"I thought you were dead" = lilly is alive

[Sanwea]

maybe she is alive!

[MorningLightMountain]

She doesn't die though. However I would say Lilly is a strong possibility for who that character is.

[Cakefish]

The only thing that doesn't quite fit into place is why Clem thought she had died. I mean, Omid and Christa probably told her about Kenny's death(?) and Clem witnesses Lilly driving off in the van/being abandoned on the roadside for herself - but not physically killed. Are we just meant to assume that Clem has assumed she died?

Apart from that oddity, I feel she is the among the most likely to make a return.

[MorningLightMountain]

I think Lilly is one of the stronger possibilties but yeah at the same time due to how Lilly exits the group Clem's line doesn't exactly fit what happens to Lilly. As I've mentioned before the actual pool of characters is quite tiny.

[jmontesi4]

Or Andy St. John or probably someone from the time period we missed ("16 months later")

It may be someone from Tavia's group (after Omid's event)
Theory: Someone from Tavia's group found Christa & Clem, later something happened, that made Christa & Clem left the group or they were forced to leave.

[MorningLightMountain]

I'll repost this that I posted in a topic on the same subject

1) It has to be someone Clementine believes was dead.

2) It can only be someone we have already met.

3) It cannot be anyone who is actually dead such as Lee, Chuck, Larry etc.

4) Whoever it is leading a gang so that rules out certain characters.

5) It cannot be anyone who is ruled due to the canon of the timeline, the group they are with or they have died after episode two's major timeskip. Such as Glen or Hershel.

6) It cannot be anyone from the TV show as that is an alternate universe Walking Dead.

[Cakefish]

Escrito originalmente por jmontesi4:

Or Andy St. John or probably someone from the time period we missed ("16 months later")

It may be someone from Tavia's group (after Omid's event)
Theory: Someone from Tavia's group found Christa & Clem, later something happened, that made Christa & Clem left the group or they were forced to leave.

Both the farm brothers could be optionally killed. They can't bring back a character who can definitely die depending on player choice.

Your second theory is indeed a possibility but I think it's more likely a character from season one who we already know.

[Mikhail Reign]

Escrito originalmente por MorningLightMountain:

I'll repost this that I posted in a topic on the same subject

1) It has to be someone Clementine believes was dead.

2) It can only be someone we have already met.

3) It cannot be anyone who is actually dead such as Lee, Chuck, Larry etc.

4) Whoever it is leading a gang so that rules out certain characters.

5) It cannot be anyone who is ruled due to the canon of the timeline, the group they are with or they have died after episode two's major timeskip. Such as Glen or Hershel.

6) It cannot be anyone from the TV show as that is an alternate universe Walking Dead.

Nick and/or Pete. Something further happens in Ep02 and we assumed they are dead for a while.

[MorningLightMountain]

The problem with the Nick/Pete theory is that whoever the person is leading another group there isn't enough time for that to occur if it were either of them.

[Authentic]

So it must be someone Clem knew and thought died. Take a look at this wiki page:
http://walkingdead.wikia.com/wiki/Video_Game_Characters

Here's a list of the characters with unknown fates that Clem knew (in order from most likely to be this character to least likely):
Kenny
Christa
Molly
Glenn
Lilly
Hershel
Victor
Ralph
Maybelle

[MorningLightMountain]

Escrito originalmente por TrevorCinema:

So it must be someone Clem knew and thought died. Take a look at this wiki page:
http://walkingdead.wikia.com/wiki/Video_Game_Characters

Here's a list of the characters with unknown fates that Clem knew (in order from most likely to be this character to least likely):
Kenny
Christa
Molly
Glenn
Lilly
Hershel
Victor
Ralph
Maybelle

Well from that list Glenn & Hershell can be immediatly ruled out. I think on grounds of common sense Maybelle can be ruled out as well.

[Mikhail Reign]

You think Glenn, who is dead, is more likely than Lilly, the last of which we seen of her was her being left in the middle of the road OR disappearing off by herself?

[Authentic]

Escrito originalmente por Mikhail Reign:

You think Glenn, who is dead, is more likely than Lilly, the last of which we seen of her was her being left in the middle of the road OR disappearing off by herself?

The game's canon is no longer that of the comic or tv series canon.

[MorningLightMountain]

Escrito originalmente por TrevorCinema:

Escrito originalmente por Mikhail Reign:

You think Glenn, who is dead, is more likely than Lilly, the last of which we seen of her was her being left in the middle of the road OR disappearing off by herself?

The game's canon is no longer that of the comic or tv series canon.

Not so the game is still set in the canon of the comics. If you are referring to Road to Woodbury all that does is seperate Lilly from the game and Lilly from the comic into two different characters it changes nothing else.

[Mikhail Reign]

Yeah Lilly isn't Lilly.

[CausticNova☣]

Doesn't she inevitably get kicked out of the camper to walk on the highway alone? There's no reason in that to THINK she was dead really