Kill Benhart of Jugo for his sword or not?

[lllllllll]

Will i lose any quests or do any harm to my game if i kill this guy for his sword?

[lllllllll]

@

[Vyrox]

I guess not.

[AutumnInJuly]

don't do it, if you do you won't be able to get the much better ver. of his sword after you start new game +. the better ver. can throw out energy waves!

[DarkRyok]

Killing npcs give you SIN. You will be more likely to be invaded, and I am not sure if you can get rid of it or not. However, during New game, you shouldn't be invaded that often anyways.

I would say don't do it, because the sword that he drops in New game isn't worth it. Now, during New Game Plus, one could definitely argue for killing him.

[Finna get it]

Summon him for enough boss fights and he gives you all his gear I believe. You don't really lose much from killing him though so it's up to you.

[AutumnInJuly]

don't kill him period, you have to complete certain quests with him alive in new game + to get a much better ver. of his sword.

[✠ SandMan]

the sword sucks + you won't be able to summon him at the last boss.
both him and vengarl the headless are pretty tanky

[Panic Fire]

Sin can be abstained for a hefty price from an npc. Sin increases your chance of being invaded by blue phantoms. And goes up when you kill people that you invade or npcs.

[AutumnInJuly]

The pardon doesn't take away Sin it takes away npc agro towards you if you strike them enough for them to attack you. Sin is always on you, even through new game +

[Magno]

Originalmente postado por DarkRyok:

Killing npcs give you SIN. You will be more likely to be invaded, and I am not sure if you can get rid of it or not. However, during New game, you shouldn't be invaded that often anyways.

I would say don't do it, because the sword that he drops in New game isn't worth it. Now, during New Game Plus, one could definitely argue for killing him.

You can get rid of sin. There is a dude for that right after the Skeleton Lords (Go outside, left and up the ladder)

[bnuuy]

Originalmente postado por AutumnInJuly:

don't kill him period, you have to complete certain quests with him alive in new game + to get a much better ver. of his sword.

Lies, the genuine version is a boss weapon. Killing him doesn't do anything to hinder you from getting the genuine one.

Originalmente postado por ℭuddℒy ᐯiкiηℊ:

Originalmente postado por DarkRyok:

[snip]

You can get rid of sin. There is a dude for that right after the Skeleton Lords (Go outside, left and up the ladder)

He does not remove sin, he only removes aggression.
Also, it is after the Prowling Magus & Congregation, not the Skeleton Lords.

[Timmy Squibbles]

Potential spoilers ahead...

Exhaust his dialog when you first see him and you'll be able to summon him for 4 boss fights. Prowling Magus, Looking Glass Knight, Giant Lord, and "Final Boss". Making sure to exhaust his dialog each time you see him between fights will progress his questline towards the achievement. Finishing his questline (3 of the 4 Boss fights), he will part with his gear in the Memory of Orro but you'll notice he gives you a faux version of his sword. Advancing to NG+ by using an ascetic in Brightstone Cove Tseldora after completing the game, you'll need to fight Dukes Dear Freja again to earn the Old Paledrake soul to trade for the Moonlight Greatsword with Ornifax.

[AutumnInJuly]

Ok my bad i was confused i thought he gave you the better ver. i stand corrected!

[Unas]

Out of curiousity, if you kill a person through the first playthough do they resawn when you go to NG? I thought that how it was on the original.

[Magno]

Originalmente postado por Red:

Originalmente postado por AutumnInJuly:

don't kill him period, you have to complete certain quests with him alive in new game + to get a much better ver. of his sword.

Lies, the genuine version is a boss weapon. Killing him doesn't do anything to hinder you from getting the genuine one.

Originalmente postado por ℭuddℒy ᐯiкiηℊ:

You can get rid of sin. There is a dude for that right after the Skeleton Lords (Go outside, left and up the ladder)

He does not remove sin, he only removes aggression.
Also, it is after the Prowling Magus & Congregation, not the Skeleton Lords.

Yeah, sorry I get my bosses mixed up :P