Banished

Banished

查看统计:
OhhJim 2019 年 11 月 21 日 下午 7:51
Some similar games to Banished
On Steam:
Ostriv
Nebuchadnezzar
Sumerians

Not on Steam:
Aztec Empire
https://forums.tigsource.com/index.php?topic=63983.0

These probably won't be out this year, but they look similar to Banished and/or the Tilted Mill games (Pharaoh/Caesar/Rise of the Middle Kingdom)
最后由 OhhJim 编辑于; 2019 年 11 月 21 日 下午 7:54
< >
正在显示第 46 - 60 条,共 61 条留言
OhhJim 2021 年 7 月 25 日 上午 10:59 
引用自 RavenNightsong
Reading thru the comments I see no one has mentioned Kingdoms Reborn. You build your city, has other town to trade with (or compete with), has a multi-player mode and more. (No mods for the game that I know of)

Kingdoms and Castles is another great game. Build your city, defend it and more. (Has mods available for those who are interested)

Both games are regularly updated as well.

Kingdoms Reborn is Early Access, so it probably wouldn't get the recommendations another game would. I tend to shy away from Early Access games, myself, but it looks interesting, and the multiplayer aspect is a bit unusual for a City Builder.
Grat Dalton 2021 年 7 月 26 日 下午 10:19 
引用自 OhhJim
Kingdoms Reborn is Early Access, so it probably wouldn't get the recommendations another game would.
This thread started with early access games listed by OP.

My wish list:
- Manor Lords TBA
- Timerborn Early access release 2021. Demo available now.
OhhJim 2021 年 7 月 26 日 下午 10:22 
引用自 Grat Dalton

My wish list:
- Manor Lords TBA
- Timerborn Early access release 2021. Demo available now.

Timberborn is weird, but some people may like it. I just can't get into the beavers making stuff.

Looking forward to Manor Lords.
最后由 OhhJim 编辑于; 2021 年 7 月 26 日 下午 10:22
CountessaNera 2021 年 7 月 27 日 上午 8:32 
Just did this search myself recently. And played Ostriv to start with. Last game I tried was Patron: https://store.steampowered.com/app/1538570/Patron/

And that one has a public demo on store page, so it is possible to try it out. Personally, i loved it completely. Very serious Banished vibe, but broader gameplay, up to date visuals and overall feels more dynamic and good to play. And supposedly it is to be released in a couple weeks time
Tux 2021 年 7 月 27 日 上午 9:17 
I dont care what anyone says, I think Forest Village is just fine. Many people just have a rage against the dev for whatever reason ( I really dont know) that makes them unable to evaualte the game play itself objectively
OhhJim 2021 年 7 月 27 日 上午 11:17 
引用自 Tux
I dont care what anyone says, I think Forest Village is just fine. Many people just have a rage against the dev for whatever reason ( I really dont know) that makes them unable to evaualte the game play itself objectively
It's fine that you love Forest Village. I know nothing about the developers; I just found it difficult to play. I think some developers don't understand how hard their games are, maybe because they play it constantly, so it's easy for them. Company of Heroes 2 is like this, for example. I played a lot of CoH1, but had big trouble with 2. Luckily, a veteran player showed me some things, and now I enjoy the game. But it shouldn't take that happening for a player to understand a game.
Tux 2021 年 7 月 27 日 下午 12:25 
引用自 OhhJim
引用自 Tux
I dont care what anyone says, I think Forest Village is just fine. Many people just have a rage against the dev for whatever reason ( I really dont know) that makes them unable to evaualte the game play itself objectively
It's fine that you love Forest Village. I know nothing about the developers; I just found it difficult to play. I think some developers don't understand how hard their games are, maybe because they play it constantly, so it's easy for them. Company of Heroes 2 is like this, for example. I played a lot of CoH1, but had big trouble with 2. Luckily, a veteran player showed me some things, and now I enjoy the game. But it shouldn't take that happening for a player to understand a game.

fair enough.

as a side note, the secret to that game is to use the kids in first person as much as possible (for better or worse)
mikebou 2021 年 7 月 29 日 下午 3:25 
I love playing Banished. And I'm really enjoying LIF-FV atm.
I play Medieval Engineers a fair bit, but the early abandonment of the game left it in a very buggy state.
And I also play Kingdoms. This game is developed by a single dev and he's doing a great job.
I also play Stranded Deep, now while this game is not of the medieval genre, it scratches the same itch for me. The devs have continued to really work hard at improving the game.
Claybot 2021 年 7 月 31 日 上午 9:44 
Ostriv has potential, (if the Dev ever figures out the priorities), if you play with Migration On (Nomads) .
Migration Off (No Nomads) is a mess, terrible balance being the main issue.
OhhJim 2021 年 8 月 7 日 下午 10:08 
I got the Patron demo, but it won't Play. I get the menu, but after I click 'Play', it closes and goes back to the Steam main menu. I guess I won't be buying it.
X-C0brA-X 2021 年 8 月 22 日 上午 5:54 
引用自 Rainbow Droid
Rimworld is just incredibly fantastic and overall a much better, more original, more detailed, and more complete game than Banished. It also has more and better mods.

But it is not really that similar to Banished.

Rimworld is a sci-fi colony survival sandbox soap opera that focuses on only a handful of individual colonists per game, but in extreme detail and with a focus on their relationships and personalities, with base building and base efficiency planning being only a major component of the game, instead of the focus as it is in Banished. It is also an ugly game with 2D sprites and your imagination has to substitute for what it lacks in graphics, so building a complex base is not nearly as rewarding as building a complex city in Banished.

But Rimworld is an incredibly amazing game and definitely Top 10 All Time PC Game material once you've learned how to play and modded it up. Seriously, it is that good. Easily worth full price, and I don't say that often.

I'll take a look at Founders Fortune later, thanks for the tip.

edit: Here's a couple more games similar to Banished:

- Foundation (I haven't bought yet but I'm going to soon, it looks great)
- Rise to Ruins (I bought but haven't played enough to give a full review, but what I've seen is very promising)


If you like Rimworld you might want to check out Going Medieval. It is pretty much a Rimworld copy set in medieval times but they took Rimworld to the next step allowing you too build multiple story buildings and even build underground.

For instance to stop food from spoiling you dig a cellar so when it is 70F outside it is 40F in the cellar so the food stays fresh. It is like they took the good parts of Rimworld and improved on it. You even have the random events like Rimworld such as heat waves, cold snaps (trying to survive in -40F weather is brutal and hypothermia comes quick to those not prepared), you even get recruits like Rimworld such as an escaped slave who you accept then must fight off the raid chasing them.

It is my new addiction simply because I can now build towers or elevated walkways and position my archers on them to unleash hell on the attackers from above where the attackers cannot touch them unless they have bows as well. It already has hundreds of hours of gameplay in it and it just hit EA with a lot of stuff planned for the future.

Like most of these games it is made by a small team of very passionate devs who truly care about their game. If you played Rimworld then jumping into Going Medieval will be a breeze. With those 2 games you really do not need any others because they will easily give you thousands of hours of entertainment.

I too love Rimworld which is why between Steam and my pre-Steam playtime I have well over 6000 hours in that game but Going Medieval has been the only game to actually break my Rimworld addiction.
Morkonan 2021 年 8 月 22 日 下午 5:48 
引用自 X-C0brA-X
...
If you like Rimworld you might want to check out Going Medieval. It is pretty much a Rimworld copy set in medieval times but they took Rimworld to the next step allowing you too build multiple story buildings and even build underground.
...

I've been watching that, too. I'm waiting until the dev adds some features before making a final decision on it. It looks promising, but I want to be sure that the building and z-level features aren't just a "hook" and that there's some deep and interesting mechanics there.

A headsup for "Songs of Syx" - The demo is free, full-featured, and only differs in that it's something like a quarter's worth of patches behind the main build. It's much more a DF-Clone type of game, but I think the scope and intent there is pretty interesting. (No z-levels and it may not appeal to die-hard Banished fans due to it's larger scale, graphics, and clear "Dwarf Fortress-like" inspiration.) If the dev does everything they say they're going to do, it could be a pretty big hit. Eclectic, but it'll gather and keep quite a few fans.

Dwarf Fortress: Steam Version - That should be ready for some kind of release fairly Soon ™. Six months or so, maybe earlier?

Ostriv - I haven't looked at it in awhile. Development seemed to be weird, so I just put my interest on the back-burner and will wait for the next headline I see.

Banished is one of my "go to" games. It's just... well done. Banished does have rather light-weight elements here and there, but the way it's all combined together yields a good play experience. It's a dependable, enjoyable, game.

My "dream game" in the Survival Colony-Builder genre would be a game like Banished with RPG elements for the colonists as well as social interaction elements and some increased priority on happiness/satisfaction/etc. A light/shallow combat system and some deeper trade "diplomacy" sorts of options would round that out nicely. Of course, moddability is key these days. (Hint - That's to let the reader know that if they come across a game like that, linking it would be very much appreciated. ;))

I've looked at other "sort of" survival colony-builder games, (All the various "kingdom" stuffs, etc) but the focus on proper scale seems to just not be as finely tuned as Banished and some other games. Banished has nearly "perfect" focus for its scale.
X-C0brA-X 2021 年 8 月 23 日 下午 4:18 
引用自 Morkonan
引用自 X-C0brA-X
...
If you like Rimworld you might want to check out Going Medieval. It is pretty much a Rimworld copy set in medieval times but they took Rimworld to the next step allowing you too build multiple story buildings and even build underground.
...

I've been watching that, too. I'm waiting until the dev adds some features before making a final decision on it. It looks promising, but I want to be sure that the building and z-level features aren't just a "hook" and that there's some deep and interesting mechanics there.

A headsup for "Songs of Syx" - The demo is free, full-featured, and only differs in that it's something like a quarter's worth of patches behind the main build. It's much more a DF-Clone type of game, but I think the scope and intent there is pretty interesting. (No z-levels and it may not appeal to die-hard Banished fans due to it's larger scale, graphics, and clear "Dwarf Fortress-like" inspiration.) If the dev does everything they say they're going to do, it could be a pretty big hit. Eclectic, but it'll gather and keep quite a few fans.

Dwarf Fortress: Steam Version - That should be ready for some kind of release fairly Soon ™. Six months or so, maybe earlier?

Ostriv - I haven't looked at it in awhile. Development seemed to be weird, so I just put my interest on the back-burner and will wait for the next headline I see.

Banished is one of my "go to" games. It's just... well done. Banished does have rather light-weight elements here and there, but the way it's all combined together yields a good play experience. It's a dependable, enjoyable, game.

My "dream game" in the Survival Colony-Builder genre would be a game like Banished with RPG elements for the colonists as well as social interaction elements and some increased priority on happiness/satisfaction/etc. A light/shallow combat system and some deeper trade "diplomacy" sorts of options would round that out nicely. Of course, moddability is key these days. (Hint - That's to let the reader know that if they come across a game like that, linking it would be very much appreciated. ;))

I've looked at other "sort of" survival colony-builder games, (All the various "kingdom" stuffs, etc) but the focus on proper scale seems to just not be as finely tuned as Banished and some other games. Banished has nearly "perfect" focus for its scale.

I understand and according to their road map they still have a ton of stuff to add. I played the demo when it was out and was intrigued by the z levels so most of my playtime on the EA version is mainly seeing just how crazy I can go with building and what the limits are. It is pretty funny to be digging part of my base underground then suddenly collapse the buildings above ground by not putting enough support underground.

I have tried Ostriv and it is a fun game but it can move a little slow with the detailed building aspect, putting in the foundation then the frames then the final building can be a long process if your supplies are far from the building site.

Songs of Syx looks very promising and it is one I will be watching for sure.

Banished is a great game and mods like Colonial Charter or Megamod make it even better but it is an older game and hopefully some of these new ones take the good parts of Banished and Rimworld and create the ultimate colony sim.

So far Going Medieval, Surviving the Aftermath and Endzone are filling my time nicely. Endzone is fully released and their upcoming DLC looks pretty interesting. Surviving the Aftermath according to their forums has 1 more big patch then they should be released. Based on the roadmap for Going Medieval I do not see them releasing until late 2022 unless they do a lot of big monthly content updates or scrap some of their plans.
Morkonan 2021 年 8 月 24 日 上午 11:20 
引用自 X-C0brA-X
...
So far Going Medieval, Surviving the Aftermath and Endzone are filling my time nicely. Endzone is fully released and their upcoming DLC looks pretty interesting. Surviving the Aftermath according to their forums has 1 more big patch then they should be released. Based on the roadmap for Going Medieval I do not see them releasing until late 2022 unless they do a lot of big monthly content updates or scrap some of their plans.

I was watching both Surviving the Aftermath and Endzone dev for some time. There's another game in that genre (apocalyptic colony survival whatsits) I was watching, too. Weird how they all sort of grinded up at the same time. I need to take another look at all those, thanks for the headsup!
Nameless Oblivion 2021 年 8 月 28 日 上午 5:48 
Dwarf Fortress.

That is all.
< >
正在显示第 46 - 60 条,共 61 条留言
每页显示数: 1530 50

发帖日期: 2019 年 11 月 21 日 下午 7:51
回复数: 61