The big question.. Assetto Corsa Vs Project Cars (NO FANBOYS)

[Klaus Schwab]

Really impressed with how both games look but I must say I'm leaning with how Project Cars is looking, youtubed the video where a guy is playing in the EVO in the wet and man it looks awsome.

I'm excited to see them both side by side when they are both fully released and I'm even more curious on how many mdders there will be for each game and why they chose that particular game to start modding.

What's everyones opinion on Project Cars ?

( ASSETTO CORSA IS NUMBER ONE BEATS EVERY OTHER RACING GAME EVER will simply be deemed as fanboyism)

[Bracinjo]

Both still have a long way to go but I've played Project Cars for a few hours recently and it's a simcade at best. Yes, it looks great and it has a lot of content but if you want sim racing Assetto Corsa wins between these two.

[WannaBE]

I doubt you will get a neutral verdict here. Best advice is to try both yourself and then make up your mind.

[Kelt]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vlSRYk7h1n0&feature=player_embedded

[SeriousSpy]

I'm buying CARS, I'm also planning on grabbing rF2 soon, perhaps once a few more good mods come out. I don't see the point in only buying one or two things, especially when it's something like a racing sim, isn't it best to grab as much as possible and have as much variety as possible?

[Bambuslooter]

Own both and you are helping the simracing genre.
pCars is miles ahead in the looking and contentwise now too, if you dont look at modding of other games.
physicswise it isnt ready, so everythin can change.
I will buy pcars also :)

[Crunch]

I only own AC right now but after watching many youtube videos I can say Pcars looks leaps and bounds ahead of AC in terms of features, visuals, and track environments. As for physics, I cant comment much other than from what I can tell the driving models are improving with Pcars. If I had to guess I would say overall Pcars is going to come out of top, as AC is far too limited in features as well as its other issues.

[Marty]

引用自 Umadbrah：

( ASSETTO CORSA IS NUMBER ONE BEATS EVERY OTHER RACING GAME EVER will simply be deemed as fanboyism)

So only Pcars fanboys can reply lol, Im a fan of AC but will still buy pcars when I can. Still from most reports by others I know pcars has a long way to go physics wise to match up in the most important aspect of a sim for me. Sure pretty graphics are nice but most of thats only good for replays and screenshots. My eyes dont see things in the way some games seem to think they would, so in car driv8ng really doesnt need overblown graphical effects

[Packy]

引用自 Stein：

I doubt you will get a neutral verdict here. Best advice is to try both yourself and then make up your mind.

+1

I will buy pCARS when it is released and continue enjoying both games (along with iRacing and rFactor2!)
: )

[SeriousSpy]

They'll compete with eachother, which is great news. I really, really hope that Project CARS kicks ass, because that makes Kunos get a move on and also make their game more kickass. Competition is good. I also hope that rF2 get's so much better than it is.

[Crunch]

引用自 Marty Cerven：

引用自 Umadbrah：

( ASSETTO CORSA IS NUMBER ONE BEATS EVERY OTHER RACING GAME EVER will simply be deemed as fanboyism)

So only Pcars fanboys can reply lol, Im a fan of AC but will still buy pcars when I can. Still from most reports by others I know pcars has a long way to go physics wise to match up in the most important aspect of a sim for me. Sure pretty graphics are nice but most of thats only good for replays and screenshots. My eyes dont see things in the way some games seem to think they would, so in car driv8ng really doesnt need overblown graphical effects

There is something to say about graphics though in any type of simulation. Its not just the textures and lighting effects, but its much about the overall track environment and scale that add immersion. Pcars looks excellent in the track environment department. However, if the drive model sucks, then yes, its a wash.

[supreme]

I recently made a post on the pcars forum about how the physics and ffb were "a joke" compared to ac and I got on the moderators' radar, he told me to be more constructively critical so I sent him a long post about how frustrated I am about the game's tire model and how I can floor it on grass and gravel carefree, and the fact that the game has been in development for so long and they're suddenly making the game more simcade, and how it's really aggrivating people. He seemed to receive the info really quite well so it makes me actually hopeful they're going to do something about that stuff. I can also tell they are really trying when it comes to ffb and tire model.

[pennarguy]

I am hanging fire; I thought the physics and ffb etc in AC would never be equalled, but GSC Extreme, has near as damn done that and kept an old schooll hard core sim format, which many of us are happy with.
People who are signed into Pcars, that I know, say that it is not a hard core sim, but it is high end simcade (whatever that may be) but it is still beta and can change.
I like AC to a certain extent, but it is not my fav' sim; sort of one of the top 3 for me.
It burst onto the sim scene with early release and has progressed well in certain areas, but it is lacking in lots of areas for sure.

[rudski]

ASSETTO CORSA IS NUMBER ONE BEATS EVERY OTHER RACING GAME EVER

;)

[Klaus Schwab]

引用自 rudski：

ASSETTO CORSA IS NUMBER ONE BEATS EVERY OTHER RACING GAME EVER

;)

YOU !! I TOLD YOU NOT TO SAY THAT WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY DID YOU SAYY THAT

[pennarguy]

引用自 Umadbrah：

引用自 rudski：

ASSETTO CORSA IS NUMBER ONE BEATS EVERY OTHER RACING GAME EVER

;)

YOU !! I TOLD YOU NOT TO SAY THAT WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY DID YOU SAYY THAT

Seems like capitals are the in thing. :)