The Crooked Man Choice (SPOILERS)

[ZoomGamer]

I dont get it i choose to kill the crooked man and after the game it says to me 10,4 % choose kill him. WHY!? Seriusly only 10,4? The rest bring him alive. Tell me why i only see the reason Miss Snow say bring him alive.

[Gustavo Eats His Own Chicken?]

The ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ title is spoilers lol.

[ZoomGamer]

Originally posted by Maybe I should change picture:

The ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ title is spoilers lol.

Done now is not a spoiler thanks for saying that

[Gustavo Eats His Own Chicken?]

Originally posted by ZoomGamer:

Originally posted by Maybe I should change picture:

The ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ title is spoilers lol.

Done now is not a spoiler thanks for saying that

NP :)

[KewaG]

I chose to let him live in order to show him just how much power he lost. Sometimes it's better to let bastards live their days out in obscurity, knowing that their choices mattered. He was a broken man when I was done with him.

[Ginjjii]

i killed him. courts r always lean toward those with power and money. after u kill him u find out he isnt guilty of all u think was doing. lol good twist.

also u get to see the court scene witch is pretty lengthy if u dont kill him. i need to replay the game for this scene.

[KewaG]

Originally posted by Dradoh:

i killed him. courts r always lean toward those with power and money. after u kill him u find out he isnt guilty of all u think was doing. lol good twist.

also u get to see the court scene witch is pretty lengthy if u dont kill him. i need to replay the game for this scene.

Or you can just replay the scene. But the game is good enough to play over again. You almost need to in order to 100% the game anyway.

[Boss]

But if you do kill him you get the option to growl at the Fabletown crowd and walk away on them. Who would want to miss that?

[ZoomGamer]

i was just thinking "I have a chance to kill him and i say to George i will give The Crooked Man a worry dead so i just killed him"

[Nico]

I plan to replay to. I will probably make all of the opposite choices. I chose to let him live because I think he should have to pay, every second of every day until he dies.

If I knew I could growl at the fables I would have killed him though.

[ZoomGamer]

i also killed him because. I said to George i will give The Crooked Man a stronger dead. (Sorry if it dont make sense i am normally not speaking english)

[Zero, Dark Knight]

Even if it's a spoiler thread, I still think I'll cover it up until you mouse over it.



Having played the game a 'good' guy, I was planning on letting him live ...despite everything he'd done.. but that was until he tried to grab Wolf and drag him towards the well at the end trial... then I was like. NOPE and threw him down the well.

As for the question of 'why' I was planning to do that, it's really quite simple. It's because of how you think as a person. I find the moral highground to be defending yourself, not attacking someone else. and so I played Wolf like that.

When I play again, I'll probably play a big silent tough guy who goes after anything that looks at him the wrong way. and will I just outright kill him? Probably, yes, no trial, no choices, no defense. Hope it helps!

[BlckEagle89]

Originally posted by ZoomGamer:

I dont get it i choose to kill the crooked man and after the game it says to me 10,4 % choose kill him. WHY!? Seriusly only 10,4? The rest bring him alive. Tell me why i only see the reason Miss Snow say bring him alive.

i did it just to make a fair trial, the guy was a ass, but i was hoping that everyone see that. And on the final desicion i chose to throw him at the well because the imprioned part didn't like me, i thought that the witch would give him a way to scape at the end, so i prefered to sent him flying to nowhere

[BlckEagle89]

Originally posted by Zero, Dark Knight:

Even if it's a spoiler thread, I still think I'll cover it up until you mouse over it.



Having played the game a 'good' guy, I was planning on letting him live ...despite everything he'd done.. but that was until he tried to grab Wolf and drag him towards the well at the end trial... then I was like. NOPE and threw him down the well.

As for the question of 'why' I was planning to do that, it's really quite simple. It's because of how you think as a person. I find the moral highground to be defending yourself, not attacking someone else. and so I played Wolf like that.

When I play again, I'll probably play a big silent tough guy who goes after anything that looks at him the wrong way. and will I just outright kill him? Probably, yes, no trial, no choices, no defense. Hope it helps!

i have to make another round to get the rest of the achievemts and i have to admit that the straight forward, little words, big bad wolf is a good idea, if everyone hate you, let them do it for a real reason *evil laugh*

[Boss]

Bill himself (the author of the comics) took all the evil choices. While that may not prove that all the evil routes are 'canon' for Bigby from the comics, it's a pretty good indication.

Bigby in the comics kills Crane because he betrayed Fabletown and had rape fantasies of Snow.
Given that this takes place before the comics, I'd say it's very likely that Bigby would kill Dum (he fired at Fabletown residents with a shotgun ffs).

As for the Crooked Man's choice, it's the same as Dum really. He tried to have Bigby killed multiple times. It's a bit of a flaw that you cannot bring this up more often during the trial (the Crooked Man just says something like "it was unfortunate" and then everything is apparantly forgiven by the audience). But just the fact alone that he assaulted Bigby in his hideout, at the factory and likely send D&D after him is enough for Bigby to throw him down the well. I believe Bigby from the comics would do the same.

[Ruv]

I replay it every time cuz it's just interesting but most of my choices are killing him. This freaking man pissed me off so much OMG. Even when you let him live like a raven in a cage he stays with that freaking old which and I don't trust her at all. So, yeah, people better to kill this bastard.