Space Engineers

Space Engineers

View Stats:
Why are the controls in this game so bad? (this and the UI)
I got a 5 buttons Razor mouse and MS comfort keyboard.
Nothing fancy programable or so. Basic stuf. All USB. Love it.

My stuff works with ALL of my 500+ games. No exceptions.
From SNES emulators to AAA and every genre there is.

The one exception to this unbreakable rule: SpaceEngineers...
... which goes out of its way to be a freaking d+++ about it.

---------------------------

I want to put this action on the side buttons of my mouse.
>CANT DO THAT!
So despite not being used, and you recognizing it, you won't let me program em?
>YES! HA! IN UR FACE!

Okay, how about I use this key on my keyboard. Its not used for a-
>CANT DO THAT!!
Why?! Its NOT used either!!
>CANT DO THAT!

Ugh... alright then... I will try a different change. How about I put C on CTRL?
>You can do that (but you can only fly down and not crouch now)
..... game, what did you just say?
>Nothing! Just go ahead and... play and ... fly... (ahemcantcrouchAHEEMM)
.... okayyy......
---------------------------

Does that 'conversation' sound FUN to you? The game is a moron.
If i want to bind a key ITS MY THING IF IT WORKS FOR ME OR NOT.
Not a REASON in the world to block my keybindings! NONE!

Every darn game i ever played got that memo!
Heck! Some insane nerds use TRACKING BALLS for e-Sports...
But this game shows the finger to the most basic requests?!
wow!

Okay fine, whatever, lets ADAPT TO THE ♥♥♥♥♥♥ and work around it somehow.
Used C for crouch and CTRL for height and R for jetpack and whatnot~fine fine.

---------------------------

UNTIL......

I saw guy on youtube make a basic spaceship. Alright. cool. I want that.
Oh he uses MIRROR MODE so he places 2 blocks at once. Now thats a time saver.

How do i ... *reads wiki/controls*
Alright. Its RIGHT THERE! Get the block. Aim it. Hit N+M to engage and cycle.
Sure, easy en.......................
.....................................
....................... you are ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ me?!
...........
it doesn't work!

I thought "perhaps I mixed up controls and its blocking it?"
So i reset them to the rather painful default (very oldshool layout tbh) but whatever.

I try again! I play by the games nonsensical rules! 100%

Do it 1:1 like in the video: nothing.
No message, no visual, and when placing its just 1 stupid block.

sigh...

At this point I say the controls are just ♥♥♥.
Never had a game this disobedient.

Bad. Wonky. Clunky. Sluggish. Laggy. Sure. Whatever. No biggy. I can deal with THAT.
But not once a game told me 'Push X' and I pushed 'X' and I got the 'finger' for doing so.

If this game was a dog... I might had to bring behind the barn end its suffering.
That's the vibe I am getting here.

---------------------------

Now so far the game was nice.
Building, digging, getting that crappy rover to work. Sweet little base...
... but those kinda things add up and break my enjoyment like a steady drop of water...

>Storage is a mess
>Controls just don't work
>Connectors of buggy were glitched (making me wonder why it wouldn't charge)
>Jetpack doesn't obey gravity when turning around (there is a 'artificial horizon' RIGHT THERE but its of NO USE. If I see I am tilted I SEE THAT I AM TILTED... doesn't help the issue! How do you take the fun out of a jetpack?!
>Some buttons got tooltips (super useful!) and other don't or tell you LITERALLY the name of the button your mouse is on....... wat? alright! google it is!

Those are all things you do/run into/have to use all the time.

I seriously recommend, before adding any more content, to take a deep breath:

> look at the storage mod and how other game do it. Let us bundle them in ONE big chunk like a Minecraft 2x crate (when attached with no filters or whatnot)
Now you got 1 instead of 2-6 'containers.

> when using a jetpack the biggest/nearest source should be 'down'. Especially on planets. "turning it on and off" and "arrow keys" are nonsense! NO OTHER GAME DOES THAT! For a reason! Its annoying to lose orientation all the time. Fly into a hole, look left, YOU FLY SLANTED! thanks for that one! Is this freaking G'Pollice?! Esh...

> Go through the list of ALL buttons and add tooltips. Why do I have to google it all if it can be in the game? You want your players to play or jump through links in a browser?
Some got tooltips, great. Some do not, bad. Some have THEIR NAME as tooltip, srly?

>And LET US BIND THE KEYS however we please! And make them work!
Not being able to - or be able to - but losing the 2ndary function... that just sucks!

Imagine you adjust your seat in your IRL car and suddenly you can't shift gears.

Apparently this game was released 2013.
I noticed a few years prior and thought 'eh, lets give em time to iron things out' and moved on...
Now, 10 YEARS after relase, it still has issues like a day1 beta.

Some of which so basic its baffling. There is just no excuse.
Last edited by FizzlePopBerryTwist; Jun 3, 2023 @ 12:24pm
< >
Showing 1-15 of 24 comments
Dan2D3D  [developer] Jun 3, 2023 @ 2:28pm 
Hi FizzlePopBerryTwist.

I see you create a lot of good Feedbacks and I recommend to tell the ones working on the game, because here on Steam is made to chat with players.

The contact links are in the pinned green messages but I will share the one you need.

All report directly to the SE Programmers :

Support Portal = https://support.keenswh.com/spaceengineers/pc
(create "Bug report" or "Request help"(Private) or "Feedback"(Petition) on the Portal)
Last edited by Dan2D3D; Jun 3, 2023 @ 3:18pm
Fianna Jun 3, 2023 @ 3:12pm 
how do i use rations
Jack Schitt Jun 3, 2023 @ 3:25pm 
We don't have to turn the jetpack on/off to go down. The C key is down.
Take a look at all of the controls. They're listed in the game (where we can edit them if we wanted to). It's easy to find...

Options > Controls.

Changing the keybinds is a bad idea for many reasons. The #1 reason to leave them alone, look at them and learn what the default keys are, is that there are so many commands in this game there are very, very few keys that don't do something. Even Shift+key, CNTRL+key, and ALT+key is all assigned to something for almost every one of the 101 keys on a standard keyboard.

The only key I can think of that doesn't do anything is F2.
Dr.Corpse Jun 3, 2023 @ 5:34pm 
Originally posted by Jack Schitt:
We don't have to turn the jetpack on/off to go down. The C key is down.
Take a look at all of the controls. They're listed in the game (where we can edit them if we wanted to). It's easy to find...

Options > Controls.

Changing the keybinds is a bad idea for many reasons. The #1 reason to leave them alone, look at them and learn what the default keys are, is that there are so many commands in this game there are very, very few keys that don't do something. Even Shift+key, CNTRL+key, and ALT+key is all assigned to something for almost every one of the 101 keys on a standard keyboard.

The only key I can think of that doesn't do anything is F2.

Even flight simulators which traditionally map almost every single key in your keyboard PLUS a number of shift / alt combos let you fully customize your inputs, not limited to keyboards but specialized controllers.
Jack Schitt Jun 3, 2023 @ 5:56pm 
The controls can be edited by clicking Options on the main menu screen. The option to change them is there. Space Engineers is a Sandbox game. A flight simulator is a completely different genre. Onions don't taste like apples.
I am glad to report: after reseting the keybindings the 'CTRL' now >works< for down AND crouching.

While this is nice in itself, it only goes to confirm that the controls indeed are bugged, since the same key as before now works as intended.
I wonder if those other issues are resolved if I reset /swap keys often enough. At least those that the game "graciously" allows me to be used.

Though I have to stress; without reseting the key-bindings on a wim, I'd never known that. (and no, before you ask, CTRL isn't used by anything else. 95% of keybindings are vanilla).

Have a good one o/
Jack Schitt Jun 4, 2023 @ 3:44am 
Interesting. You 'reset' them? Meaning you reset them to default? The default key for crouch and down with the jetpack is C.
Originally posted by Jack Schitt:
We don't have to turn the jetpack on/off to go down. The C key is down.
Take a look at all of the controls. They're listed in the game (where we can edit them if we wanted to). It's easy to find...

Options > Controls.

Changing the keybinds is a bad idea for many reasons. The #1 reason to leave them alone, look at them and learn what the default keys are, is that there are so many commands in this game there are very, very few keys that don't do something. Even Shift+key, CNTRL+key, and ALT+key is all assigned to something for almost every one of the 101 keys on a standard keyboard.

The only key I can think of that doesn't do anything is F2.
A good point.
The keybindings are 2-3 layered and totally overloaded.
How many of those you need REALLY? Let alone at the start.

Keep the movement and the building.
That's what players do at the start (for hours and hours).

The rest, the specific ones, you might as well leave unasigned.

Later, once you are a super spacecombat ace, you can look up and sort out the options you need. This way you don't have to worry about 2-3x binding and controls blocking another (like it was with my CTRL apparently!)

----------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------

Not like the key-layout is any good.
Some essential keys are in the middle of the keyboard...

Like 'INVENTORY on 'I'

The inventory?! The one thing you will use CONSTANTLY (especially at the start) is on a key you need to lift your hand off, look down, and tap it- only to center back on WASD?
... thats so bad...

I put that one on 'T' so I can quickly manage/build. Not lift any hand from anything.

This kinda layout, so clunky, I think they used on Baldurs Gate? Its ancient.
You don't give functions to keys with the right starting letter! Thats childsplay.

You give functions to letters >centered around movement<... and expand from there!
Movement/navigation is the first thing each game needs.
Anything after that is merely an addition that should help to elevate this.

Once you figure that thing out (like gaming did in the past 20years) you get a good layout with essentials 'within reach' and extra buttons for more elaborate actions further away...

--- and once those elaborate actions become more relevant, players can swap a key or two.

Craming those kinda options into the very start (like with 'T' for example being alignment nonsense nobody uses for 35hrs) you are not doing anyone ANY favor.
Originally posted by Jack Schitt:
The controls can be edited by clicking Options on the main menu screen. The option to change them is there. Space Engineers is a Sandbox game. A flight simulator is a completely different genre. Onions don't taste like apples.
Here is a list of the 457ish games I currently own.
I didn't include: those I deleted, refunded, demos, briefly played on free weekends, forgot, played at a friends place, and a bunch of mobile stuff and whatnot...

It doesn't matter what genre a game is.
Its software. They all offer keybindings.
They all~ every one on this list~ work and obey any tap I make.

SpaceEngineers prefers to give me the finger.

As mentioned before: i reset the controls on a wim to (hopefully) fix the MIRROR MODE...
only thing i happened to fix (i only found out after a nap) was CTRL now does go down AND crouch.

The game is bugged. its sad but it happens.
I'd loved to know that one sooner.
Who expects the <controls< to be bugged this bad?

Thought that issue died in 95'
Originally posted by Jack Schitt:
Interesting. You 'reset' them? Meaning you reset them to default? The default key for crouch and down with the jetpack is C.
Yes.
I reset them to default to make 100% sure I didn't miss anything, since the 'mirror build mode' I saw doesn't work for me... and:
The mirror building still doesn't work... (and I gave up on it)

... but setting C' to 'CTRL now does go 'down' AND 'crouch' like I wanted it to do days ago.

That's how I did bind my keys since 'C' is a bad choice in my opinion.**
The second I swapped C' to 'CTRL (left)' it now works with 'down' AND 'crouch'.

Same config.
Same device.
Different day.

Its like 'turning it off and on again' ... a classic :)

**ps.
Put your hand on WASD.
Now look at it...
Middle finger is on W or S
Ring is on A.
Pointer on D.

To reach C your best opition is the MiddleFinger.
You leave W+D to hold 'C' to go down.
So you can't move forward/backward AND go down at the same time.

That's bad. Objectively.

Putting C' onto CTRL' neither of those WASD fingers leaves its place.
Your 'little thinger' will handle going down/crouch for you without losing control.

Same for sprinting. Little finger does hold SHIFT for you.
Since you never RUN AND CROUCH or 'go down and run' at the same time, thats ideal.

Using 'C', in my opinion, is simply following old layouts without giving it thought.
And this is what happened here. 'Inventory' is on 'I' for petes sake...

How often do you need your inventory? :)
Might as well put it on 'INSERT' or the backside of your Computer while you are at it lol

ps. I also put Jetpack on 'R for the same reasons.
You leave 'D' for a second but thats usually fine and the increase in 'on/off' speed is more than worth it ;) This way you can orientate that broken jetpack to the ground way easier ♥

psps 'P for Park to 'Enter by the numlock'
If i want to chat i hit the middle Enter.
Searching for 'P just to park my vehicles (and doing so constantly) seems dumb.
The Enter by Numlock now is my handbreak. Ez to reach for regular/quick use.
*puts on sunglasses*
Last edited by FizzlePopBerryTwist; Jun 4, 2023 @ 5:02am
Imagine how nice building could be if scrolling the wheel rotates blocks for you.
And IF the game let me use button 4+5 on the side of my mouse i could flip the angle.

Flip, rotate, place.
Not using that stupid 2x6 cluster in the middle of my keyboard (far away from useful controls)

Again: Bad controls here. Bad bindings too.
Could come back all day and find new issues with it but my point has been made ♥
Gorbadon Jun 4, 2023 @ 5:00am 
Originally posted by FizzlePopBerryTwist:
Put your hand on WASD.
Now look at it...
Middle finger is on W or S
Ring is on A.
Pointer on D.

To reach C your best opition is the MiddleFinger.
You leave W+D to hold 'C' to go down.
So you can't move forward/backward AND go down at the same time.

I use thumb to press C or Space, trying to use MiddleFinger for that would feel quite akward for me. (European QWERTZ keyboard layout if that is different for you)

Originally posted by FizzlePopBerryTwist:
Imagine how nice building could be if scrolling the wheel rotates blocks for you.
And IF the game let me use button 4+5 on the side of my mouse i could flip the angle.

Scrolling selects a block from a block group (the ones with a + on their symbol), so that funktion would have to be moved somewhere else to not conflict.
Last edited by Gorbadon; Jun 4, 2023 @ 5:06am
Jack Schitt Jun 4, 2023 @ 5:08am 
"To reach C your best opition is the MiddleFinger."
I use my index finger to press C. We're supposed to use our left index finger for that.

We don't have to hold C to crouch. It toggles: Press C once = crouch. Press C again (or shift) the engineer stands back up.

I use the default keybinds in this game because there's so many of them I don't want to make a mess of them. I tried changing them when I first started playing in 2012 and it was a headache getting ALL of the binds bound to something. On top of that it made a mess of the menu and other commands trying to change them around.

"Same for sprinting. Little finger does hold SHIFT for you."
CAPs toggles Run/Walk by default.

You obviously don't know what the keybinds are and do. I tried to prevent you from making this mess on yourself. I tried...
Now when you have issues with something and need help with 'what's the keybind for [this]?' nobody is going to be able to help you. You're not going to be able to follow helpful tutorial videos that share things like "I did that by pressing [this] key then [this] key." either.

"Later, once you are a super spacecombat ace"
By the things you're saying I think it's safe to assume you're fairly new to the game. You'll see....
I tried.

Best of luck! :D
If you got the controls workin' for ya, Great!
Jack Schitt Jun 4, 2023 @ 5:15am 
Originally posted by FizzlePopBerryTwist:
Imagine how nice building could be if scrolling the wheel rotates blocks for you.
There's a plugin included with the Plugin Loader that does that. I use it. But...because there's so many binds that aren't available even that plugin requires us to hold alt or shift and use the wheel to rotate the blocks.

Originally posted by FizzlePopBerryTwist:

Again: Bad controls here. Bad bindings too.
Could come back all day and find new issues with it but my point has been made ♥
I don't agree, at all, that they're "bad". You don't know what the keybinds are (you've proven that with the things you've said :P).

I tried warning you you're only making a mess on yourself changing the keybinds.
I tried....
If they work that way for you...great!

Who wants to bet a few bucks this person's going to be changing them back to default and following my advice sooner than later? I did it to myself too when I started playing. Then I realized, by moving them, I was screwing myself out of so many other things and it was best to learn and deal with what the default keys are. LOL
PS. now that I >can< crouch with CTRL I noticed the 'going through CTRL1-0 is a bit problematic....but that's on the game. Not on me.

Its bad to tie "down+crouch" onto one key when anything else isn't.

A game where you can walk+ steer vehicles shouldn't layer those controls
or at least let us change the CTRL1-0 stuff. Which it also does not.

So 2x fail on the game.
Either let us bind any function to any key, or gtfo ^^

This reminds me of games that layer functions to keys with a timer on it, where the game has to wait for half a second to identify if you are holding, or pressing the button, before taking appropriate action.

Just... don't

put 'next toolbar' + previous tollbar' on + and - on the num.
I really don't want to give into those nonsensical controls forcing you to do X by blocking off controls with other controls or outright blocking keys.

Why block players from using options YOU PROVIDE? That's just being a jerk.

"Sorry, can't let you use this fork, use the one on the left...'
Cause you know; a fish fork couldn't possibly be used on salad. No way.
Last edited by FizzlePopBerryTwist; Jun 4, 2023 @ 5:31am
< >
Showing 1-15 of 24 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Jun 3, 2023 @ 12:21pm
Posts: 24