Ichabod Crane SPOILER

[Blade Runner]

So Crane was obsessed with Snow White and killed Lily while acting out his twisted fantasy with her. Did this surprise you? I personally didn't think that he had it in him. He seemed like such a cream puff.

[blasto2236]

I'm still not sure he's the killer. He did smash the mirror in anger, but I think that may be because he realized he's a patsy in all of this.

I also wouldn't count The Woodsman out just yet. So far his favorite regular hooker and the fill in have both turned up dead. He's playing innocent, and I think they're playing it up a little too much. He's by no means the mastermind, but I still think he might be involved.

[Taci GG]

i think Crane got set up

[Blade Runner]

IDK, destroying the magic mirror just seems like such an extreme reaction if he's innocent. Lashing out violently isn't a great way to convince people that he didn't commit the murder.

[Petite Fleur Sasha]

I am not sure he could take a picture of himself being a murderer and maniac and just leave it there. He is pretty unpleasant but I guess too weak to do it and too smart not to be caught. So yes I think it is a set up too.

[BeastBox]

Pretty sure he's got a helpless woman fetish and smashed the Mirror partly out of anger, partly out of shame, partly out of "running now, have fun finding me without this". I don't think he killed Lily or Faith, though. And he definitely had no reason to be leaving their heads on his own front steps. Someone else is doing the beheading.

[blasto2236]

Originally posted by BeastBox:

Pretty sure he's got a helpless woman fetish and smashed the Mirror partly out of anger, partly out of shame, partly out of "running now, have fun finding me without this". I don't think he killed Lily or Faith, though. And he definitely had no reason to be leaving their heads on his own front steps. Someone else is doing the beheading.

Our opinions on the development process may differ, but your theory is spot on.

[Petite Fleur Sasha]

Well I agree. He could buy the ladies and have this fetish like dressing them, put flowers on the bad etc. And even have an unambiguous picture of it, right. But without murdering part.

[FmErick]

im wondering if lilly is a troll how could crane possibly be strong enough to kill her? if he did actually do it that is...

[himmatsj]

Originally posted by blasto2236:

I'm still not sure he's the killer. He did smash the mirror in anger, but I think that may be because he realized he's a patsy in all of this.

I also wouldn't count The Woodsman out just yet. So far his favorite regular hooker and the fill in have both turned up dead. He's playing innocent, and I think they're playing it up a little too much. He's by no means the mastermind, but I still think he might be involved.

How do you know it's the woodsman lily filled in for?

[blasto2236]

If you captured the Woodsman instead of Dee, he reveals that Lily was his usual girl, and one o the reasons he started whaling on Faith is because he was angry she showed up instead of Lily.

[Zaltys]

Originally posted by Jon Snow:

IDK, destroying the magic mirror just seems like such an extreme reaction if he's innocent. Lashing out violently isn't a great way to convince people that he didn't commit the murder.

I wouldn't call it an extreme reaction. Since he just lost his cozy job and has possibly been framed for murders. And of course, he knows that the real Snow will find out about it.

No matter what, his reputation is completely ruined. Even if he's not the killer, he's definitely been one of Lily's regular customers and has been withholding vital information.. That much was obvious when they examined the body; especially when you mention Lily's drug use and Crane gets all worried about diseases.

[Gigelorum]

I'm waiting for the Headless Horseman to make an appearance now....

[Figgleforth]

I suspect he was framed by Blue Beard. I mean we know that there are Glamours of other fables, perhaps Blue used a Glamour of Crane in-order to frame him, thus allowing Blue to take his place. Plus, why would those pictures have been there? Seems too easy.

[Superstar Carwash]

I'm pretty sure Crane was set up by Bluebeard.

[Der Zonk]

What if the Crane on the photo is a glamoured fable, too?