my theory of whos the killer (contains spoilers)

[yarheeguy]

we all may think it was crane but i think it not him

i just thoght of something that can put it all together of whos the killer of faith and lilly

i think the merderer is that lady that opened the door for ya when your at the cat house. heres the reason why

when you were at room 207, you found a huff and puff. and that blonde lady (realy can't spell her name) said that she thoght bigby was the only one who smoke them, but when you at the cat house you see that lady smokeing a huff and puff

now we don't know whats her name is yet so here anorther theory

here what i think shes the queen of hearts from alice in wonderland

heres some reason why

1. you find only heads of faith and lilly and the qoh mostly say "off with your head"

2. she don't like to be largh at. (that what i think she mosly don't like)

3. dee and dum got a boss, maybe its qoh because thay are in the same book. and maybe she hired crane aswell.

4. on lilly's perfume bottle it says "use this" maybe a reffrance on the bottle says "drink me" and the cake says "eat me" in allice in wonderland

5. how and who could of taken the photo of crane and fake snow, to me i think qoh was there and taken the photo to show that the killer looks like crane and she can get off the hook

6. if you look very closely george was on the book and next to his name was "ms. smith" thats maybe qoh that she was with george, so that means crane use her fake last name

so i think its that lady and her name is known as the queen of hearts, i don't know her real or renamed name.

what do ya guys think about this theory.

[MorningLightMountain]

As mentioned before Tweedledee and Tweedledum are in from Through the Looking Glass and not Alice in Wonderland so far there hasn't been any suggestion of other characters from those books being involved.

As for perfume you'd assume that it's the same perfume that Snow uses and as with the outfits he is trying to make his fantasy as accurate as possible.

While I don't agree with your theory it's a reasonably complete one.

[yarheeguy]

Originally posted by MorningLightMountain:

As mentioned before Tweedledee and Tweedledum are in from Through the Looking Glass and not Alice in Wonderland so far there hasn't been any suggestion of other characters from those books being involved.

As for perfume you'd assume that it's the same perfume that Snow uses and as with the outfits he is trying to make his fantasy as accurate as possible.

ok you right again, but the queen of hearts is also in through the looking glass, but fully diffrent and named as the red queen. so i am going to see which queen am i'm talking about so its ether the red queen or the queen of hearts of her known as

[MorningLightMountain]

Quoting Wikipedia The Red Queen is a fictional character in Lewis Carroll's fantasy novella, Through the Looking-Glass. She is often confused with the Queen of Hearts from the previous book Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, although the two are very different.

[yarheeguy]

Originally posted by MorningLightMountain:

Quoting Wikipedia The Red Queen is a fictional character in Lewis Carroll's fantasy novella, Through the Looking-Glass. She is often confused with the Queen of Hearts from the previous book Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, although the two are very different.

ya know you can't always trust wikipedia

and i know that thay are different characters but i'm just thinking which one is morst likely

[yarheeguy]

just found anorther reason why that lady could be qoh

[MorningLightMountain]

Originally posted by yarheeguy:

Originally posted by MorningLightMountain:

Quoting Wikipedia The Red Queen is a fictional character in Lewis Carroll's fantasy novella, Through the Looking-Glass. She is often confused with the Queen of Hearts from the previous book Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, although the two are very different.

ya know you can't always trust wikipedia

and i know that thay are different characters but i'm just thinking which one is morst likely

A valid point regarding wikipedia but not in this instance.

[Dexano]

And who toke the foto of Crane and Snow (Lily)?

[yarheeguy]

Originally posted by Dexano:

And who toke the foto of Crane and Snow (Lily)?

i did said it.

[wazaa]

The basic in murder novels means that the killer has to shown himself on the first chapters. Now, if we check who shown, and who is not in the comics, the possibilities is not so big.

I vote for Little Mermaid.

[BeastBox]

I have a pet theory that the murder weapon is Woody's axe ... but it's being "borrowed" when he's fall-down drunk (since he doesn't always have it with him). Everyone keeps looking at the decapitations and saying "Headless Horseman" this or "Red Queen" that and other characters that aren't even in the book, and completely ignore the MAGIC FRIGGIN' AXE the game shoves in your face ten minutes in, even after comments Bigby makes to the murder weapon being sharp, or magic (or both). :)

Now, who and why are still up in the air. But we'll see. :)

[Snort Cannon]

its not Red Queen because shes not in the comics and Queen of hearts is also not in the comics

[yarheeguy]

Originally posted by Snort cannon:

its not Red Queen because shes not in the comics and Queen of hearts is also not in the comics

crane is in this game and he's not in the comics, faith is in this game and he's not in the comics, dum and dee is in the game but thay are not in the comics

i could go on and on

[Snort Cannon]

Crane is in the comics and his fantasies about snow are explained even more than at the game at the moment.

Originally posted by yarheeguy:

Originally posted by Snort cannon:

its not Red Queen because shes not in the comics and Queen of hearts is also not in the comics

crane is in this game and he's not in the comics, faith is in this game and he's not in the comics, dum and dee is in the game but thay are not in the comics

i could go on and on

[Snort Cannon]

The abscense of Dee and Dum hints at theyre death

[yarheeguy]

Originally posted by Snort cannon:

Crane is in the comics and his fantasies about snow are explained even more than at the game at the moment.

Originally posted by yarheeguy:

crane is in this game and he's not in the comics, faith is in this game and he's not in the comics, dum and dee is in the game but thay are not in the comics

i could go on and on

alright, i hope deathofcard will tell ya the correct thing about this, he is smart :)