Once Human going to get Lawsuit next for Monster-Capturing Mechanic?

[Marcus101RR]

Steam Link: https://steamcommunity.com/app/1623730/discussions/0/4852154959746784059/?ctp=11
Patent: https://patents.justia.com/patent/20240278129
TL;DR: https://chatgpt.com/share/66eba42c-a2b8-8003-85ba-d9bc8b835e97

So, Does this mean Once Human's Deviant Capturing Pet system is about the same as PalWorld, and Pokemon right? Don't hate me I am not saying Once Human is, infact, quite the opposite, but by the logic of Nintendo's heinous attempt to patent this in May 2024, i find this entertaining as watching twin towers get rammed again.

Discuss...cause this is just the most ridiculous thing I have EVER seen from (nintendo)..

[Island E]

Автор сообщения: Snootch

Автор сообщения: Island E

Nintendo is claiming that the game mechanics of palworld are too similar to theirs, specifically monster capturing through ball like objects is the main patent they are claiming is being infringed upon. Bunch of people in this thread don't seem to know what their really talking about when it comes to copyright and patent laws.

Even still, Nintendo can't really do anything. They don't hold the all mighty rights to be the sole creators of that style of game. It'd be as stupid as if a bunch of Fast Food places just sued one another because they all sold Cheeseburgers.

Nintendo is basically sending out junk mail at this point.

Sorry to be the one to tell you, but patent laws are dumb, I never claimed otherwise.

[Island E]

Автор сообщения: Big Boom Boom

Автор сообщения: Island E

Nintendo is claiming that the game mechanics of palworld are too similar to theirs, specifically monster capturing through ball like objects is the main patent they are claiming is being infringed upon. Bunch of people in this thread don't seem to know what their really talking about when it comes to copyright and patent laws.

LMAO, Nintendo has not claimed anything. What weed are you high on? All Nintendo has said is they are suing Palworld because they infringe on their patents. Until court documents become public, then wtf are those patents is anyone's guess.

You clearly have no idea how the world works mate.

"Nintendo filing this lawsuit for patent infringement, not copyright violation, means it has given up making the case that Palworld’s characters are similar to Pokémon’s,” said Toyo Securities analyst Hideki Yasuda. “But it shows Nintendo has more ways to stop games it doesn’t like. The company owns a lot of patents related to basic game mechanics that are used in many titles available today.” Source[finance.yahoo.com]

Link to the most likely patent. [patents.justia.com]

You clearly have no idea how the world works buddy, it's called research.

[JazzGuru]

Автор сообщения: SilvaBlad3

doesnt work like that bud, this is nothing like Nintendo games

This! For a start, it's on PC. Yeah, I still dream of being able to play Legend of Zelda on here...

[Big Boom Boom]

Автор сообщения: Island E

Автор сообщения: Big Boom Boom

LMAO, Nintendo has not claimed anything. What weed are you high on? All Nintendo has said is they are suing Palworld because they infringe on their patents. Until court documents become public, then wtf are those patents is anyone's guess.

You clearly have no idea how the world works mate.

"Nintendo filing this lawsuit for patent infringement, not copyright violation, means it has given up making the case that Palworld’s characters are similar to Pokémon’s,” said Toyo Securities analyst Hideki Yasuda. “But it shows Nintendo has more ways to stop games it doesn’t like. The company owns a lot of patents related to basic game mechanics that are used in many titles available today.” Source[finance.yahoo.com]

Link to the most likely patent. [patents.justia.com]

You clearly have no idea how the world works buddy, it's called research.

No you don't. LMAO, did you even read? They are announcing they are suing on some undisclosed (for now) patents. And you are an idiot for linking a patent registered in the US when, guess what, they are suing in Tokyo District Court. Again, all you are doing right now is making GUESSES. They haven't announced on basis what they are suing on.

Not even Palsworld knows the specific of patents they are being sued on.
"Pocketpair responded by saying it is “unaware of the specific patents we are accused of infringing” and will investigate the infringement claims."

Did you even read?

[⟨⧹▾⧸⟩]

If something like this can be lawsuit then whoever made FPS games of left click = shoot can be lawsuit?

[⟨⧹▾⧸⟩]

I dont think being able to get sued by 'copying' mechanics or interactions is valid. It takes away being able to make innovations thats inspired by previous ideas. And also prevent similar games to exist.

[Island E]

Автор сообщения: Big Boom Boom

making GUESSES.

Yes, I'm sorry if you were confused about that this entire time. I apologize for desecrating the journalistic integrity of the steam forums, our only trusted holy media. I should have disclosed that that was conjecture, I didn't mean to make to so angry, hope what ever is wrong with you gets better c:

[Neme]

Автор сообщения: Big Boom Boom

Dude, Palworld Pal design is a clear copy of Pokemon. Deviants don't look anything like that.

PLUS, in this we do not throw a round object at the thing we want to capture lol

[Big Boom Boom]

Автор сообщения: Island E

Автор сообщения: Big Boom Boom

making GUESSES.

Yes, I'm sorry if you were confused about that this entire time. I apologize for desecrating the journalistic integrity of the steam forums, our only trusted holy media. I should have disclosed that that was conjecture, I didn't mean to make to so angry, hope what ever is wrong with you gets better c:

Oh I'm sorry, I didn't realise you know you are an idiot who failed at reading comprehension. I hope you got a chance at fixing whatever is wrong with you, really. You are clearly confused and don't know how the world works.

I love how you link to an article which clearly said nobody knows which patents being involved (and Nintendo has a bazillion of them) to prove your point. It's so ironic.

[• Karu • [BR]]

They tried a lawsuit on palworld (again) because the Nintendo Corporation created a patent that copyrights any mechanic-like monster catching with a BALL on a field.
Once Human doesnt use trinkets for that, instead they contain their energy in the cradle or in a showcase containment.
I dont think it will get affected since the designs are crearly different and unique, which palworld didnt even cared much on this aspect and just shoved similar monsters that can CLEARLY reference the original idea, thats why it triggered Nintendo

Example: Temtem is just pokemon with cute graphics, its a paid game and Nintendo is chilling about it, every aspect of the game is inspired by the pokemon game, but they made their own designs and stuff (such as the capturing device, lore, and such)

[Big Boom Boom]

Автор сообщения: • Karu • BR

They tried a lawsuit on palworld (again) because the Nintendo Corporation created a patent that copyrights any mechanic-like monster catching with a BALL on a field.

Correction, this is the first time they sued Palworld. All this patent about throwing a ball to capture monster comes from some speculative tweet on X. At this stage the specific patents (note plural) they are suing on are not known to public. Palworld may have an idea now on the specifics, or they may not even know yet. Last communication is they don't.

Most industry experts say Nintendo doesn't ♥♥♥♥ around unless they know they win. And the reaction in Japan is completely different to Steam, with majority gamers agree with Nintendo.

[• Karu • [BR]]

Автор сообщения: Big Boom Boom

Автор сообщения: • Karu • BR

They tried a lawsuit on palworld (again) because the Nintendo Corporation created a patent that copyrights any mechanic-like monster catching with a BALL on a field.

Correction, this is the first time they sued Palworld. All this patent about throwing a ball to capture monster comes from some speculative tweet on X. At this stage the specific patents (note plural) they are suing on are not known to public. Palworld may have an idea now on the specifics, or they may not even know yet. Last communication is they don't.

Most industry experts say Nintendo doesn't ♥♥♥♥ around unless they know they win. And the reaction in Japan is completely different to Steam, with majority gamers agree with Nintendo.

Oh got it, thanks for the clarification, sorry if i wrote any misleads
I think i got caught by the popular gossip lmao

[Big Boom Boom]

It's most likely going to get settled out of Court and we will never know specifics of it.

[Captain Pansy]

you all fell for a clown farmer troll thread.

[Gyson]

Автор сообщения: Big Boom Boom

Dude, Palworld Pal design is a clear copy of Pokemon. Deviants don't look anything like that.

The lawsuit isn't about what the creatures look like.