If Crane was the killer

[Selfish Lee Everett]

Why would he take a picture of himself looming over Snow White, and then leave it behind in the crime scene?

Seems like there's two possibilities. One, the killer is glamoured as Ichabod Crane. Two, Crane secretly has a crush on Snow and perhaps the killer caught him while he was enjoying one of his "massages". A harmless crush albeit a creepy one. The photos were intentionally left behind for Bigby to discover. Also I remember in the episode 1 ending montage, Bigby holds him over the Witching Well, so in the next episode he will reveal himself.


P.S.- I discovered an extra ending that seems to be fairly uncommon, at least according to the choices it took to achieve. I arrested the Woodsman in the first episode, interrogated him, then revealed to Holly about him enjoying her sister's services, and in the episode 2 ending montage it shows Gren getting ready to kick his ass. Ha ha can't wait to see them turn on each other.

[BeastBox]

Originally posted by Selfish Lee Everett:

Crane secretly has a crush on Snow and perhaps the killer caught him while he was enjoying one of his "massages".

This seems like the obvious interpretation to me.

Originally posted by Selfish Lee Everett:

P.S.- I discovered an extra ending that seems to be fairly uncommon, at least according to the choices it took to achieve. I arrested the Woodsman in the first episode, interrogated him, then revealed to Holly about him enjoying her sister's services, and in the episode 2 ending montage it shows Gren getting ready to kick his ♥♥♥. Ha ha can't wait to see them turn on each other.

LOL; nice! I played again to interrogate Woody but I didn't take that option or see that trailer. Pretty funny if Gren and Holly were worried about Lily for months and Woody has to listen to it in their bar, knowing she's routinely in his apartment ...

[Stump Chuggins]

Yes, Crane most definitely has a "crush" on the real Snow, if you want to call it that.

[[NGNS-SWE] ⚡ Quezkatolen ⚡]

I still dont understand why Crane would smash the mirror and be that angry if he was innocent.

I mean, the Crane smashing the mirror must have been the real Crane. Also, what happend to the mirror? did it die now? I mean, if someone saw me with a prostitue I would be mad - but not hurt someone innocent next to me in rage. And if im innocent, the worst thing to do, is destroying the mirror and going into rages and then pretend im "Innocent".

As I said, I suspect he might have killed Lily. Or he might have drugged her so she was wasted as hell, then outside she was laughing at him for some reason, and this rage-a-holic killed her and then decied to behead to make the killing look like the previous.

Or else Bibgy and Snow suddenly has two cases, two separate murderes, but by making it look like the serial killer - he will make bibgby look into the first murderer first, and if arrested - proabbly book him for both.

So basically I think tell tales wanna trick people in two ways; 1 . there is a serial killer and not multiple killers. 2. That Crane also killed Faith - which I don't believe at all.

[BeastBox]

Originally posted by QuezcatoL! (SWE):

I still dont understand why Crane would smash the mirror and be that angry if he was innocent.

He's not innocent. They caught him in his sick little perversion and he's mad and ran in shame. Even Snow called him a "disgusting weasel". Plus it's canon with the comics.

The murder is a seperate matter completely.

[[NGNS-SWE] ⚡ Quezkatolen ⚡]

Originally posted by BeastBox:

Originally posted by QuezcatoL! (SWE):

I still dont understand why Crane would smash the mirror and be that angry if he was innocent.

He's not innocent. They caught him in his sick little perversion and he's mad and ran in shame. Even Snow called him a "disgusting weasel". Plus it's canon with the comics.

The murder is a seperate matter completely.

I still think the smashing of mirror is a huge overreaction. And especially if your accused of murder you can't do stupid things like that.

[BeastBox]

Originally posted by QuezcatoL! (SWE):

I still think the smashing of mirror is a huge overreaction.

I think you're underestimating Crane's pride. You may not smash a mirror, but he would.

[[NGNS-SWE] ⚡ Quezkatolen ⚡]

Originally posted by BeastBox:

Originally posted by QuezcatoL! (SWE):

I still think the smashing of mirror is a huge overreaction.

I think you're underestimating Crane's pride. You may not smash a mirror, but he would.

Could be.
if I was suspected of murder I wouldnt punch someone innocent close to me, all im saying.

[aprospro]

i dont think that crane is the persin behind everything. saying that i still think he is the killer, however not the master behind the whole story

[PandaLyambda]

Originally posted by Selfish Lee Everett:

Crane secretly has a crush on Snow and perhaps the killer caught him while he was enjoying one of his "massages".

I am totally agree with this version. And I have some arguments:
1) Snow White on the photo with Crane was dressed in the dress (which was in the wardrobe near the photoes). But as we know, Lily's body was found in the costume.
2) In first episode Bigby found blood on the fence. Crane was living in this building and I don't think that he needed to jump through the fence with Faith's head. (just imagine this)
3) Сigarette. Crane didn't like when somebody smokes in his office. Did he could to smoke at the time of murder?
4) And I sure that something strange with the bottle of wine. The one in 207 room not coincedes with one that Snow White bought (or what was stolen by flying monkey). Also Crane went out of office without wine at all.