Please adds Achievements transfer original to Remastered.

[johnnypearl]

[Ordisoftware]

According to my experience as a coder and in view of the system of which I am only a user, I suppose that this is not the responsibility of the dev team but of Steam which does not offer this kind of thing to date, it is therefore necessary to suggest this functionality in the event of a remaster to Steam, on this forum it is a priori useless, have a good game and enjoy the beauty as well as the semiosis.

https://steamcommunity.com/app/2561580/discussions/0/4634860616374298103/

[johnnypearl]

Originally posted by Ordisoftware:

According to my experience as a coder and in view of the system of which I am only a user, I suppose that this is not the responsibility of the dev team but of Steam which does not offer this kind of thing to date, it is therefore necessary to suggest this functionality in the event of a remaster to Steam, on this forum it is a priori useless, have a good game and enjoy the beauty as well as the semiosis.

https://steamcommunity.com/app/2561580/discussions/0/4634860616374298103/

It has nothing to do with Steam, friend, when Destiny 2 arrived on Steam, all the achievements were transferred, it also happened recently with The Division 2, Assassin's Creed Valhalla, and even with DEATH STRANDING that all the achievements were unlocked for the DEATH STRANDING DIRECTOR'S CUT version.

[Jubileu]

Originally posted by johnnypearl:

Originally posted by Ordisoftware:

According to my experience as a coder and in view of the system of which I am only a user, I suppose that this is not the responsibility of the dev team but of Steam which does not offer this kind of thing to date, it is therefore necessary to suggest this functionality in the event of a remaster to Steam, on this forum it is a priori useless, have a good game and enjoy the beauty as well as the semiosis.

https://steamcommunity.com/app/2561580/discussions/0/4634860616374298103/

It has nothing to do with Steam, friend, when Destiny 2 arrived on Steam, all the achievements were transferred, it also happened recently with The Division 2, Assassin's Creed Valhalla, and even with DEATH STRANDING that all the achievements were unlocked for the DEATH STRANDING DIRECTOR'S CUT version.

That's true, other games have done that too.

[Ordisoftware]

Thus it's a SteamWorks SDK usage issue if what you say is true, and I don't know anything about that.

[Aemony]

Originally posted by Ordisoftware:

According to my experience as a coder and in view of the system of which I am only a user, I suppose that this is not the responsibility of the dev team but of Steam which does not offer this kind of thing to date, it is therefore necessary to suggest this functionality in the event of a remaster to Steam, on this forum it is a priori useless, have a good game and enjoy the beauty as well as the semiosis.

https://steamcommunity.com/app/2561580/discussions/0/4634860616374298103/

This is incorrect as developers have full control over achievements unlocks as well as unlock removals (which some game's debug modes actually allows the player to do).

In practice, all that's required of developers to implement this sort of functionality is:
1. When loading a save file, the game goes through and checks whether the save in question have actually fulfilled any of the requirements of the achievements.
2. The game then calls ISteamUserStats::SetAchievement with the relevant achievement ID.

That said, I'd personally prefer it if this kind of functionality is gated behind a prompt or a toggle as I myself prefer achievements not to carry over for games I like replaying (such as this one).

[johnnypearl]

Originally posted by Ordisoftware:

Thus it's a SteamWorks SDK usage issue if what you say is true, and I don't know anything about that.

On PlayStation 5, everyone is complaining that there is no such tool, it only transfers the save, the achievements are not being unlocked either, it is definitely not a problem with the Steam platform.

[johnnypearl]

Originally posted by Aemony:

Originally posted by Ordisoftware:

According to my experience as a coder and in view of the system of which I am only a user, I suppose that this is not the responsibility of the dev team but of Steam which does not offer this kind of thing to date, it is therefore necessary to suggest this functionality in the event of a remaster to Steam, on this forum it is a priori useless, have a good game and enjoy the beauty as well as the semiosis.

https://steamcommunity.com/app/2561580/discussions/0/4634860616374298103/

This is incorrect as developers have full control over achievements unlocks as well as unlock removals (which some game's debug modes actually allows the player to do).

In practice, all that's required of developers to implement this sort of functionality is:
1. When loading a save file, the game goes through and checks whether the save in question have actually fulfilled any of the requirements of the achievements.
2. The game then calls ISteamUserStats::SetAchievement with the relevant achievement ID.

That said, I'd personally prefer it if this kind of functionality is gated behind a prompt or a toggle as I myself prefer achievements not to carry over for games I like replaying (such as this one).

So in your case, you just had to not load your "SAVE" and start a new game, since you like to play it again.

[Ordisoftware]

It's simple: either a function exists in the SDK to transfer achievements from one game to another in the case of remasters and remakes, or it doesn't exist. If it exists then it is not called here. Otherwise one have to ask Steam to create it.

[wolfinston85]

USE SAM

[johnnypearl]

Originally posted by wolfinston85:

USE SAM

I've thought about it, but I'll wait to see if something comes in the next patch.

[acowsik]

Originally posted by wolfinston85:

USE SAM

Achievement transfer on save import should have been implemented when they designed the remaster to import the complete edition saves... we should not be resorting to that... moreover it will not pop the trophies for you.

Adding a retroactive achievement check and unlock is definitely possible... its just down to Nixxes to implement that check on save load.

I definitely am not replaying the game from scratch... I imported my 100% save and I just roamed around areas to see the changes in visuals.

[Doc_H]

Originally posted by johnnypearl:

Please adds Achievements transfer original to Remastered.

+1
It worked (on the ps5) for "the last of us part 2 remastered" too...

[dukehawk]

Originally posted by johnnypearl:

+1

[RodroG]

Originally posted by Aemony:

Originally posted by Ordisoftware:

According to my experience as a coder and in view of the system of which I am only a user, I suppose that this is not the responsibility of the dev team but of Steam which does not offer this kind of thing to date, it is therefore necessary to suggest this functionality in the event of a remaster to Steam, on this forum it is a priori useless, have a good game and enjoy the beauty as well as the semiosis.

https://steamcommunity.com/app/2561580/discussions/0/4634860616374298103/

This is incorrect as developers have full control over achievements unlocks as well as unlock removals (which some game's debug modes actually allows the player to do).

In practice, all that's required of developers to implement this sort of functionality is:
1. When loading a save file, the game goes through and checks whether the save in question have actually fulfilled any of the requirements of the achievements.
2. The game then calls ISteamUserStats::SetAchievement with the relevant achievement ID.

That said, I'd personally prefer it if this kind of functionality is gated behind a prompt or a toggle as I myself prefer achievements not to carry over for games I like replaying (such as this one).

Thank you for the explanation and accurate info @Aemony. I also prefer achievements not to carry over in this case.

[RodroG]

Originally posted by johnnypearl:

Originally posted by Aemony:

This is incorrect as developers have full control over achievements unlocks as well as unlock removals (which some game's debug modes actually allows the player to do).

In practice, all that's required of developers to implement this sort of functionality is:
1. When loading a save file, the game goes through and checks whether the save in question have actually fulfilled any of the requirements of the achievements.
2. The game then calls ISteamUserStats::SetAchievement with the relevant achievement ID.

That said, I'd personally prefer it if this kind of functionality is gated behind a prompt or a toggle as I myself prefer achievements not to carry over for games I like replaying (such as this one).

So in your case, you just had to not load your "SAVE" and start a new game, since you like to play it again.

Not necessarily. For example, I finished HZD's original port long ago but never tried an NG+ playthrough, and I want to get the achievements again. Now, with the remaster, I decided to start an NG+ playthrough, so I had to load/import my previous end-game SAVE. I don't want to start a regular new game.