Lords Blade Ciaran?

[masterflurry]

Should I kill her? And also should I give her Artorias' soul? I regret not killing her on my last character, but I gave her the soul then too. I am doing a dex build so I don't think I'll need the sword, but I probably need if for the achievement. I feel bad about killing her, but I want that armor lol. Also if I die from her will she leave? Thanks! :D

[Erabeus]

If you don't need the Abyss sword, you can just give her the soul. Or you can just use it to gain souls. If you give it to her, you get those badass weapons, which are really good for a dex build.

If you feel bad about killing her, just get to the Kiln of the First Flame, kill her, and quickly go into NG+. That's what I did with Gough (I'm sorry, Gough, I needed your armor ;_;)

[masterflurry]

Lol yea I'll feel bad killing npcs, but I was thinking about do your method on other npcs too. I might need to kill her, I should just give her the soul and let her die happy lol. I even felt bad killing the Crestfallen Warrior lol. I am gonna end up killing Gough too :'( (Probably sound like a pansy). Once you give her the soul and get the weapons she leaves. So I might kill her... After giving her the soul so she could be at peace xD. Well thanks for the response! :D

[Hobo]

To be honest , I faced the same issue about killing Ciaran or not . In the end I just gave her the soul , and oh my , those weapons she hands out are incredible , especially the golden tracer..... However , I think you can say no to her , kill her , and still get her weapons and armor too ...

[Baellor]

Kill her, you wont feel bad after 5 minutes. Or just avoid interaction and straight up murder her. No sense giving her a soul for 2 weapons when you can kill her, get a soul, armor, and 2 awesome weapons.

[masterflurry]

True^. I think I might just do that... Well thanks for help! :D I shall do this after I murder this Sanctuary Guardian and Artorias. xD

[Tally]

I hesitated on my decision and she disappeared, probably not the best for my primarily dex. build. Still it's fun to dress in full Artorias gear with the Abyss greatsword.

Something particularly intriguing to me though is that, when you decline to give her Artorias' soul, she says it's probably what Artorias would have wanted.

Still, I'm tradint the soul for the tracers in NG+.