Stay loyal to Ashley or romance Jack?

[JuLLe]

So right now I'm doing a complete playtrough of Mass Effect, and I'm wondering wether I should romance Jack or stay romanced to Ashley.
I've done every romance in the series except Jack and Ashley/Kaidan. Need help deciding this
Thanks

[SwobyJ]

Ashley is more core to the story in ME3 than Jack.

Super slight spoiler warning?

Ashley:
-initial squadmate but leaves and rejoins
-core romance content
-1-3 missions that really involve her
-Citadel DLC adds more

Jack:
-not a squadmate
-secondary romance content
-1 mission that really involves her
-Citadel DLC adds more to equalize her as a love interest, and temporary use in battle in an arena mode
-Extended Cut DLC equalizes her more too

If you really like Jack more, go for it (at least if you're okay with buying Citadel DLC for ME3 when you get it). Otherwise Ashley is more supported in terms of trilogy support (except for ME2 having almost no content).

[Bisen]

I never cared much for Ashley.

[WalrusMan]

Liara or Tali...

Okay I'm a xenophile. Ahsley is xenophobic.

So I'm just going to go ahead and say Jack.

[TheDamnHunter]

I was never a fan of Ash, I killed her as often as I could in ME1. But that's just my opinion. I think Jack mackes a great character development in ME3, while Ash is pretty much the same as in ME2. I really liked the reactions of her students, when you stay loyal to Jack in ME3, the romance with Ash is more romantic though.

[Pav]

For me Miranda every single time - I find it so hard to stay loyal to anyone from ME1 as soon as Miranda enters the picture (which is the first 5 mins of ME2 haha)

Ashley and Tali are probably to 2 I liked the least

Tali - Never even tried to romance her (just seemed wrong - she seems like a much younger sister)

Ashley - I always found it fun to romance her in ME then dump her in ME2 after her ♥♥♥♥♥ fit on horizon. Then in ME3 when she gets all pissy about it, I throw it back in her face :D'

So to answer your question, Jack everytime.

Imo Jack and Miranda were the best romance choices - if only they were squadmates in ME3