of the character's floatiness, made it unique per char same with jumps and gave everyone their own unique standard combo (just non-weapon attacks, weapon attacks can stay how they are)

I do like rivals but outside of the combat brawlhalla has more.

[MORNINGTIME]

Rivals is a much better competitive fighter, but not as supported as Brawlhalla, it seems.
Brawlhalla is much more of a party game than a fighting game, and Melee is essentially the grandfather in between them.

[EcchiOtakuTM]

Originally posted by MORNINGTIME:

Rivals is a much better competitive fighter, but not as supported as Brawlhalla, it seems.
Brawlhalla is much more of a party game than a fighting game, and Melee is essentially the grandfather in between them.

Yep true.

[Benjo]

Originally posted by EcchiOtakuTM:

Originally posted by Navonod Rethgualed:

You mean tr4sh?

Hey they can't all be perfect lol but yea if the project m modders get a chance to do the same for it, we might have a legend right there...wish nintendo employed the project m modders

7 years later...

H
D
R