How can I replace my save game with another?

[Arthur Morrigan]

I got a new hard drive recently and transferred all my old stuff over, but for some reason MGR won't load my old save. I found my old save in My Documents and put it in My Documents on my new computer. That didn't work. I found the MGR save data in userdata in the Steam folder and replaced that. That didn't work. I've tried deleting both to see if it would at least recognize that the save wasn't there. That didn't work. I've turned off Steam Cloud and replaced everything and it still insists on using the current save instead of the one I'm trying to replace it with.

What do I have to do to get my old save back? Steam Cloud is a load of garbage that apparently never bothered to keep my old data.