Butikksiden
Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed Collection
Alle Diskusjoner Skjermbilder Kunstverk Kringkastninger Videoer Nyheter Veiledninger Anmeldelser

Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed Collection

Butikksiden
Vis statistikk:
Globale prestasjoner
✡︎☭ Farmuhan ☭✡ 5. juli 2013 kl. 16.32
This gameplay for this game is similar with HotWheel extreme racing, right?
when i see gameplay for this game, this game remins me with Hotwheel extreme racing in PS 1, i think, but maybe, this game is stealing hotwheel copyright gameplay.

is it right? if it's wrong, i say, i'm sorry

but this game is very similar with hotwheel game in PS 1

Hotwheel extreme racing in PS 1, the car can be transformed ship and plane, you can see this gameplay for it, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BHBfvO6Mmig

sinuc all stars racing transformed is similar with hotwheel extreme racing
< >
Viser 1–14 av 14 kommentarer
RazerAndBlade 5. juli 2013 kl. 16.42 
Similar only in that you can race on land and in water. Other than that it doesn't even seem close. You can't copyright the idea of switching between racing on land and on water (or air). If you could copyright those types of ideas SEGA would get sued by Nintendo for making a racing game where you get items and shoot them at other racers (Mario Kart).
#1
Omega X 5. juli 2013 kl. 16.45 
In order for this to be a copyright violation, the game has to be completely duplicated.
#2
CaptBasil 5. juli 2013 kl. 16.47 
The whole racing on land, water or through the air thing has also already been done by Diddy Kong Racing, several years before Hot Wheels Extreme Racing came out (although in that case, you couldn't switch mid-race, but still...).
Sist redigert av CaptBasil; 5. juli 2013 kl. 16.47
#3
✡︎☭ Farmuhan ☭✡ 5. juli 2013 kl. 17.36 
Opprinnelig skrevet av Paul31286:
The whole racing on land, water or through the air thing has also already been done by Diddy Kong Racing, several years before Hot Wheels Extreme Racing came out (although in that case, you couldn't switch mid-race, but still...).

ohhhh, so who is the first maker for the gameplay? diddy kong racing?



Opprinnelig skrevet av Wolfmane:
Similar only in that you can race on land and in water. Other than that it doesn't even seem close. You can't copyright the idea of switching between racing on land and on water (or air). If you could copyright those types of ideas SEGA would get sued by Nintendo for making a racing game where you get items and shoot them at other racers (Mario Kart).

hmmm, i know that, but i don't want make a game similar with that, but i want to know why that game is similar with hothweel extreme racing.


Opprinnelig skrevet av Xaionik:
In order for this to be a copyright violation, the game has to be completely duplicated.

but the gameplay is duplication, we get to call it copyright infringement?
#4
A Slipstream Sloth 5. juli 2013 kl. 17.41 
Having some issues getting into the game(technical errors), but, ironically, isn't there a hotwheels vehicle or something in the game? I thought I saw a Hotwheels copyright on the splash screen.
#5
✡︎☭ Farmuhan ☭✡ 5. juli 2013 kl. 17.47 
Opprinnelig skrevet av A Slipstream Sloth:
Having some issues getting into the game(technical errors), but, ironically, isn't there a hotwheels vehicle or something in the game? I thought I saw a Hotwheels copyright on the splash screen.


i know for that, but for this question, i ask, the gameplay is similar, can we call copyright infringement?? just it,
#6
GreenSwede 5. juli 2013 kl. 17.48 
You can't call it copyright infringement just because some gameplay aspects look similar.
#7
✡︎☭ Farmuhan ☭✡ 5. juli 2013 kl. 17.56 

Opprinnelig skrevet av Green Giant:
You can't call it copyright infringement just because some gameplay aspects look similar.

I want to ask, what conditions make that a game violates copyright?
#8
Ryotaro Dojima: Ace Detective 5. juli 2013 kl. 17.59 
Opprinnelig skrevet av fajarmf94:
Opprinnelig skrevet av Green Giant:
You can't call it copyright infringement just because some gameplay aspects look similar.

I want to ask, what conditions make that a game violates copyright?

The exact code of the game, as well as every single aspect of the gameplay, has to be copied with either no or just minimal alterations. In this case, it's a solid no. In fact, if you tried to sue SUMO, you'd just get laughed at(Possibly even by the judge). There's no case for infringement here.
Sist redigert av Ryotaro Dojima: Ace Detective; 5. juli 2013 kl. 18.00
#9
✡︎☭ Farmuhan ☭✡ 5. juli 2013 kl. 18.06 
Opprinnelig skrevet av Ryotaro Dojima: Ace Detective:
Opprinnelig skrevet av fajarmf94:

I want to ask, what conditions make that a game violates copyright?

The exact code of the game, as well as every single aspect of the gameplay, has to be copied with either no or just minimal alterations. In this case, it's a solid no. In fact, if you tried to sue SUMO, you'd just get laughed at(Possibly even by the judge). There's no case for infringement here.


ohhh, so, if the gameplay is same, that is not violates copyright???
#10
Storm 5. juli 2013 kl. 18.09 
Opprinnelig skrevet av fajarmf94:
Opprinnelig skrevet av Ryotaro Dojima: Ace Detective:

The exact code of the game, as well as every single aspect of the gameplay, has to be copied with either no or just minimal alterations. In this case, it's a solid no. In fact, if you tried to sue SUMO, you'd just get laughed at(Possibly even by the judge). There's no case for infringement here.


ohhh, so, if the gameplay is same, that is not violates copyright???

If you could copyright gameplay we would only have 1 game for every genre lol.
#11
✡︎☭ Farmuhan ☭✡ 5. juli 2013 kl. 18.13 
Opprinnelig skrevet av Kalis:
Opprinnelig skrevet av fajarmf94:


ohhh, so, if the gameplay is same, that is not violates copyright???

If you could copyright gameplay we would only have 1 game for every genre lol.

but not gameplay race, lol, the gameplay race transformer car, not racing gameplay,
#12
Ryotaro Dojima: Ace Detective 5. juli 2013 kl. 18.21 
Opprinnelig skrevet av fajarmf94:
Opprinnelig skrevet av Ryotaro Dojima: Ace Detective:

The exact code of the game, as well as every single aspect of the gameplay, has to be copied with either no or just minimal alterations. In this case, it's a solid no. In fact, if you tried to sue SUMO, you'd just get laughed at(Possibly even by the judge). There's no case for infringement here.


ohhh, so, if the gameplay is same, that is not violates copyright???

Nope. Code just has to be. Gameplay is a concept, and is shared freely. There were many final fantasy-type games when the genre was popular, but no one was sued for those. Same with rip-offs of Modern Warfare. If they used actual assets from the game, that would be one thing. But just being similar in the gameplay department is childishly weak.

Transformed has differences, by the way:

1. Airplanes
2. Actual physics (mostly effects boat controls)
3. Dynamic stages
4. Drifting
5. Stunts
6. A variety of game modes, including battle modes.
#13
✡︎☭ Farmuhan ☭✡ 5. juli 2013 kl. 18.23 
Opprinnelig skrevet av Ryotaro Dojima: Ace Detective:
Opprinnelig skrevet av fajarmf94:


ohhh, so, if the gameplay is same, that is not violates copyright???

Nope. Code just has to be. Gameplay is a concept, and is shared freely. There were many final fantasy-type games when the genre was popular, but no one was sued for those. Same with rip-offs of Modern Warfare. If they used actual assets from the game, that would be one thing. But just being similar in the gameplay department is childishly weak.

Transformed has differences, by the way:

1. Airplanes
2. Actual physics (mostly effects boat controls)
3. Dynamic stages
4. Drifting
5. Stunts
6. A variety of game modes, including battle modes.


oh i understand, thanks
#14
< >
Viser 1–14 av 14 kommentarer
Per side: 1530 50

Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed Collection > Generelle diskusjoner > Emnedetaljer
Dato lagt ut: 5. juli 2013 kl. 16.32
Innlegg: 14

Diskusjonsregler og retningslinjer