my theory of whos the killer (contains spoilers)

[yarheeguy]

we all may think it was crane but i think it not him

i just thoght of something that can put it all together of whos the killer of faith and lilly

i think the merderer is that lady that opened the door for ya when your at the cat house. heres the reason why

when you were at room 207, you found a huff and puff. and that blonde lady (realy can't spell her name) said that she thoght bigby was the only one who smoke them, but when you at the cat house you see that lady smokeing a huff and puff

now we don't know whats her name is yet so here anorther theory

here what i think shes the queen of hearts from alice in wonderland

heres some reason why

1. you find only heads of faith and lilly and the qoh mostly say "off with your head"

2. she don't like to be largh at. (that what i think she mosly don't like)

3. dee and dum got a boss, maybe its qoh because thay are in the same book. and maybe she hired crane aswell.

4. on lilly's perfume bottle it says "use this" maybe a reffrance on the bottle says "drink me" and the cake says "eat me" in allice in wonderland

5. how and who could of taken the photo of crane and fake snow, to me i think qoh was there and taken the photo to show that the killer looks like crane and she can get off the hook

6. if you look very closely george was on the book and next to his name was "ms. smith" thats maybe qoh that she was with george, so that means crane use her fake last name

so i think its that lady and her name is known as the queen of hearts, i don't know her real or renamed name.

what do ya guys think about this theory.

[[NGNS-SWE] ⚡ Quezkatolen ⚡]

quote=QuezcatoL! (SWE);558747288167202132]
ps! Bluebeards fairy tale involved him beheading women, Tell Tales would never made it that obvious on who is the killer, so forget him atleast. [/quote]
I'm not actually paying any attention to the characters' original stories on this one; few if any of the characters in this game act like their fables imply, and some (like Woody) are intentionally the opposite. People saying "well it must be so and so because they cut off heads in their story!" just make no damn sense. Does anyone in this game act like they do in their original fables? :p [/quote]


Well, I havnt read the comic - im swedish btw, but I have heard about the bluebeard story...think it was from the 1700.

[BeastBox]

Originally posted by QuezcatoL! (SWE):

Crane never had a motive to kill Snow, what I mean is - Lily who btw he might have been requested dressed up as other women as well, was a threat to him.
Maybe he was afraid that she knew him as the mayor and would sooner or later blackmail him.
So he kills her, and behead her while she "sleeps" probably fell in a coma state because of her drugs, which was seen on her legs.
So he had all the time and could behead her without any problem.

That would be an awfully convienient coma. Also convenient that he can suddenly reproduce the manner Faith was killed in (did he even see Faith's head?) Also, if this is a concern for him, why cancel his glamour? He obviously had one on him when he walked past Beauty in the lobby, and we see the glamour box in the episode 3 trailer. If she can keep hers on, he can keep his. She'd never know his identity.

I think you're also forgetting the "discression is our guarentee" line. Lily's not blackmailing anyone, and that's likely something advertised to potential clients like Crane. Her lips are sealed, after all. No point in killing.

Originally posted by QuezcatoL! (SWE):

Then, since he know this "woman" would be missing he decied to fool/trick bigby into that its the murder of the serial killer again, and not by someone else.
And, that way, he could lead bigby into arresting someone he already suspected from before, like woody who is already a big problem in the community.

Well, except there was no serial killer when it was just Faith. And really, if he were going to do that, why not remove her glamour first like they did when examining the body? Crane just seems hugely put off by the whole affair of the mundy involvement and the interrogation and examining Lily's body ... all these complications he essentially invited on himself.

Too many mental gymnastics. Crane had some fun with a hooker, was very cautious about instructions and not getting caught, and then the next morning he finds out she's been killed and Bigby and Snow are on the case ... worst possible scenario. The moment he gets caught he runs like the dickens, and that's pretty much his involvement IMHO.

[[NGNS-SWE] ⚡ Quezkatolen ⚡]

well, it make not much sense for Crane to put her into sleep, then just sneak away and then the killer shows up and behead her...

so, either this was something they did many times, and the "coma/sleep" was from her injections/drugs, then the picture could have been an old one... and the killer trying to set up Crane.
Crane would still be in panic mode because;

A. he is accused of being the killer.
B. he was paying hookers to dress up as his co-worker, hardly anything a mayor should do...

But as I said before, I suspect this game/story will have more then one killer, and 1-2 killings that will have nothing to do with the first death of faith, to try and fool people around.

thats why I suspect crane migh tactually be a killer, who decied to just dump the body as the victim of the serial killer.

[BeastBox]

Originally posted by QuezcatoL! (SWE):

well, it make not much sense for Crane to put her into sleep, then just sneak away and then the killer shows up and behead her...

I don't see why not. Assuming Lily was even asleep in the first place (she could have just been lying there, being his fantasy), if that's the fantasy he paid for, that's what he would do and then leave. One way or another, she had to have gotten back out of the bed before being killed because the dress she was wearing is in the closet, unbloodied, so I'm not sure where this 'coma' you speak of is coming from. Did I miss something?

EDIT: Incidentally, I noticed in Bluebeard's BoF profile that he's not a stranger to "the Crooked Lane". Guessing that the Crooked Man is heavily involved in the murders, Bluebeard has a deal with him to oust Crane, but Bluebeard's also keeping enough distance from him that when the fecal matter hits the oscillating unit as far as the actual murders go, he gets off scot free. Why is The Crooken Man after Faith and Lily? Well, the Tweedles are after Faith for stealing something ... and according to Beauty, the Tweedles work for The Crooked Man ... the question becomes "what did Faith steal?"