Am i the only one who thinks this game is overrated?

[ZED]

unstable internet connection
bad character build and plot hole
meaningless long time farm (you even have to farm for story mission,the hell is that)
same play style as the last product back in 2010
and in this game ,it doesnt even have an online mod.(you think that fom ♥♥♥♥ counts?seriously?)
peace walker on psp even have co-op mod to play with your friend this is totally nothing


the only advantage is "made by hideo produced by hideo hideo hideo hideo"
UGH
no more mgs for me

[Jazman2k]

No you're not.

[joxertm22]

Why do someone think this game is overrated at all?
I said after a few hours when I started that it looks to me as 8/10 material. And after 100 hours of it, I still think that.

It's a great game, fun, it's just not a masterpiece.
Sure, some will say it deserves 9/10 because of many things they'll number, but sorry. FOB scandal is instantly -1 if not -2 on the overall score.

[Scottrf]

Some will think underrated, some will think overrated, some will think it's rated right. Such is life.

[ZED]

Originally posted by Scottrf:

Some will think underrated, some will think overrated, some will think it's rated right. Such is life.

so what do you think

[Scottrf]

Originally posted by ZED:

Originally posted by Scottrf:

Some will think underrated, some will think overrated, some will think it's rated right. Such is life.

so what do you think

I think underrated/overrated are meaningless terms and depend completely on subjectivity and what rating you're comparing it to.

The game I think is very good.

[Fang]

I personally think a 10 is hugely overrated. A 9 is a bit too positive in my opinion but I can see reason in it. I personally think it deserve an 8 or an 8,5.

The cons being the messy FOB system, micro's, several story decisions, and the repetitive missions.

[WOLF PACIFIER]

It is. Most of the AAA games overrated now.
Honestly I didn't expected something special from MGS5, but the story line... The main thing is dead. Open world always kill story trying to compensate it using events or sandbox.
But this is not bad game at all. I would say it 8/10 but not 10\10 because there is no perfect games made ever. Max score in my scale it's a 9/10.

[ZED]

Originally posted by joxertm22:

Why do someone think this game is overrated at all?
I said after a few hours when I started that it looks to me as 8/10 material. And after 100 hours of it, I still think that.

It's a great game, fun, it's just not a masterpiece.
Sure, some will say it deserves 9/10 because of many things they'll number, but sorry. FOB scandal is instantly -1 if not -2 on the overall score.

8 is still too high to me.imagine this is a new game developed by some other company.it would be nothing but a game with good graphic.the reuse of the same idea in peace walker is unforgivable,from develop system to fighting system its all the same.the evolve of a game series should not only be the physical way,it have to give people new feelings.mgs pp absolutely failed in that way,and all it can do is trying to touch us with story which in my opinion failed too since the disappointing characterization.
i think hideo wants to use this game to achieve his movie dream,which is unhealthy because that will cause the the game become neither fish nor flesh,it was a big problem in mgs4 and today,it is even worse.

[Puppet Pal Clem]

game is good and i got my money worth, and i can see the small detail the devs have paid attention too. 9/10 better than a lot of games this year, and possibly the best so far. Game isnt even finished too. MGO comes out next year for pc. So idk why complain

[ZED]

Originally posted by Scottrf:

Originally posted by ZED:

so what do you think

I think underrated/overrated are meaningless terms and depend completely on subjectivity and what rating you're comparing it to.

The game I think is very good.

i thought this game's rating in steam should be mixed but it not .and most of the reasons for people to give it a higher review is simply the hideo.that is why i saying it is overrated.people are not rating this game rationally

[Scottrf]

Na I think you're completely wrong. The game is excellent, far better than the majority of games and the issues people are complaining about aren't issues with the core gameplay.

[Fang]

Originally posted by Scottrf:

Na I think you're completely wrong. The game is excellent, far better than the majority of games and the issues people are complaining about aren't issues with the core gameplay.

A game isn't only judged on its core gameplay. You could do so, but it wouldn't be an unbiased review. Besides, I'd say the game becoming repetitive is a problem with the core gameplay (or sandbox games as a whole).

[ZED]

Originally posted by Scottrf:

Na I think you're completely wrong. The game is excellent, far better than the majority of games and the issues people are complaining about aren't issues with the core gameplay.

and if you are only talking about the core gameplay,i can be sure to tell you this is a hd version of mgs peace walker

[darknessviking]

this game is a total mess. i am so sad over how bad it is,i am truly baffled over how they can ever release this. i dont know if its because kojima did it or if they kicked him and then accidentally made this a mess but..yeah. it really breaks my heart over how bad this was. the first mission is amazing.and then it just all crumbles.

[ZED]

Originally posted by darknessviking:

this game is a total mess. i am so sad over how bad it is,i am truly baffled over how they can ever release this. i dont know if its because kojima did it or if they kicked him and then accidentally made this a mess but..yeah. it really breaks my heart over how bad this was. the first mission is amazing.and then it just all crumbles.

i cant believe they force people to repeat the same mission over and over again to earn the new story mission.what is the point?increase gamming time violently?