Best Steam locomotive DLC?

[ArcherDooser/Roo]

What is the best steam locomotive DLC in train simulator?

[Darloman]

I suspect you are going to get several different replies to this, depending on personal preferences! Also, there's the question of what era and purpose (e.g. freight, express passenger, local passenger or shunter) you prefer.

However I'm going to stick with express passenger or MT locos and broaden out my suggestions a little to three locos. First, the context. I prefer locos that can be driven in advanced mode without a HUD and have a performance that is at least approaching that of the real loco.

So without further ado and in no particular order:

JT BR 7MT "Britannia" class. (This was originally sold by JT, but it wasn't made by JT).

JT LNER Class V2 (Another that was originally sold by JT but I think was made by someone else).

Bossman Games' LMS Rebuilt Royal Scot.

You will find the V2 listed under Routes, for some strange reason or accident!

[CrazyGecko]

The Black 5 and 8F by BMG are pretty good.

[braniff]

For me the FEF-3 by Smokebox is absolutely stunning ! Can't wait to see their Big Boy ! : )

[snipawulf04]

UK: BMG Black 5 or 8f
USA: Smokebox FEF-3.
To be fair, I wouldn't say no to Victory Works S-160 either.

[Broomwagon]

Depends what you like - 42xx is pretty good and comes with a great selection of wagons.....though I reaaly like the large prairie.

[Cyclone]

Netherfield DLC. It includes four Steam train locos bundled with it, one of which is no longer available. Does the route count?

[Brutalist Ape]

Originally posted by CrazyGecko:

The Black 5 and 8F by BMG are pretty good.

Agree.

Bossman Games steam locomotives are by far the best.

Try the Black 5, or if you want something faster, the Jubilee or Royal Scot.

https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2102449678

[gaugeglass]

Anything from the "Victory Works" collection by Pete Gillam.

[dcshoe]

"Best" is a relative term. I find Smokebox's 4-4-0 locomotives prototypical and difficult to drive, offering more of a challenge than the others I have, if that's part of "best."

[JustWentSouth]

I have no experience in British steam. However, I have countless hours driving US steam on multiple game platforms. The locomotives that Smokebox produces for Train Simulator are unparalleled. They are simply fabulous.

The more you learn, more enjoyable they become. I now take scenarios with other steam (and diesel!) engines and run them subbing in Smokebox Locos.

Visually they are stunning and fun to drive wirh a HUD. However, what’s even better are the physics and the mechanics of driving and firing in the advanced versions. It is challenging, consuming, and immersive. And, Smokebox is happy to answer any questions you might have about the intricacies of driving.

I second the votes for the FEF. However, I also love the AT&N consolidation; it’s a different and somewhat more laid back experience. The 19th century Cheyenne and Promontory locos are also excellent and give a great feel for early railroading.

Highly recommended!

[Chicken Balti]

Hello, as a real world UK steam driver, the most realistic regarding gauge glass water level and other well associated simulated operational aspects, would be the Mesh Tools Super D and Bossman Black Five. Wait for the next sale, both pricey otherwise.
The powerful 7F Super D is very well simulated and a challenge to drive on gradients, but very rewarding when fired and driven correctly (detailed study of the manual is essential).
The Bossman Black Five is also well simulated and rather more 'real world' than other TS Black Fives released over the years (again, study of the manual essential).
Best.

[Piston Pete]

Totally agree with the Bossman Black Five and Meshtools Super D (G2).

[ArcherDooser/Roo]

How did this get a reply after 3 years? That's impressive.

[Piston Pete]

Because I bought those locomotives not long ago and they are pretty amazing compared to the rest of my collection :)

[ArcherDooser/Roo]

Ah nice!

Originally posted by Piston Pete:

Because I bought those locomotives not long ago and they are pretty amazing compared to the rest of my collection :)