The witcher 3 vs MGS The Phantom Pain

[Proffesional feeder]

imo No matter what this game will be like, The witcher 3 totally deserve The game of The Year award and I'm not even trolling.

The witcher 3 was so well made

[Fang]

Escrito originalmente por Fiddles Schididdles:

Escrito originalmente por Fang:

How could we possibly have this discussion if this game isn't out yet. :p

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XJvOxFhVNbQ

The answer to everything.

[noobiwan]

Escrito originalmente por Goatie:

it surprises how alot of people think bloodprone is better than the witcher lol

bloodbrone reminds me of the monster hunter series in the sense that the controls and the camera movement are ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ atrocious in both games, so bad that it is hard to play the game and then call the game challenging

Calls out Bloodborne for the, atleast in his opinion, bad camera and controls. Plays Witcher 3.

Are you kidding me? Witcher 3 is gameplay-wise probably the weakest of the big hitters this year (Bloodborne, Witcher 3, Fallout 4, MGS 5). The only things that make Witcher 3 stand out, are the story and the superb dialogue writing. The rest is average (quest design, level design) or even bad (combat, controls).
On the other hand, Bloodborne has probably the best leveldesign of those games, everything is interconnected and the combat feels fast, responsive and incredibly satisfying. The setting is also the most unique of the listed games. Sadly technical problems are preventing it from being the absolute GOAT.


Fallout 4 will probably suffer from the same problems as FO3 and, to some extend NV, which means: ♥♥♥♥ gunplay (although it seems like they've improved it a lot), ♥♥♥♥ writing (in FO3, NV was amazing in that regard), bugs, bad performance and copy'n'paste dungeons.
Still pretty unsecure about MGS 5, the story-telling is, according to some previews, pretty temperate, and I'm still skeptical about the open-world, since it could also suffer the same fate as the Ubisoft games.

[JINORU]

GotY awards are totally pointless

[Metric Guard]

Escrito originalmente por Jinoru:

GotY awards are totally pointless

BREAKING NEWS: Captain Obvious strikes again!

[Tumas Altaawus]

The Witcher 3 is meant to be an RPG, but is more of an action/adventure game. MGS V on the other hand is a hardcore stealth/action TPS, and plays just like that. IMO MGS V TPP will be better made than TW3. Whilst TW3 is lengthy and fun, it's not a very good RPG, just a good action/adventure game. It also ran poorly, had downgraded visuals, and content cut for PR "free DLC".

[M2B]

Here you all are wasting time arguing about how X is better than Y, and how Z is better than Y but not as good as X, etc. etc.

One thing we can all agree on. MGS 5 TPP will be amazing.

[[OH] Cogglesz]

I find it pretty funny how people can just round up a whole year with one game. I wish i was that easily entertained that one game done me a whole year. I'm hype as ♥♥♥♥ for Phantom Pain. Hype as ♥♥♥♥ for Fallout 4 too. Gerald controls like a ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ Tank Lol Bloodborne compared to that is Smooth as hell animation. Love the game myself but there no denying it has its few flaws just like any other game, you'd be ignorant to deny such a thing.

As for me my taste splits into Genres of games. Don't really class MGS V as an RPG game with dungeons, monsters and magic. I'm happy loving all the different kinds of games. Gimmie shoot em' ups. Beat em' ups, racing games, MMO's i don't give a ♥♥♥♥, So long as its a well produced game thats value for money.

The GOTY is just a label that means nothing now a days. 10 games will have that label and even Arkham Knight will recieve a version, Guess you're fine having you're favorite game associated with that title. Well worth it isn't it? Kinda feel like you're ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ on Witcher 3 by saying its GOTY. Who would want to be associated with that?

[clairebear]

The game isn't even out yet

[Brandon]

Escrito originalmente por Sample Text:

yeah yeah lets see who's horse controls the best first

thats hilarious man

[MelhemX]

MGSV: TPP will totally different from the witcher 3

[Moon Punisher]

Pffff i wouldnt vote for witcher 3 even if it was the only game made this year , it doesnt deserve it.

Personally im betting on FO4 getting more GotY , but only time will tell.

[Akaster]

Comparing witcher and mgs is similar to comparing beer and elephant. It's absolutely different games

[handsovereyes]

This post is a waste of digital space.

[Vallaes]

Seriously what you even compare here?

Two different games, one is basic fantasy game that has no relations, no intentions to transport message by story telling to the player of very important political content paired with the today best stealth game with great established story and game mechanics that had an massive impact on video game history and industry because it was the first game that was actually movie like, while other games can't with higher budgets even come close to quality and content of Metal Gear nor Metal Gear Solid. The other is a mere hype game just like all Assassins creeds after they ♥♥♥♥ them out every 6 month.

I haven't played Witcher 3 yet, but i've played Witcher and i dislicked the combat system and how annoying stupid it was compared with many others, not to mention that is like saying what is your favorite movie, where you have to pick only one single movie under millions with dozens of different genres with many good movies, such questions are stupid in my opinion.

[Straasha87]

TPP is just too japanese to garner a lot of GOTY awards in the current "pregressive" minded political landscape of the gaming press.